Skip to main content

Client memorandum | September 14, 2023

Authors: Gregg Beechey, Zac Mellor Clark, Nishkaam Paul

The third quarter of 2023, like Q1 and Q2, has seen the promulgation of regulation that is significant—or at least potentially significant—to private fund managers active in and/or marketing into Europe.

Highlighted developments this quarter include:

1  Provisional Agreement Reached on AIFMD 2

2  Private Fund Advisers Rules

3  Implementation of Consumer Duty

4  ESMA Paper on the Definition of Investment Advice under MiFID II

5  FCA Dear CEO Letter regarding Liquidity Management

6  Proposed Amendment to UK Securitization Regulation

1  Provisional Agreement Reached on AIFMD 2

As noted in our Q2 2023 Regulatory Update, the European Council, European Commission, and European Parliament entered trilogue negotiations to finalise the text of “AIFMD 2” in March with debate ongoing throughout the Swedish, and now into the Spanish, Presidency of the European Council. It was announced on 20 July that political agreement had been reached. The final text is expected to closely follow the recent compromise draft, and whilst there are various technical issues still being discussed, the expectation is that the final text will be released soon. We will provide a more detailed summary of “AIFMD 2” and the likely impact of the amendments, in particular in connection with the new loan origination regime, upon publication of the final text.

2  Private Fund Advisers Rules

As noted in our recent client alert, the United States Securities and Exchanges Commission (the “SEC”) last month adopted anticipated but controversial new rules to regulate private fund advisers. From a European perspective, the rules are not quite as intrusive as was originally feared with: (i) a key distinction between those rules that will apply to registered investment advisers and those that apply to exempt reporting advisers, (ii) recognition that the rules should not generally apply to a non-US manager’s non-US activities, and (iii) transitional provisions for certain requirements where funds qualify for “legacy status.” However, the rules have been challenged in the US courts, with six private fund trade groups acting together to sue the SEC on the basis that it has gone beyond its authority in promulgating these rules and that the rules will harm the private funds industry and the wider economy. We will continue to provide updates as the situation unfolds.

3  Implementation of Consumer Duty

The United Kingdom’s Financial Conduct Authority (the “FCA”) implemented new rules around what it calls the “consumer duty” with effect from 31 July. The consumer duty is—as the name suggests—designed with consumers in mind and sets out a higher level of consumer protection in retail financial markets for FCA-authorised firms to adhere to. The new rules will have limited impact for those managers that only admit professional investors to their funds. However, to the extent that UK-based managers allow even a small number of natural person investors to subscribe—whether team members, “friends and family,” or high net worth investors—in the absence of an exemption, there will be questions for such firms to consider. Whilst we would expect affected managers to have considered this already, the FCA recently put out an update summarizing its thoughts on what firms should be doing to prepare and which may be of interest.

4  ESMA Paper on the Definition of Investment Advice under MiFID II

The European Securities and Markets Authority (“ESMA”) recently published a supervisory briefing clarifying how the term “investment advice” is to be interpreted under the MiFID II regime, covering key questions as to what form of information could be regarded as advice, when a recommendation will be viewed as based on an investor’s personal circumstances and therefore a “personal recommendation” (a key limb of the definition of investment advice), and some perimeter matters. Strictly speaking, a supervisory briefing is intended to provide guidance to European regulators rather than directly to regulated firms, but clearly it helps provide a steer for those firms (whether EU or non-EU) advising European investors directly who may be subject to European rules on provision of investment advice.

5  FCA Dear CEO Letter regarding Liquidity Management

The FCA published a “Dear CEO” letter setting out the findings of their review of liquidity management arrangements by Authorised Fund Managers (“AFMs”). Whilst AFMs are technically managers of specific types of retail-focused fund vehicles, the FCA noted that the findings of the review are just as relevant to those private fund managers with “semi-liquid” or “semi-retail” strategies, not least because it is liquid (or semi-liquid) funds investing in illiquid (or semi-liquid) assets where liquidity management can pose the most challenges. According to the FCA, whilst there were a range of approaches and a wide disparity in “quality,” most AFMs fell short in at least some aspects with many AFMs failing to attach sufficient weight to liquidity risk management or to have in place suitably robust liquidity management mechanisms. Given the heightened regulatory focus on this, and the further focus anticipated with the coming of AIFMD 2, managers offering any sort of liquidity should consider whether they should improve their practices in light of the FCA’s findings.

6  Proposed Amendment to UK Securitization Regulation

The EU Securitization Regulation is one of the areas of European regulation that was “onshored” into UK law in connection with Brexit, thus creating the “UK Securitization Regulation.” Now, as part of the package of amendment and repeal known as the Edinburgh Reforms (as summarized in our Q1 2023 Regulatory Update) and its drive for a Smarter Regulatory Framework delivering better regulation, the UK Government has published near-final amendments to the existing legislation. Whilst intended to simplify and streamline certain elements of the existing UK regime, these amendments do have the effect of bifurcating the UK regime from that applicable in the EU. For example, the proposed UK amendments narrow the scope of the definition of “institutional investor” so that UK due diligence requirements only apply to UK AIFMs. However, this contrasts with the European Commission’s position which is that non-EU AIFMs would be encompassed within the definition of “institutional investors”.

As a result of this bifurcation, firms active in both the UK and the EU will inevitably have to comply with both the EU Securitization Regulation and the “new-and-improved” UK Securitization Regulation. As such, however welcome the changes, they are unlikely to offer firms significant relief given that they only replace the existing UK legislation.

Please contact Gregg Beechey, Zac Mellor-Clark, Nishkaam Paul, or your usual Fried Frank contact if you would like to discuss any of the above.


This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.