SEC Adopts Sweeping New Rules for Private Fund Advisers
Client memorandum | August 24, 2023
Authors: Jessica Forbes, Jonathan W. Rash, Joanna Rosenberg, Michael L. Sherman
On August 23, 2023, the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) adopted highly anticipated new rules under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 (the “Advisers Act”) that regulate private fund advisers (collectively, the “Final Rules”).[1] In response to industry comments, the SEC made significant changes to the rules proposed on February 9, 2022 (collectively, the “Proposed Rules”), and modified or eliminated some of the more controversial elements of the Proposed Rules. Notably, as explained in more detail below, the Final Rules do not include the proposed prohibition on reimbursement, indemnification, exculpation, or limitation of liability for ordinary negligence. In addition, certain parts of the Final Rules now include a “grandfathering provision” or “legacy status.” However, notwithstanding some industry-favorable changes to the proposal, we still expect the Final Rules to alter longstanding business and legal practices in the private funds industry and to significantly increase the regulatory compliance burden on private fund advisers.
This memorandum provides a high-level comparison of the Final Rules and the Proposed Rules.[2] It is based on remarks from the SEC Commissioners and Staff during the Open Meeting at which the Final Rules were adopted and also on our initial review of the Final Rule text and the 660-page Adopting Release. The Final Rules and the Adopting Release raise many complex legal and commercial questions that are not explored here.
FINAL RULES VS. PROPOSED RULES
The Proposed Rules were divided into five categories: (1) prohibited activities (renamed “restricted activities” in the Final Rules), (2) preferential treatment, (3) quarterly statements, (4) annual audits, and (5) “adviser-led secondaries” (i.e., continuation funds and other GP-led restructurings).[3] The Final Rules retain this basic organizational structure, albeit with significant changes within each of the five categories. The main differences between the Proposed Rules and the Final Rules are as follows:
1. Quarterly Statements.
- The Final Rules provide additional time for funds-of-funds to deliver quarterly statements to their investors, as well as additional time for all private funds to deliver fourth-quarter statements. Specifically, under the Final Rules, quarterly statements must be delivered to investors within 45 days after the end of the first three quarters of each fiscal year and within 90 days after the end of the fourth quarter, except that funds-of-funds have 75 days and 120 days, respectively, to deliver quarterly statements to their investors.
- The Proposed Rules would have required the quarterly statements to include the fund’s ownership percentage of each covered portfolio investment.[4] This requirement has been eliminated from the Final Rules. However, the Adopting Release states that advisers must still disclose the name of each covered portfolio investment if “necessary for an investor to understand the nature of the potential or actual conflicts associated with” payments made by the investment to the adviser or its related persons.[5]
- Under the Final Rules, performance metrics in the quarterly statements for illiquid funds must be shown with and without the impact of fund-level subscription facilities (as opposed to only without).[6]
- The Final Rules require liquid funds (i.e., any private fund that is not an illiquid fund) to disclose annual net total returns only for the past 10 fiscal years or since inception, whichever time period is shorter.
2. Annual Audits. Compliance with the annual audit requirements under the Custody Rule (including as to the auditor independence requirements of Regulation S-X) is now sufficient to comply with the Private Fund Audit Rule. This change to the Proposed Rules obviates the need for private fund advisers to comply with overlapping, and potentially conflicting, annual audit requirements.[7]
3. Adviser-Led Secondaries. Whereas the Proposed Rules required a fairness opinion, private fund advisers now have the option to provide investors participating in a continuation fund transaction with either a fairness opinion or a valuation opinion.[8]
4. Restricted Activities.
- Unlike the Proposed Rules, the Final Rules generally do not prohibit adviser activities. Rather, activities that would have been prohibited under the Proposed Rules are “restricted” and allowable under the Final Rules pursuant to certain conditional exceptions (including specific disclosure and, in some cases, consent requirements).[9]
- The SEC did not adopt the Proposed Rule that would have prohibited private fund advisers from charging a portfolio investment for monitoring, servicing, consulting, or other fees in respect of services the adviser does not, or does not reasonably expect to, provide to the portfolio investment. The SEC stated in the Adopting Release that this Rule is unnecessary “because such activity already is inconsistent with the adviser’s fiduciary duty.”[10]
- Similarly, the SEC did not adopt the Proposed Rule that would have prohibited an adviser from seeking reimbursement, indemnification, exculpation, or limitation of liability from a private fund or its investors for a breach of fiduciary duty, willful misfeasance, bad faith, negligence, or recklessness. The SEC states in the Adopting Release that this prohibition was “not necessary to achieve [its] goal to address [the] problematic practice” of advisers seeking to avoid liability for breaches of fiduciary duty and other malfeasance.[11]
5. Preferential Treatment.
- Under the Final Rules, the prohibitions on granting preferential redemption or information rights do not apply if: (i) with respect to redemption rights only, the investor is required by law to have the redemption rights; or (ii) in either case, the redemption or information rights, as applicable, are offered to all existing and future investors in the private fund and any similar pool of assets.[12]
- The Final Rules also modified the Proposed Rule requirements on the timing and content of certain notices. Specifically, the Final Rules are narrower than the Proposed Rules in that they require advisers to provide advance written notice to all prospective fund investors (before they invest in the fund) only of “any preferential treatment related to any material economic terms” provided to other investors in the same fund.[13] In addition, the Final Rules require written disclosure of all other preferential treatment (for illiquid funds, as soon as reasonably practicable following the end of the fundraising period, and for liquid funds, as soon as reasonably practicable following the investor’s investment) and annual updates of any new preferential treatment since the last notice, without regard to the nature or materiality of such preferential treatment.
6. Legacy Status. The Final Rules include limited “grandfathering” clauses that were absent from the Proposed Rules. Specifically, the Final Rules grant “legacy status” to the portions of the Preferential Treatment Rule that prohibit preferential redemption and information rights and the portions of the Restricted Activities Rule that preclude an adviser from borrowing from a private fund client or charging the fund for certain investigation fees and expenses without investor consent.[14] These “legacy provisions” apply, if at all, only when: (i) the fund has commenced operations as of the compliance date; (ii) the relevant document(s) (which can include, as applicable, the fund’s governing agreements, side letters, and loan documents) were entered into in writing prior to the compliance date; and (iii) the parties would be required to amend the relevant document(s) in order to comply with the Final Rules.
APPLICATION TO CERTAIN ADVISERS AND FUNDS
Consistent with the Proposed Rules, the Restricted Activities and Preferential Treatment Rules apply to both registered and unregistered private fund advisers, whereas the other Final Rules apply only to registered private fund advisers. The Final Rules also exempt advisers to securitized asset funds (“SAFs”),[15] including CLOs and other securitization vehicles, solely with respect to the SAFs they advise.[16] Additionally, the Adopting Release makes clear that, consistent with the SEC’s traditional view that the substantive provisions of the Advisers Act should not be applied to non-U.S. clients of a non-U.S. adviser, the Final Rules generally do not apply to a non-U.S. adviser with respect to its offshore private funds.
COMPLIANCE DATES
The compliance date for the Private Fund Audit Rule and the Quarterly Statement Rule is 18 months after publication in the Federal Register for all advisers subject to those Rules. The compliance date for the Adviser-Led Secondaries Rule, the Preferential Treatment Rule, and the Restricted Activities Rule is 12 months after publication in the Federal Register for large private fund advisers (i.e., those with $1.5 billion or more in private fund assets under management), and 18 months for smaller advisers.
Appendix
The following chart provides a high-level, section-by-section comparison of the Final Rules versus the Proposed Rules. We emphasize that this information is based on our observations of the Open Meeting at which the Final Rules were approved, and a preliminary review of the Final Rules, the Adopting Release, and the related press release and fact sheet.
|
1. Prohibited/Restricted Activities[17] (Rule 211(h)(2)-1) |
||
|
Topic |
Proposed Rule |
Final Rule |
|
Investment-Level Fees |
Prohibits charging fees for investment-level services that the adviser does not provide or reasonably expect to provide. |
Not in Final Rule. |
|
Investigation Fees and Expenses |
Prohibits charging a private fund for fees or expenses associated with an examination or investigation of the adviser or its related persons by any governmental or regulatory authority. |
Charging a private fund for fees and expenses associated with an examination is permitted only if the adviser notifies the fund investors of the fee/expense (and $ amount thereof) within 45 days of end of quarter in which charge occurs. Charging a private fund for investigation fees and expenses is permitted only with the consent of a majority in interest of the fund’s unaffiliated investors, except the adviser is flatly prohibited from charging the fund for fees or expenses related to an investigation that results in a legal sanction for violations of the Advisers Act. |
|
Compliance Fees and Expenses |
Prohibits charging a private fund for any regulatory or compliance fees or expenses of the adviser or its related persons. |
Charging a private fund for such fees and expenses is permitted only if the adviser notifies the fund investors of the fee/expense (and $ amount thereof) within 45 days of end of quarter in which charge occurs. |
|
GP Clawback |
Prohibits calculating GP clawback obligations net of taxes. |
GP clawbacks net of taxes are permitted so long as the adviser discloses the pre-tax and post-tax amount of the clawback to investors within 45 days of end of quarter in which the clawback occurs. |
|
Standard of Liability |
Prohibits reimbursement, indemnification, exculpation, or limitation of liability by a private fund or its investors for a breach of fiduciary duty, willful misfeasance, bad faith, negligence, or recklessness. |
Not in Final Rule. |
|
Fee and Expense Allocations |
Prohibits charging or allocating fees and expenses related to a portfolio investment on a non-pro rata basis when multiple affiliated private funds have invested (or propose to invest) in the same portfolio investment. |
Charging or allocating such fees and expenses on a non-pro rata basis is permitted if the allocation (i) is fair and equitable; (ii) the adviser provides advance written notice to fund investors of the non-pro rata allocation; and (iii) the adviser provides a description of how the non-pro rata allocation is fair and equitable under the circumstances. |
|
Adviser Borrowings |
Prohibits an adviser from borrowing money, securities, or other private fund assets, or receiving a loan or an extension of credit, from a private fund client. |
Such borrowings are permitted if the adviser (i) notifies investors of material terms of borrowing; and (ii) obtains written consent from at least a majority in interest of the unaffiliated investors. |
|
2. Preferential Treatment (Rule 211(h)(2)-3) |
||
|
Topic |
Proposed Rule |
Final Rule |
|
Redemption Rights |
Prohibits granting an investor in a private fund or substantially similar pool of assets the ability to redeem its interest on terms that the adviser reasonably expects to have a material, negative effect on other investors in that private fund or in a substantially similar pool of assets. |
Permitted only if ability to redeem is required by applicable law or if adviser offers same rights to all investors. |
|
Portfolio Information |
Prohibits providing portfolio information to any investor if the adviser reasonably expects that providing the information would have a material, negative effect on other investors in that private fund or in a substantially similar pool of assets. |
Permitted only if adviser offers same rights to all investors. |
|
Other Preferential Treatment |
Prohibits providing any other preferential treatment to any private fund investor unless the adviser provides written notice of specific information regarding such preferential treatment to prospective investors (prior to their investment in the private fund) and current investors (at least annually). |
Substantially similar to Proposed Rule, except disclosure to prospective investors only applies to “material economic terms” and timing of disclosure to existing investors differs as between illiquid funds and liquid funds. |
|
3. Quarterly Statements (Rule 211(h)(1)-2) |
||
|
Topic |
Proposed Rule |
Final Rule |
|
Basic Requirements |
Mandatory quarterly statements for each private fund that has at least two full calendar quarters of operating results, with statements distributed to investors within 45 days of each calendar quarter end, unless such quarterly statement is prepared and distributed by another person. |
Substantially similar to Proposed Rule, except all funds have 90 days to produce fourth-quarter statements and funds-of-funds have 75 days to provide statements for Q1-Q3 and 120 days to produce statements for Q4. |
|
Fund-Level Reporting |
Each quarterly statement must include a table showing (i) all fees and expenses paid or allocated to the adviser and its related persons by the fund (presented both before and after any fee offsets); (ii) all other fees and expenses paid by the fund, with separate line items for org costs, accounting, legal, admin, audit, tax, due diligence, and travel (presented both before and after any fee offsets); and (iii) any fee offsets carried forward to reduce future payments or allocations to the adviser or its related persons. |
Substantially similar to Proposed Rule. |
|
Investment-Level Reporting |
Each quarterly statement must include a separate table showing (i) all investment-level fees and expenses allocated or paid to the adviser and its related persons (both before and after fee offsets); and (ii) the private fund’s ownership percentage of each such investment, with brief descriptions of the investments. |
Substantially similar to Proposed Rule, except Final Rule eliminates requirement to disclose ownership percentage of underlying investments. |
|
Performance Information (closed-ended funds) |
Each quarterly statement must include the following performance measures shown since inception and computed without the impact of any fund-level subscription facilities: (i) gross IRR and gross MOIC; (ii) net IRR and net MOIC; (iii) gross IRR and gross MOIC for realized and unrealized portions of portfolio, shown separately; and (iv) statement of contributions and distributions. |
Substantially similar to Proposed Rule, except performance is required to be shown both with and without impact of any fund-level sub lines (as opposed to only without). |
|
Performance Information (open-ended funds) |
Each quarterly statement must include (i) annual net returns for each calendar year since inception; (ii) average annual net total returns over 1-, 5-, and 10-year periods; and (iii) cumulative net total returns for current year. |
Substantially similar to Proposed Rule, except annual net returns only need to be shown for the past 10 years or since inception, whichever time period is shorter. |
|
4. Annual Audits (Rule 206(4)-10) |
||
|
Topic |
Proposed Rule |
Final Rule |
|
Basic Requirements |
Audited financial statements must be prepared annually and upon liquidation by an independent public accountant in accordance with U.S. GAAP (or, in the case of foreign private funds, reconciled with U.S. GAAP) and distributed to investors promptly. |
Substantially similar to Proposed Rule, except that Final Rule clarifies that requirements can be satisfied by complying with the Custody Rule (including the auditor independence requirements of Regulation S-X). |
|
SEC Notification |
Independent auditor must agree with adviser in writing to notify SEC (i) promptly upon issuing a private fund audit that contains a modified opinion and (ii) within four business days of resignation or dismissal from, or other termination of, the engagement, or upon removing itself or being removed from consideration for being reappointed. |
Not in Final Rule. |
|
Exception for Funds and Advisers Not in Control Relationship |
Prohibits adviser from providing investment advice to any private fund it does not control unless the adviser takes all reasonable steps to cause the private fund to undergo an audit that meets all the requirements of this rule. |
Same as Proposed Rule. |
|
5. Adviser-Led Secondaries (Rule 211(h)(2)-2) |
||
|
Topic |
Proposed Rule |
Final Rule |
|
Fairness Opinion and Relationship Summary |
Unlawful to undertake an adviser-led secondary transaction with respect to any private fund unless the adviser, prior to closing, (i) obtains and distributes to investors a fairness opinion from an independent opinion provider and (ii) prepares and distributes to investors a written summary of any material business relationship between the adviser or its related persons and the independent opinion provider over the past two years. |
Substantially similar to Proposed Rule, except that adviser has option to obtain and distribute a valuation opinion in lieu of a fairness opinion. |
[1] See Private Fund Advisers; Documentation of Registered Investment Adviser Compliance Reviews, Release No. IA-6368 (Aug. 23, 2023) (hereinafter the “Adopting Release”). For purposes of the Final Rules, a private fund adviser is any adviser to an issuer (other than a “securitized asset fund”) that would be an investment company as defined in section 3 of the Investment Company Act of 1940 but for section 3(c)(1) or 3(c)(7) of that Act.
[2] A chart comparing the Proposed Rules with the Final Rules is included as an appendix to this memorandum.
[3] For a detailed review of the Proposed Rules, see SEC Proposes Sweeping New Rules and Amendments to Existing Rules Applicable to Private Fund Advisers.
[4] “Covered portfolio investment” means “a portfolio investment that allocated or paid the investment adviser or its related persons portfolio investment compensation during the reporting period.” Rule 211(h)(1)-1.
[5] Adopting Release at 101. Relatedly, the Final Rules require disclosure of portfolio investment compensation largely as proposed, notwithstanding significant industry pushback on the proposal. See Adopting Release at 95–101. “Portfolio investment compensation” means “any compensation, fees, and other amounts allocated or paid to the investment adviser or any of its related persons by the portfolio investment attributable to the private fund’s interest in such portfolio investment, including, but not limited to, origination, management, consulting, monitoring, servicing, transaction, administrative, advisory, closing, disposition, directors, trustees or similar fees or payments.” Rule 211(h)(1)-1.
[6] “Illiquid fund” means “a private fund that: (1) [i]s not required to redeem interests upon an investor’s request; and (2) [h]as limited opportunities, if any, for investors to withdraw before termination of the fund.” Rule 211(h)(1)-1.
[7] Separately, the SEC reopened the comment period for the proposed Safeguarding Rule (which would replace the current Custody Rule, if adopted) for an additional 60 days.
[8] “Valuation opinion” means “a written opinion stating the value (as a single amount or a range) of any assets being sold as part of an adviser-led secondary transaction.” Rule 211(h)(1)-1.
[9] However, charging investigation-related expenses to a fund is prohibited to the extent the investigation results in a sanction for violation of the Advisers Act. Similarly, the non-pro rata allocation of investment-related expenses is permissible only if, in addition to specific disclosure and consent, such allocation is fair and equitable.
[10] Adopting Release at 251.
[11] Adopting Release at 256–61. In a footnote to his prepared statement, Chair Gensler observed that “[t]he adopting release states the SEC’s existing view that seeking indemnification for an adviser breaching its federal fiduciary duty operates as a waiver and is invalid under the Advisers Act.” We continue to evaluate the Adopting Release’s treatment of this issue.
[12] “Similar pool of assets” means “a pooled investment vehicle (other than an investment company registered under the Investment Company Act of 1940, a company that elects to be regulated as such, or a securitized asset fund) with substantially similar investment policies, objectives, or strategies to those of the private fund managed by the investment adviser or its related persons.” Rule 211(h)(1)-1.
[13] Adopting Release at 292 (emphasis added).
[14] Legacy status is not available with respect to the disclosure portions of the Preferential Treatment Rule or the restriction on charging/allocating expenses related to investigations that result in a sanction for violations of the Advisers Act.
[15] “Securitized asset fund” means “any private fund whose primary purpose is to issue asset backed securities and whose investors are primarily debt holders.” Rule 211(h)(1)-1. This definition matches the definition of the same term in Forms ADV and PF.
[16] After considering industry comments on the unduly broad scope of the Proposed Rules, the SEC concluded that SAFs are “sufficiently distin[ct] from other types of private funds to warrant” exclusion from the Final Rules. Adopting Release at 54. However, the SEC noted that it will “continue to consider whether any additional regulatory action may be necessary with respect to SAF advisers in the future.” Id. at n.154.
[17] In recognition of the Final Rule’s approach of generally allowing these activities where disclosure and/or consent is provided or other conditions are met, the SEC relabeled this portion of the Final Rules as “Restricted Activities.”
This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.