Skip to main content

Client memorandum | June 29, 2023

Authors: Gregg Beechey, Zac Mellor-Clark, Nishkaam Paul

The second quarter of 2023 saw a significant number of regulatory developments that impact, or have the potential to impact, private fund managers active in and marketing into Europe.

Notable developments during this period, outlined at a high level in this memo, included (but were by no means limited to):

  1. The progression of amendments to the Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive (“AIFMD 2”) to trilogue.
  2. The entry into force of the revised European Long-Term Investment Funds Regulation (“ELTIF 2.0”), and the publication by the European Securities and Markets Authority (“ESMA”) of a consultation paper setting out draft Level 2 regulatory technical standards related to ELTIF 2.0 (“RTS”).
  3. The publication of the European Commission’s Retail Investment Strategy (“RIS”) proposal.
  4. Various developments related to the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (the “SFDR”).
  5. Feedback from the UK Financial Conduct Authority (“FCA”) on its Sustainability Disclosure Requirements (“SDR”).

1      AIFMD 2 enters into trilogues

As noted in our previous Q1 2023 Regulatory Update[1], on 24 January 2023, the European Parliament announced it had reached political agreement on AIFMD 2. The European Council, the European Commission (“Commission”) and the European Parliament subsequently entered the trilogues on 8 March 2023.

It had been hoped that the trilogue negotiations would conclude before the tenure of the Swedish Presidency of the European Council comes to an end on 30 June 2023. However, reports from Brussels indicate that agreement has not been reached, and disagreements remain, principally on the issue of delegation, the perimeter of and conditions under the AIF loan origination regime, and undue costs (amongst other issues).

The trilogues will now resume under the Spanish Presidency of the European Council, whose tenure runs from 1 July 2023 until 31 December 2023. It seems unlikely there will be another trilogue meeting until September 2023. It remains to be seen what consequences this delay will have on the outcome of the negotiations.

2      ELTIF 2.0 and RTS

ELTIF 2.0 entered into force on 9 April 2023. ELTIF 2.0 makes various technical changes to the ELTIF Regulation in order to address perceived shortcomings of, and lack of market engagement with, the current regime which, despite originally launching with great fanfare, has seen relatively limited uptake.

The publication of ELTIF 2.0 comes at an interesting time, with an increasing number of private managers, who have historically confined their marketing within the EU to professional investors, exploring ways of accessing capital from retail investors. Please refer to our previous Client Memorandum[2] for further information.

ELTIF 2.0 mandates ESMA to develop draft RTS on a number of key topics, including the redemption policy and life of an ELTIF, required costs disclosure and the matching mechanism. On 23 May 2023, ESMA launched a consultation paper which included an initial draft of the RTS.

The RTS are of particular industry focus, as they will determine, amongst other things, the viability of open-ended ELTIFs under ELTIF 2.0. The general consensus amongst practitioners in this space appears to be, however, that the initial draft RTS are not fit for purpose, and require a lot of work in order for an open-ended ELTIF to be a viable model.

The consultation period closes on 24 August 2023, with the final RTS due by 10 January 2024 (on which date changes under ELTIF 2.0 come into effect).

3      Publication of the RIS

On 24 May 2023, the Commission published its greatly anticipated RIS, which comprises a proposed Directive which would amend the AIFMD and the Markets in Financial Instruments Directive (“MiFID”) (amongst other Directives), and a proposed Regulation which would amend the Packaged Retail and Insurance-based Investment Products Regulation (amongst other Regulations).

The purported aim of the package is to create safer conditions to grow retail investor participation in capital markets (one of the Commission’s three key objective of the 2020 Capital Markets Union Action Plan). However, a number of important amendments seem to go further than the original policy aim, and apply equally in a professional client context.

The RIS is significant both in its breadth and potential industry impact. From the perspective of a European private fund manager, there are a number of proposals in the RIS to watch. This includes amendments to the AIFMD to introduce a new “undue costs” regime, which will regulate management fees and performance fees (amongst other things) by imposing value assessments. There is crossover here with AIFMD 2. Also of note is the proposed strengthening of the MiFID inducements rules, whereby (i) portfolio managers would no longer be permitted, in the course of providing portfolio management services to a client, to receive (or pay) fees, commissions or non-monetary benefits from a third party, even if they don’t retain them and instead pass them on to the client (which has the potential to impact deal economics); and (ii) persons providing reception and transmission of orders or execution of orders to or on behalf of retail clients (which may include fund distributors) would no longer be able to receive (or pay) fees, commissions or non-monetary benefits, in the course of providing such services, from third-party manufacturers (which has the potential to disrupt current fund distribution models in Europe).

It is not all bad news, however. The RIS proposes amendments to the MiFID elective professional client criteria. Though, as a matter of principle, reform of these criteria is encouraging for the private funds industry, the amendments proposed remain biased (like the existing criteria) towards day traders and are unlikely to be overly helpful if implemented as drafted. The RIS also falls short of imposing a complete ban on the receipt of inducements by investment advisers, as was previously feared.

The deadline for feedback on the proposal is 31 July 2023. The current proposal represents, however, merely the start of a long legislative journey. The detail of the RIS is liable to change, potentially significantly, as a result of political negotiations and feedback from stakeholders. It may be 2026 before the relevant rules under consultation actually come into effect.

4      SFDR

As noted in our previous Q1 2023 Regulatory Update[3], the Level 2 regulatory technical standards (the “SFDR RTS”) underlying and fleshing out the SFDR have applied from 1 January 2023, and managers of in-scope products must now ensure that their disclosures (including pre-contractual disclosures) and reporting (including annual reports in respect of the 2022 financial year) comply with these new requirements.

In addition, market approach in respect of the SFDR has continued to develop during the course of Q1 2023, and regulators (both at the EU and Member State level) have continued to develop and clarify the regime, both by issuing guidance and consulting on future changes. Key updates include the following:

Commission Decision

As an entirely new disclosure regime, addressing the dynamic and evolving issue of sustainability, the SFDR has posed a number of interpretative issues and some teething pains. In order to address some of the former, the Commission published a ‘Commission Decision’ setting out responses to questions it has received from the three European Supervisory Authorities (the ESMA, the European Banking Authority and the European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority or, collectively, the “ESAs”), and simultaneously updating its previously published responses.

While the new guidance is set out in a rather unintuitive in manner (with new responses in one annex, updates to old responses in another, and no consolidated document), it does provide useful clarity on a variety of issues. These include the application of the 500 employee principal adverse impact (“PAI”) threshold at entity level, clarification of what ‘consider’ means in the context of PAIs, guidance in respect of a number of other SFDR definitions, and what investments would constitute ‘sustainable investments’.

National developments

Under the SFDR, the Commission was required to evaluate the functioning of the regime by the end of 2022. The Commission has confirmed that this assessment, described as ‘comprehensive’, is underway, and it was intended that a consultation (distinct from the ESAs’ consultation referenced below) would be published in the first half of 2023. In the meantime, a number of national competent authorities have issued their own proposals to the Commission in order to feed into this process. The French Autorité des Marchés Financiers, in particular, has proposed that the Commission prescribe certain minimum requirements that products would need to meet in order to qualify under Article 8 and Article 9 of the SFDR to prevent greenwashing and ensure investor protection.

Consultation on updates to SFDR RTS

The ESAs are already consulting on possible updates to the SFDR RTS. The consultation[4], published on 12 April 2023, is intended to broaden the disclosure framework and address technical issues which have emerged since the SFDR was first published. Amongst other proposals, the ESAs are seeking input on the simplification of pre-contractual and periodic disclosure templates, the enhancement of social indicators for PAIs, and more specific disclosure requirements pertaining to the ‘do not significantly harm’ assessment in the context of ‘sustainable investments’. The consultation is open until 4 July 2023. A final report is expected in October 2023.

5      FCA SDR and Investment Labels

The UK’s answer to the SFDR, the SDR, continues to take shape behind the scenes. Following the conclusion of its consultation in January 2023, the FCA announced[5] that it had received extensive feedback from various stakeholders, including the British Venture Capital Association, the International Capital Markets Association, the Investment Association and the Principles for Responsible Investment. Respondents were broadly supportive of the proposals, but raised a number of valid concerns regarding the practical challenges that they may pose.

As a result, the FCA will consider its approach, in particular, to the application of marketing restrictions, and will clarify the criteria for the use of certain sustainability labels by financial products, asset classes and strategies. While the FCA noted that it will seek ‘international coherence with other regimes’, it remains likely that managers managing and/or marketing products in both the UK and the EU will be subject to two distinct regimes and operational requirements.

In terms of timing, the FCA intends to publish its policy statement on the SDR and the labelling regime in Q3 2023, representing a slight delay, to permit it to consider the significant response. It is expected that the SDR and the labelling rules will take effect from Q3 2024.

It is worth noting that the SDR and the related labelling regime are seeking similar outcomes to the new Consumer Duty (coming into effect 31 July 2023) by providing consumers with the information they need to enable them to make informed decisions about the products in question.


This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.