Skip to main content

Treasury Issues Proposed Rule to Implement Outbound Investment Regime

Client memorandum | June 24, 2024

Authors: Michael T. Gershberg, Gregory Bernstein

On June 21, 2024, the U.S. Treasury Department issued a Proposed Rule to implement President Biden October's 2023 Executive Order (“EO”) establishing a regime to restrict certain types of outbound investment to China. The Proposed Rule builds upon and adopts the same structure as an earlier Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (“ANPRM”) -- the notification, and in some instances the outright prohibition, of certain investments by U.S. persons in Chinese companies (including Hong Kong and Macau) that are engaged in specific activities related to semiconductors and microelectronics, quantum computing, and artificial intelligence (“AI”). Treasury seeks public comments on the Proposed Rule through August 4, 2024, including on several provisions for which Treasury provides alternative formulations or parameters. The investment restrictions will only apply prospectively and will not take effect until Treasury publishes a final rule.

An summary of the proposed rule is below, along with a description of the main changes from the ANPRM. Treasury has also set up an Outbound Investment Program website that includes a fact sheet on the Proposed Rule.

I. The Structure of the Proposed Rule

The EO mandates the creation of a program to will require U.S. persons to provide notification of certain investments that “may contribute to the threat to the national security of the United States,” and prohibit U.S. persons from engaging in certain investments that “pose a particularly acute national security threat” to the United States. The general structure of the Proposed Rule regulates the involvement of a U.S. person in connection with a covered transaction involving or resulting in the establishment of a covered foreign person. The proposed definition of covered foreign person is tied to that person’s relationship to a “country of concern” (i.e., China, Hong Kong, or Macau) and involvement in a covered activity related to semiconductors and microelectronics, quantum computing, or AI. A covered transaction may either be prohibited or subject to a notification requirement, depending on the specific covered activity conducted by the covered foreign person.

The outline of the outbound investment regime was described in our prior alert on the EO and ANPRM. The main changes that the Proposed Rule makes to the ANPRM include the following, which are described further below:

  • The scope of covered transactions involving AI systems, which is proposed to include both a technical parameter and end-use parameter, as well as limited changes to the scope of covered activity regarding semiconductors and quantum computing.
  • A knowledge standard is included to describe the knowledge a U.S. person must have regarding the facts of a particular transaction in order to trigger its obligations under the Proposed Rule.
  • A clarification of the circumstances under which U.S. persons are prohibited from “knowingly directing” certain transactions by non-U.S. persons.
  • A new exception for transactions involving third country persons if Treasury has determined that country has similar measures aimed at outbound investments.
  • A clarification of circumstances under which limited partner investments in private funds are covered or exempt.

II. Covered Transactions

These scope of covered transactions would include the following by a U.S. person, directly or indirectly:

  1. acquisition of an equity interest or contingent equity interest in a covered foreign person;
  2. financing of a covered foreign person through a debt instrument that is (i) convertible to equity, or (ii) affords the U.S. person the right to make management decisions or appoint a board member;
  3. conversion of a contingent equity interests or convertible debt instrument into an equity interest in a covered foreign person;
  4. greenfield investments that could result in the establishment of a covered foreign person;
  5. acquisition of a limited partner interest in a non-U.S. private fund that undertakes a transaction that would be a covered transaction if undertaken a U.S. person; and
  6. the establishment of a joint venture that will engage in covered activity.

The obligations of U.S. persons when conducting the transactions above are based on the knowledge of the U.S. person at the time of the transaction. In other words, this will not be a strict liability regime.  Rather, an investment would only constitute a covered transaction if the U.S. person has knowledge at the time of the relevant facts and circumstances that would make the investment covered (e.g., that an investment target is a covered foreign person or that a foreign investment fund is likely to invest in a covered foreign person). The Proposed Rule clarifies that knowledge in this context includes (i) actual knowledge that a fact or circumstance exists or is substantially certain to occur; (ii) an awareness of a high probability of a fact or circumstance’s existence or future occurrence; and (iii) reason to know of a fact or circumstance’s existence.  Since this is a broad knowledge standard that requires reasonable due diligence, the Proposed Rule further states that an inquiry into the existence of such knowledge “will be made based on information a U.S. person had or could have had through a reasonable and diligent inquiry,” including the following facts:

  1. The inquiry a U.S. person, its legal counsel, or its representatives have made on behalf of the U.S. person regarding an investment target or relevant counterparty, including questions asked of the investment target or relevant counterparty, as of the time of the transaction;
  2. The contractual representations or warranties the U.S. person has obtained or attempted to obtain from the investment target or relevant counterparty with respect to the determination of a transaction’s status as a covered transaction and an investment target or relevant counterparty’s status as a covered foreign person;
  3. The effort by the U.S. person at the time of the transaction to obtain available non-public information relevant to the determination of a transaction’s status as a covered transaction and an investment target or relevant counterparty’s status as a covered foreign person, and the efforts undertaken by the U.S. person to obtain and review such information;
  4. Available public information, the efforts undertaken by the U.S. person to obtain and review such information, and the degree to which other information available to the U.S. person at the time of the transaction is consistent or inconsistent with such publicly available information;
  5. Whether the U.S. person, its legal counsel, or its representatives have purposefully avoided learning or sharing relevant information;
  6. The presence or absence of warning signs, which may include evasive responses or non-responses from an investment target or relevant counterparty to questions or a refusal to provide information, contractual representations, or warranties; and
  7. The use of public and commercial databases to identify and verify relevant information of an investment target or relevant counterparty.

The Proposed Rule goes into significant detail on the contours of the knowledge requirement, indicating the Treasury will expect U.S. persons to conduct robust due diligence before engaging in a foreign investment transaction. Notably, the Proposed Rule also requires a post-transaction notification if a U.S. person subsequently obtains knowledge that a transaction already conducted was a covered transaction.

III. Covered Foreign Persons

The term “covered foreign person” is defined to include (a) person of a country of concern that engages in a covered activity, and (b) any other person that directly or indirectly holds any voting interest, board seat, or equity interest in such person or holds any power to direct or cause the direction of the management or policies of such person; and where the person derives more than 50% of its revenue or net income or incurs more than 50% of its capital expenditures or operating expenses from such person. This definition was expanded since the ANPRM and would expand the scope of this regime to cover a range of entities that hold an interest in a Chinese company engaged in a covered activity.

In turn, the term “person of a country of concern” is defined to include the following:

  1. Chinese citizens and permanent residents (who are not also U.S. citizens or permanent residents);
  2. entities with a principal place of business, headquarters, incorporated or other organized under the laws of China;
  3. the Chinese government, including any agency or instrumentality, any person acting for or on behalf of the government, or any entity with respect to which the government holds at least 50% voting interest, voting power of the board, or equity interest, or otherwise possesses the power to direct or cause the direction of the management and policies of such entity; and
  4. any entity in which the above persons, individually or in the aggregate, directly or indirectly, hold at least 50% of outstanding voting interest, voting power of the board, or equity interest.

IV. U.S. Persons

The Proposed Rule applies to investments by U.S. persons, which is defined similarly to U.S. sanctions programs:  U.S. citizens, lawful permanent residents, entities organized under the laws of the United States or any jurisdiction within the United States, including any foreign branch of any such entity, and any person in the United State.

In addition, the EO directs Treasury to prohibit U.S. persons from “knowingly directing transactions” if such transactions would be prohibited if engaged in by a U.S. person. This mandate is similar to the concept of “facilitation” in U.S. economic sanctions—i.e., that covered transactions made by non-U.S. persons may also be effectively restricted unless there is no U.S. nexus. In this regard, Treasury proposes to define “knowingly directs” such that a U.S. person “has authority, individually or as part of a group, to make or substantially participate in decisions on behalf of a non-U.S. person, and exercises that authority to direct, order, decide upon, or approve a transaction.” Such authority exists when a U.S. person is an officer, director, or senior advisor, or otherwise possesses senior-level authority at a non-U.S. person, unless the U.S. person recuses themselves from a relevant investment.

As a practical matter, this would mean that non-U.S. businesses, including private funds organized outside of the United States, may be within scope of the outbound investment regime if U.S. persons serve as officers, managers, or senior employees and are involved in decision-making related to notifiable or prohibited transactions.

Notably, the Proposed Rule also imposes an affirmative obligation on U.S. persons, including U.S. parent companies and funds, to “take all reasonable steps” to prevent any transaction by a foreign entity controlled by such U.S. person if it would be prohibited if directly engaged in by a United States person. In determining whether a U.S. person took all reasonable steps to prevent such a transaction, it will evaluate, among other things, (i) binding agreements between the U.S. person and the controlled foreign entity, (ii) internal policies, procedures, and guidelines, (iii) periodic training, (iv) internal controls, (v) testing and auditing, and (vi) the exercise of governance or shareholder rights.

V. Exemptions

In the Proposed Rule, Treasury provides a number of exemptions from the definition of covered transaction, including:  

  1. investments in publicly traded securities (denominated in any currency, and that trades on a securities exchange or “over-the-counter” in any jurisdiction);
  2. investment in securities issued by an “investment company” or business development company;
  3. passive investment of a certain size as a limited partner in a private fund;
  4. a full buyout of all country of concern ownership of an entity, such that the entity would not constitute a covered foreign person following the transaction;
  5. certain intracompany transaction between a U.S. parent and a majority-controlled subsidiary to support ongoing operations or other non-covered activities;
  6. a transaction fulfilling a binding, uncalled, capital commitment entered into prior to August 9, 2023;
  7. acquisition by a member of a lending syndicate of a voting interest in a covered foreign person upon default if the U.S. person cannot initiate any action vis-à-vis the debtor and does not have a lead role in the syndicate; and
  8. certain transactions involving a third-country person if the Treasury determines that the country is addressing national security concerns posed by outbound investment and the transaction is of a type for which associated national security concerns are likely to be adequately addressed by the actions of that country or territory.

With respect to the LP exemption, the Proposed Rule provides two alternative criteria: (1) the investment is passive and the capital commitment is 50% or less of the fund’s total assets under management (or the investor receives a binding contractual commitment that its capital will not be used for a prohibited investment), and (2) the capital commitment is $1 million or less. The latter option would likely exempt more LP investments and may be simpler to implement, although Treasury is still considering these alternatives.

VI. Covered Activity

The Proposed Rule specifies the covered activities that would result in an investment being notifiable or prohibited.  Notably, Treasury provides alternative formulations or parameters in certain provisions, and requests public comments on which alternatives to include in the final rule. These covered activities were purposefully drafted to be specific and limited such that they post a risk to U.S. national security.

 

Prohibited Investments

Notifiable Investments

Semiconductors & Microelectronics

Investments in entities that are engaged in:

  • The development or production of electronic design automation software designed to be exclusively used for integrated circuit design.
  • The development or production of certain fabrication and advanced packaging equipment.
  • The design, fabrication, and packing of integrated circuits that meet or exceed certain criteria.
  • The development, sale, installation or production of certain supercomputer enabled by advanced integrated circuits.

Investments in entities that are engaged in:

  • The design, fabrication, or packaging of integrated circuits for which transactions involving U.S. persons are not otherwise prohibited.

Quantum Information Technologies

Investments in entities that are engaged in:

  • The development of a quantum computer or production of critical components such as dilution refrigerator or two-stage pulse tube cryocooler.
  • The development of a quantum sensing platform designed or military end uses, government intelligence, or mass-surveillance end uses.
  • The development or production of a quantum network or quantum communication system designed to be exclusively used for networking to scale up the capabilities of quantum computers, secure communications, or other application that has any military, government intelligence, or mass-surveillance end use.

None proposed.

Artificial Intelligence

Investments in entities that are engaged in:

  • The development of an AI system[1] that is designed to be exclusively used for military, government intelligence, or mass-surveillance end uses.
  • The development of an AI system that is trained using a quantity of computing power above certain thresholds.

Investments in entities that are engaged in:

  • The development of an AI system that is designed to be used for any military, government intelligence, or mass-surveillance end uses.
  • The development of an AI system intended to be used for cybersecurity applications, digital forensics tools, and penetration testing tools, or the control of robotic systems
  • The development of an AI system that is trained using a quantity of computing power above certain thresholds.

VII. Penalties

The Treasury Department will have the authority to nullify, void, or otherwise compel the divestment of any prohibited transaction entered into after the effective date of the regulations. Civil and criminal penalties under IEEPA will also be available for violations of the final rule.  The Proposed Rule also provides for a voluntary self-disclosure program.

VIII. Key Takeaways

The Proposed Rule is the next step in the U.S. government’s efforts to regulate outbound investments that may affect national security. While the outbound investment screening regime has been referred to in media accounts as a sort of “reverse CFIUS,” in practice it will bear greater similarity to U.S. sanctions programs.  In particular, it will apply to U.S. persons, including U.S. person managers of foreign companies and foreign subsidiaries of U.S. companies.  On the other hand, this system will not review and approve specific transactions as CFIUS does. Rather, U.S. persons are responsible for determining whether a given transaction is prohibited or notifiable, and submitting the notification if applicable. While the Proposed Rule applies to a limited number of industries, U.S. companies, particularly private funds that make technology investments, should closely monitor the rulemaking process to ensure that they are ready to comply with regulations once they are effective.



[1] The Proposed Rule defines “AI system” as (a) a machine-based system that can, for a given set of human-defined objectives, make predictions, recommendations, or decisions influencing real or virtual environments—i.e., a system that uses data inputs to: (1) Perceive real and virtual environments; (2) Abstract such perceptions into models through automated or algorithmic statistical analysis; and (3) Use model inference to make a classification, prediction, recommendation, or decision; and (b) any data system, software, hardware, application, tool, or utility that operates in whole or in part using a system described in (a).


This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.