Skip to main content

President Biden Issues Long-Awaited Executive Order to Create Outbound Investment Regime

International Trade and Investment Alert™ | August 17, 2023

Authors: Michael T. Gershberg, Gregory Bernstein

On August 9, 2023, President Biden issued an Executive Order (“the EO”) to establish a regime restricting certain types of outbound investment to China. The EO directs the U.S. Department of the Treasury to promulgate rules that would require the notification of, and in some instances would outright prohibit, certain investments by U.S. persons in Chinese companies that are engaged in specific activities related to semiconductors and microelectronics, quantum computing, and artificial intelligence. Pursuant to the EO, the Treasury Department has issued an Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (“ANPRM”) that provides preliminary information on how Treasury may implement the EO and seeks public comments until September 28, 2023. Since the EO is not self-executing, the new regime will not take effect until Treasury’s regulations are finalized—presumably in 2024.  Treasury expects that the investment restrictions will only apply prospectively.  While the restrictions currently will only apply to China (including Hong Kong and Macau), future executive orders could potentially expand the regime to other “countries of concern.”

Many details of the outbound investment screening regime are not yet finalized and the definitions and other rules included in the ANPRM are subject to further revision following the notice-and-comment rule-making process. Treasury has also set up an Outbound Investment Program website that includes a fact sheet. An overview of the EO and the ANPRM is provided below.

The Outbound Investment Executive Order and ANPRM

The EO tasks the Treasury Department—in consultation with the U.S. Department of Commerce and other relevant executive agencies—to issue regulations that will require U.S. persons to provide notification of certain investments (notifiable transactions) and prohibit U.S. persons from engaging in certain investments (prohibited transactions). In broad terms, the EO states that notifiable transactions will include those that “may contribute to the threat to the national security of the United States,” whereas prohibited transactions will include those that “pose a particularly acute national security threat” to the United States. We describe below the current framework for this new regime—including who the law applies to, what types of transactions are in-scope, and which Chinese persons are covered.

Covered Transactions

These covered transactions include the following by a U.S. person, directly or indirectly:

  1. acquisition of an equity interest or contingent equity interest in a covered foreign person;
  2. financing, through convertible debt instruments, of a covered foreign person;
  3. greenfield investments that could result in the establishment of a covered foreign person; and
  4. the establishment of a joint venture with a covered foreign person or which could result in the establishment of a covered foreign person.

Covered Foreign Persons

The term “covered foreign person” is expected to include the following:

  1. Chinese citizens and permanent residents;
  2. entities organized in China;
  3. entities with a principal place of business in China; and
  4. non-Chinese entities with a Chinese subsidiary or branch that represents more than fifty percent of the parent’s consolidated revenue, net income, capital expenditure, or operating expenses.

To narrow the scope of the EO and its implementing regulations, the definition of “covered foreign person” is further limited to such Chinese individuals and entities engaged in specific activities related to semiconductors and microelectronics, quantum computing, and artificial intelligence.

The ANPRM provides additional detail on what types of transactions are likely to be notifiable or prohibited once the outbound investment screening regime is implemented.

 

Prohibited Investments

Notifiable Investments

Semiconductors & Microelectronics

Investments in entities that are engaged in:

  • The development or production of electronic design automation software designed to be exclusively used for integrated circuit design.
  • The design, fabrication, and packing of integrated circuits that meet or exceed certain criteria.
  • The installation or sale to third-party customers of certain supercomputer enabled by advanced integrated circuits.

Investments in entities that are engaged in:

  • The design, fabrication, or packaging of integrated circuits for which transactions involving U.S. persons are not otherwise prohibited.

Quantum Information Technologies

Investments in entities that are engaged in:

  • The production of a quantum computer, dilution refrigerator, or two-stage pulse tube cryocooler.
  • The development of a quantum sensing platform designed or military end uses, government intelligence, or mass-surveillance end uses.
  • The development of a quantum network or quantum communication system designed to be exclusively used for secure communications, such as quantum key distribution.

Not currently being considered.

Artificial Intelligence

Investments in entities that are engaged in:

  • The development of software that incorporates an AI system[1] and is designed to be primarily or exclusively used for military, government intelligence, or mass-surveillance end uses

Investments in entities that are engaged in:

  • The development of software that incorporates an artificial intelligence system and is designed to be exclusively or primarily used for certain functions including: cybersecurity; the control of robotic systems; surreptitious listening devices; non-cooperative location tracking; or facial recognition.

U.S. Persons

The EO only applies directly to investments by U.S. persons, which Treasury anticipates defining in a manner comparable to how the term is defined in various sanctions programs (i.e., U.S. citizens and lawful permanent residents, entities organized in the United States, and persons physically located in the United States).  However, the EO also directs the Treasury Department to prohibit U.S. persons from “knowingly directing transactions” if such transactions would be prohibited if engaged in by a U.S. person. This mandate is likely to have a similar effect to the concept of “facilitation” in U.S. economic sanctions—i.e., that covered transactions made by non-U.S. persons may also be effectively restricted unless there is no U.S. nexus.  Accordingly, the Treasury Department anticipates prohibiting a U.S. person (such as an officer, senior manager, or equivalent senior-level employee at a foreign business or fund) from ordering, deciding, approving, or otherwise causing to be performed a transaction that would be prohibited under the proposed regulation if engaged in by a U.S. person.

As a practical matter, this would mean that non-U.S. businesses, including private funds organized outside of the United States, may be within scope of the outbound investment regime if U.S. persons serve as officers, managers, or senior employees and are involved in decision-making related to notifiable or prohibited transactions. However, the ANPRM anticipates that it will be permissible for a foreign fund with a U.S. person who serves on the management committee to make an investment that would be a prohibited transaction if performed by a U.S. person, provided that the U.S. person has recused himself from the particular investment. The ANPRM does not detail what measures will constitute recusal.

The ANPRM also clarifies that the prohibition on knowingly directing transaction is not intended to prohibit U.S. persons from providing third-party investment advisory services, underwriting, debt rating, prime brokerage, global custody, or the processing, clearing, or sending of payments by a bank, or legal, investigatory, or insurance services for covered transactions. Similarly, university-to-university research collaborations, the procurement of raw materials for covered national security technologies or productions, and intellectual property licensing arrangements are not intended to be captured by the definition of covered transaction, provided they are not undertaken as part of an effort to evade the regulations.

Notably, the EO and ANPRM impose an affirmative obligation on U.S. persons, including U.S. parent companies and funds to “take all reasonable steps” to prevent any transaction by a foreign entity controlled by such U.S. person if it would be prohibited if directly engaged in by a United States person. It is not yet clear how control will be determined in this context, although Treasury anticipates limiting this provision to majority-owned subsidiaries.  The ANPRM indicates that reasonable steps could be defined to include (i) binding agreements between the U.S. person and the controlled foreign entity, (ii) internal policies, procedures, and guidelines, (iii) periodic training, (iv) internal controls, (v) testing and auditing, and (vi) the exercise of governance or shareholder rights.

Exemptions

In the ANPRM, the Treasury Department expects to exempt a number of investments from the definition of covered transaction, including:  investments in publicly traded securities; investments in index funds, mutual funds, ETFs, and similar instruments; and investments by passive limited partners (e.g., limited partners who do not receive any rights other than standard minority shareholder protections) in venture capital funds, private equity funds, and other private funds, provided that the limited partner's investment is below a yet-to-be-determined de minimis threshold.

Penalties

The penalties for noncompliance with the regulations once they take effect are expected to be steep.  The Treasury Department will have the authority to nullify, void, or otherwise compel the divestment of any prohibited transaction entered into after the effective date of the regulations. The ANPRM also contemplates that the Treasury Department may impose a civil penalty up to the maximum allowed under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act for: (i) material misstatements in or material omissions from any information submitted in connection with the new regime; (ii) the undertaking of a prohibited transaction; or (iii) the failure to timely notify the Treasury Department of a notifiable transaction. The Treasury Department has not indicated how it intends to monitor transactions in order to help identify prohibited or non-notified transactions, but has requested public input on this point.

Key Takeaways

The EO and ANPRM are important first steps in the U.S. government’s efforts to regulate outbound investments that may affect national security. While the EO and the outbound investment screening regime it will create has been referred to in media accounts as a sort of “reverse CFIUS,” in practice it will likely bear many similarities to U.S. sanctions programs.  In particular, it will apply to U.S. persons, including U.S. person managers of foreign companies and foreign subsidiaries of U.S. companies.  On the other hand, this system will not review and approve transactions as CFIUS does. While the EO and ANPRM apply to a limited number of industries, U.S. companies, particularly private funds that make technology investments, should closely monitor the rulemaking process to ensure that they are ready to comply with regulations once they are promulgated.



[1]        Notably, the ANPRM contemplates a broad definition of “AI system” to include any “engineered or machine-based system that can, for a given set of objectives, generate outputs such as predictions, recommendations, or decisions influencing real or virtual environments.” The ANPRM also notes that AI systems can operate with varying levels of autonomy.


This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.