Skip to main content

The EU’s Foreign Subsidy Regime – The First Year

Antitrust and Competition Law Alert® | August 28, 2024

Authors: Tobias Caspary (London | Brussels), Valeri Bozhikov (London | Brussels), Clemens Ziegler (Brussels)

More than a year has now passed since the European Union (“EU”)’s Foreign Subsidy Regulation (“FSR”)[1] started to apply and since the European Commission (“Commission”) adopted its Implementing Regulation (EU) 2023/1441 (the “Implementing Regulation”[2]).[3] The notification obligations under the FSR will soon, on 12 October 2024, also have been in force for one year.[4] Also, the Commission has recently published guidance on its understanding of the term “distortion” under the FSR,[5] which is discussed below.

By way of a reminder, the FSR constitutes a trade policy instrument addressing a perceived legislative gap: to control non-EU subsidies that distort competition in the EU’s internal market and thereby undermine its level playing field (particularly with regards to the efficient allocation of capital). It requires businesses to notify and obtain prior clearance for certain transactions and public procurement procedures, and allows the Commission to open ex officio investigations into potentially distortive non-EU subsidies. 

COMMISSION’S PRACTICE TO DATE

What happened on the enforcement landscape in the past 12 months?

  • Within the first hundred days, the Commission had pre-notification discussions in the context of 53 deals, only 14 of which led to a formal notification.[6] This shows that the Commission is also willing to decline jurisdiction, which is a positive development.

  • The Commission opened five in-depth investigations under the FSR, of which four in the area of procurement procedures and one in the area of concentrations.

  • In February 2024, the Commission created an entirely new Directorate for FSR matters within its Directorate General for Competition (“DG COMP”). The new Directorate K is headed by a very senior and experienced State aid official, Karl Soukup, who is indeed still also acting Director of DG COMP’s horizontal State aid Directorate H (General Scrutiny & Enforcement). Three units have been allocated to the new Directorate.[7] It is encouraging that the Commission has deployed such important resources, enabling it to review cases swiftly.

  • On 10 June 2024, the Commission opened its first concentration-related in-depth investigation under the FSR. It did so after finding, based on a preliminary review, sufficient indications that at least one of the parties to the notified concentration had been granted a foreign subsidy that distorts the internal market.

  • The procurement-related investigations always concerned Chinese bidders - in the areas of trains (in Bulgaria), solar panels (in Romania)[8] and wind turbines (in Bulgaria, France, Greece, Romania and Spain[9], and in Germany[10]). While the investigation regarding Germany appears to be ongoing, none of the other investigations resulted in a final decision by the Commission as the bidders pre-empted this by walking away from the bids in question.

  • Interestingly, the Commission itself came under scrutiny in China by the launch of a sort of “tit-for-tat” investigation by the Ministry of Commerce.[11] The Commission’s reaction was unsurprising: “The EU's rules to fight unfair foreign subsidies don't specially target China, as companies are exposed to being probed ‘regardless of their seat or nationality”.[12]

  • Following the first dawn raid (on-site inspection) that the Commission conducted under the FSR in late April 2024,[13] the raided company, active in security equipment, unsuccessfully applied for an interim order to the General Court of the EU to temporarily suspend a Commission’s production order for mailboxes stored on servers in China in the context of a continued inspection (the “continuation” of the dawn raid at the Commission’s premises) pursuant to Article 14(3) FSR.[14]

COMMISSION’S GUIDANCE DOCUMENT AND THE NOTION OF “DISTORTION”

Additionally, some open procedural questions relating to the FSR[15] have been clarified in the meantime. The Commission’s guidance document of 26 July 2024[16] offers some clarification on how it understands the term “distortion” in both merger control and public procurement context, namely under Article 4(1), Article 6 and under Article 27 FSR, respectively.

  • “Distortion” in the FSR’s merger control context: where a foreign subsidy offers a benefit to an undertaking (improving its competitive position) it is considered a distortion if it actually or potentially negatively affects competition in the EU internal market. The competitive position of an undertaking can be improved directly by a foreign subsidy given to an EU entity active in the internal market, but also indirectly, e.g. in the case of cross-subsidisation. As far as the (actual or potential) negative effect on competition is concerned, such effects can be found with regard to any activity in which the beneficiary engages in the internal market. Negative effects might also be found, also in view of Recital 6 of the FSR, where foreign subsidies lead to an unlevel playing field, i.e. when they unduly alter the chances of succeeding in the market.[17]

  • “Distortion” in the FSR’s procurement context: two cumulative conditions must be met: (i) the tender submitted by the subsidised entity must be unduly advantageous in relation to the works, supplies or services concerned and (ii) there must be a link between the granting of the subsidy and the tender.
null
  • Difference between notions of “distortion in the internal market” under FSR and of “distortion of competition” under the EU State Aid rules: under EU State Aid rules, there is a distortion of competition under Article 107(1) TFEU when the State grants a financial advantage to an undertaking in a liberalised sector with actual or potential competition. Aid that relieves the beneficiary of expenses it would otherwise have had to bear in the course of its day-to-day business operations is normally considered to distort competition. Conversely, under the FSR, there is no presumption of a distortion of the internal market just because the beneficiary of a foreign subsidy is economically active in a liberalised sector. Rather, the distortion can either be based on the presumption of Article 5 FSR (foreign subsidies most likely to distort) or on indicators such as those listed in Article 4(1) FSR (i.e., the amount and nature of the foreign subsidy; the situation of the beneficiary, including its size and the markets or sectors concerned; the beneficiary’s economic activity in the EU; and the subsidy’s purpose, conditions and use in the EU).

[1]            Regulation (EU) 2022/2560 of December 14, 2022 on foreign subsidies distorting the internal market (OJ [2022] L 330/1).

[2]            Pursuant to its Article 54(2), the FSR started to apply as of 12 July 2023. On that same day, the Commission adopted its Implementing Regulation (Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2023/1441 of 10 July 2023 on detailed arrangements for the conduct of proceedings by the Commission pursuant to Regulation (EU) 2022/2560 of the European Parliament and of the Council on foreign subsidies distorting the internal market (OJ [2023] L 177/1)).

[3]            See also our earlier alerts on the subject: Tobias Caspary, Valeri Bozhikov, Rebecca Ponnuthurai & Romain Girard, EU’s Unprecedented Foreign Subsidy Regime Comes Into Force, Fried Frank (July 5, 2023). See also Dr. Tobias Caspary, Neda Moussavi, Valeri Bozhikov & Eloise Robson, Ex-US merger control: five trends for 2024, Fried Frank (February 5, 2024).

[4]            Pursuant to its Article 54(4), the FSR’s notification obligations under Article 21 (for concentrations) and Article 29 (for public procurement procedures) started to apply as of 12 October 2023.

[5]            Commission Staff Working Document. Initial clarifications on the application of Article 4(1), Article 6 and Article 27(1) of Regulation (EU) 2022/2560 on foreign subsidies distorting the internal market of 26 July 2024, Brussels, 26.7.2024, SWD(2024) 201 final (“Guidance SWD”).

[6]            L Moscoso/I Stoyanova, “The Foreign Subsidies Regulation – 100 days since the start of the notification obligation for concentrations”, in: European Commission, Competition FSR Brief. Issue 1, February 2024.

[7]            See DG COMP’s Organisation Chart. See also L Crofts, “New EU teams formed to police harmful foreign subsidies” (MLex article, 1 February 2024).

[8]            Speeches by Executive Vice President Vestager at the Forum Europa (EC Speech 24/3510, 27 June 2024) and at the Institute for Advanced Study (EC Speech 24/1927, April 9, 2024).

[9]            WindEurope Press Release “EU starts investigation into Chinese wind turbines under new Foreign Subsidies Regulation”, 9 April 2024.

[10]          RENEWS, “EU extends Chinese turbine probe to Germany”, 10 July 2024.

[11]          The Chinese Ministry of Commerce announced “a trade and investment barrier investigation into the relevant practices adopted by the EU in its investigation of Chinese enterprises”; the investigation has an end date of 10 January 2025, but could be extended until April 2025. See “China opens investigation into EU trade barriers” (10 July 2024), available here.

[12]          O Pandiello, T Gil, “Foreign-subsidy rules don't discriminate, EU regulator says in response to Chinese probe” (MLex article, 10 July 2024).

[13]          P Soler, “Commission carries out first raid under foreign subsidies regulation”, Euronews, 23 April 2024.

[14]          Order of 12 August 2024 in Case T-284/24 R Nuctec Warsaw Company Limited and Nuctec Netherlands v Commission EU:T:2024:564.

[15]          See the two Fried Frank alerts referred to in n. 3 above.

[16]          See n 5 above.

[17]          Guidance SWD (n 5 above), answer to Question 1 (p. 1 f.).


This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.