Skip to main content

Client memorandum | November 2, 2023

Authors: Josh La Grange, Jonathan S. Adler

Introduction

On October 13, 2023, the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC” or the “Commission”) adopted new measures regarding short selling transparency.[1] First, the SEC adopted new Rule 13f-2 under Section 13(f) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended (the “Exchange Act”), together with related Form SHO, requiring institutional investment managers with short positions exceeding certain thresholds to report a significant amount of information to the SEC, albeit not for individually-identified public disclosure.[2] Second, to provide the Commission with greater transparency concerning certain short sale-related data, the SEC adopted amendments to the national market system plan (“NMS Plan”) governing the consolidated audit trail (“CAT”) regarding the classification of certain short selling by market makers. The rules were adopted on the same day the SEC took a related action in adopting Exchange Act Rule 10c-1a, which establishes a new regime for reporting of securities loans.[3]

Background

Rule 13f-2 is intended to implement the specific statutory mandate in Section 929X of the Dodd–Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (“Dodd-Frank”) to “prescribe short-sale reporting rules providing for the public disclosure of the name of the issuer and the title, class, CUSIP number, aggregate amount of the number of short sales of each security, and any additional information determined by the Commission following the end of the reporting period.” Subject to applicable thresholds, these new requirements apply to short sales by institutional investment managers or in accounts directly or indirectly subject to the investment discretion of institutional investment managers. The rules apply to (i) equity securities of a class registered pursuant to Exchange Act Section 12 or for which the issuer of that class of securities is required to file reports pursuant to Exchange Act Section 15(d) (a “reporting company issuer”)[4] and (ii) equity securities of a class of securities of an issuer that is not a reporting company issuer (a “non-reporting company issuer”).[5]

Although relevant to a narrower segment of market participants, in the same release the SEC also established that CAT reporting firms will be required to indicate whether an order is a short sale effected in bona fide market making activities for which an exception from the “locate” requirement is claimed under Regulation SHO.

Short Sale Reporting Requirements

Persons Subject

The reporting requirement applies only to “institutional investment managers,” as defined in Exchange Act Section 13(f)(6)(A). The term “includes any person, other than a natural person, investing in or buying and selling securities for its own account, and any person exercising investment discretion with respect to the account of any other person” (“Managers,” herein, to reflect the usage in Form SHO). Thus, as proposed, the SEC has leveraged the term “investment discretion,” defined in existing Exchange Act Rule 13f-1(b), which adopts the definition contained in Exchange Act Section 3(a)(35) but also includes all accounts over which any person under a Manager’s control exercises investment discretion. Exchange Act Section 3(a)(35) states that “a person exercises ‘investment discretion’ with respect to an account if, directly or indirectly, such person (A) is authorized to determine what securities or other property shall be purchased or sold by or for the account, (B) makes decisions as to what securities or other property shall be purchased or sold by or for the account even though some other person may have responsibility for such investment decisions, or (C) otherwise exercises such influence with respect to the purchase and sale of securities or other property by or for the account as the Commission, by rule, determines, in the public interest or for the protection of investors, should be subject to the operation of the provisions of this chapter and the rules and regulations thereunder.”

Thresholds

Managers will need to consider the applicable threshold set forth in the instructions to Form SHO for reporting company issuers (“Threshold A,” in the language of the instructions to Form SHO) and non-reporting company issuers (“Threshold B”).[6] In both cases, the thresholds are measured based on all accounts over which the Manager, or any person under the Manager’s controls, has investment discretion.

Threshold A means:

(1) a monthly average gross short position at the close of regular trading hours in the equity security with a U.S. dollar value of $10 million or more, or (2) a monthly average gross short position at the close of regular trading hours as a percentage of shares outstanding in the equity security of 2.5 percent or more….

Threshold B means:

a gross short position in the equity security with a U.S. dollar value of $500,000 or more at the close of regular trading hours on any settlement date during the calendar month….

The instructions to Form SHO further clarify the determination of the valuations and percentages used for the two thresholds, generally by reference to applicable details as of the close of regular trading hours in the equity security in question on each settlement date during the calendar month.

Form SHO

Within fourteen (14) calendar days after the end of each month, Managers will be required to file a custom XML-formatted Form SHO on EDGAR with regard to each class of equity securities subject to such disclosure on the basis of the applicable threshold described above. Form SHO makes use of a system of “notice,” “entries report,” and “combination report” filings (similar to what is now used for Form 13F), in order to avoid duplicative reporting where more than one Manager required by Rule 13f-2 to file Form SHO for the same reporting period exercises investment discretion with respect to the same securities.[7]

Further, Managers will be required to amend and restate any Form SHO within ten (10) calendar days of discovering errors affecting the accuracy of the short sale data reported therein.

Form SHO has two substantive tables that are required to be compiled:

  • In Table 1, for equity securities as to which reporting is required, the Manager must report its gross short position, by share amount and dollar value, as of the end of the month.
  • In Table 2, for each settlement day during the month as to each reportable security, the net amount of the Manager's purchases vs. sales for that day (with net purchases reported as a positive number and sales as a negative). In Table 2, the Manager must also provide information as to whether purchases were made to cover an existing short and information as to the manner in which such securities are purchased or sold; e.g., whether pursuant to an option exercise by or against the Manager, or a secondary transaction.

To protect the identity of reporting Managers, the SEC will publicly report both Table 1 and Table 2 information as to each security aggregated across all Managers.[8] In the Adopting Release, the SEC confirmed its expectation that it will do so within a month after the end of the calendar month subject to a given reporting cycle.[9]

Effectiveness and Compliance Dates

Rule 13f-2 and Form SHO will become effective 60 days after the Adopting Release is published in the Federal Register, with compliance required twelve (12) months thereafter. The SEC will not begin to publish aggregated data collected on Form SHO filings, however, until three (3) months later.[10]

CAT NMS Plan

Likely of narrower interest, the SEC also amended the CAT NMS Plan to indirectly require broker-dealers with a reporting obligation to CAT to augment the short sale order data previously reportable (e.g., whether an order is long, short, or short exempt) to disclose whether a market participant is relying on the bona fide market making exception to locate requirement in Rule 203(b)(2) of Regulation SHO.

As a general matter, Rule 203(b)(1) requires broker-dealers to accept a short sale order for, or effect a short sale in an equity security only if, the broker-dealer has borrowed the security, entered into an arrangement to borrow the security, or has reasonable grounds to believe that the security can be borrowed so that it can be delivered when due (the so-called “locate requirement”).[11] Rule 203(b)(2), however, establishes a carve-out from the locate requirement for short sales effected by a market maker in connection with bona fide market making activities.[12] In adopting the amendment to the CAT NMS Plan, the SEC indicated that it intends to develop information regarding the use of the bona fide market maker locate exception that will better allow regulators to understand market practices with respect to the use of that exception.[13]

This amendment is effective sixty (60) days following the publication of the Adopting Release in the Federal Register, with compliance starting eighteen (18) months after such effectiveness.



[1] See Press Release 2023-221, SEC Adopts Rule to Increase Transparency Into Short Selling and Amendment to CAT NMS Plan for Purposes of Short Sale Data Collection; Final Rule, Short Position and Short Activity Reporting by Institutional Investment Managers, Exchange Act Release No. 34-98738 (Oct. 13, 2023) (“Adopting Release”); Notice of the Text of the Amendment to the National Market System Plan Governing the Consolidated Audit Trail for Purposes of Short Sale-Related Data Collection, Exchange Act Release No. 34-98739 (Oct. 13, 2023). The SEC originally proposed similar amendments in February 2022. Proposed Rule, Short Position and Short Activity Reporting by Institutional Investment Managers, Exchange Act Release No. 34-94313 (Feb. 25, 2022). See also, Fried Frank Client Memo, SEC Proposes Rulemaking to Require Short Sale Reporting (March 2, 2022).

[2] See Adopting Release at Section VII.F.

[3] The securities lending reporting requirement is notably different in scope from the short selling rules and extends to, e.g., transactions in U.S. Treasury securities and other non-equity and non-Exchange Act registered issuances.

[4] Although the term “reporting company issuer” appears on its face to refer to an issuer, rather than to equity securities of a class of securities, the term is defined in respect of a particular class of securities (i.e., that is, one registered under Exchange Act Section 12 or for which the issuer thereof is required to file reports pursuant to Exchange Act 15(d)). See Form SHO “Instructions for Calculating Reporting Threshold.” Further, the text of new Rule 13f-2(a)(1) and (2) is clear that it is the status of the class of securities that determines the applicable threshold for reporting purposes.

[5] The Adopting Release acknowledges that the Commission received comments questioning the application of proposed Rule 13f-2 to short selling in equity securities of a class issued by a non-U.S. issuer and neither registered pursuant to Exchange Act Section 12 nor subject to reporting pursuant to Exchange Act Section 15(d). After addressing such comments, the Adopting Release confirms that new Rule 13f-2 applies to such securities. See “Comments to Limit Scope to Equity Securities of U.S. Reporting Company Issuers” in Adopting Release at Section II.A.2.b.

[6] See footnote 2 above.

[7] See Special Instruction 5 to Form SHO.

[8] See Adopting Release at Section VII.F.

[9] E.g., the SEC would expect to publish data regarding January by the end of February. See Adopting Release at Section II.B.3.

[10] See Adopting Release at Section VI.

[11] See 17 CFR 242.203(b)(1).

[12] See 17 CFR 242.203(b)(2).

[13] See “Comments and Final Rule” in Adopting Release at Section IV.B.


This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.