New York City Department of City Planning Releases Proposed Text of Zoning Amendment Entitled “City of Yes for Economic Opportunity”
Client memorandum | December 5, 2023
The New York City Department of City Planning (“DCP”) has released the proposed text of its zoning amendment entitled “City of Yes for Economic Opportunity.”
As discussed in our prior client memorandum, this initiative is intended to facilitate economic growth by amending certain outdated or ambiguous zoning regulations. For example, the proposal includes clarifications in connection with a range of uses, including life sciences, amusements, observation decks and veterinary/pet care.
We wish to highlight two particular aspects of the proposal:
- the consolidation and reorganization of “use groups”; and
- the imposition of new “streetscape” regulations governing ground floor uses.
Use Group Consolidation and Reorganization
The City of Yes for Economic Opportunity zoning initiative proposes to consolidate and reorganize the listing of Use Groups in the Zoning Resolution to make it easier for businesses to determine which uses are permitted.
The current 18 Use Groups will be reduced to 10 Use Groups, and commonly known Use Group categories will be changing. For example, offices, which are currently categorized as Use Group 6, would be recategorized as Use Group 7. Use Group 4, which currently designates certain community facility uses, would become the category for infrastructure and utility-related uses. Various “amusement or recreation facilities” from multiple Use Groups would be combined into a single Use Group 8 that would also include event spaces. And many Use Group 16, 17, and 18 manufacturing uses would be consolidated into the new Use Group 10. A high-level summary of the proposed new Use Groups is set forth below.
|
Use Group |
Description |
|
1 |
Agriculture and Open Uses |
|
2 |
Residences |
|
3 |
Community Facilities |
|
4 |
Public Service Facilities and Infrastructure |
|
5 |
Transient Accommodations |
|
6 |
Retail and Services |
|
7 |
Offices and Laboratories |
|
8 |
Recreation, Entertainment and Assembly Spaces |
|
9 |
Storage |
|
10 |
Production Uses |
DCP has provided more detailed charts on its website explaining how existing uses would be recategorized here and what uses would be included in each of the proposed Use Groups here.
While many of the use group updates may provide helpful modernization or clarifications, there could be unforeseen implications of the proposed new framework, including administrative delays and uncertainty as the new framework is applied to existing buildings or projects currently in the planning stages.
New Ground Floor Use Requirements and Limitations
DCP’s proposed zoning updates would for the first time impose citywide requirements and restrictions with respect to ground floor uses (commonly known as “streetscape” regulations). Streetscape regulations currently exist in certain “special purpose districts” and parts of Manhattan; the proposal would consolidate those district-specific regulations into a consistent set of regulations that would apply to commercial districts and special purpose districts across wide swaths of the city.
Among the streetscape regulations are requirements for certain retail and service uses to be provided to a minimum depth, restrictions on certain ground floor uses (such as tenant amenity spaces) and limitations on lobby widths. The map below illustrates the areas that would be covered by the new regulations, which are designated as Tier A, Tier B and Tier C, corresponding to varying degrees of requirements.

In our experience, ground floor use requirements can present significant challenges for site planning. While the proposed regulations have the potential to streamline streetscape requirements for sites within special districts that are currently subject to similar controls, the expansion of streetscape regulations to a broader swath of the City (including additional frontages in special districts) raises concerns. As drafted, the proposed regulations could affect alterations of existing buildings, and projects currently in planning or early phases of construction.
The City of Yes for Economic Opportunity proposal is currently under review at the City’s 59 Community Boards. DCP anticipates enactment of the proposed zoning text amendment, with any modifications arising out of the public review process, in the spring of 2024.
Please contact us for additional information about the potential implications of this initiative and DCP’s other two pending citywide zoning initiatives (“City of Yes for Carbon Neutrality” and “City of Yes for Housing Opportunity”).
This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.