Skip to main content

New York City Department of City Planning seeks feedback on “City of Yes for Economic Opportunity” Zoning Text Amendment

Client memorandum | July 12, 2023

Authors: Anita W. Laremont and Leigh Whitman

The New York City (“City”) Department of City Planning (“DCP”) is currently collaborating with stakeholders and the public to craft an amendment (the “Amendment”) to the Zoning Resolution of the City of New York (the “Zoning Resolution”) in connection with the “City of Yes for Economic Opportunity” initiative, which is one of three City-wide initiatives meant to modernize and update the Zoning Resolution to support small businesses, create affordable housing, and promote sustainability (in addition to City of Yes for Carbon Neutrality and for Housing Opportunity).

Goals and Proposed Changes

The goals of the Amendment are to maintain and facilitate economic growth by removing red tape, ambiguity, and outdated regulations. As presented at the July 11, 2023 info session, the Amendment would include 18 proposals aimed at achieving the following goals: 1) expanding options for businesses to locate; 2) supporting growing industries; 3) fostering vibrant neighborhoods; and 4) providing clarity and predictability. The specific changes proposed include the following:

1. Expand Options for Businesses to Locate

Remove ground floor restrictions on otherwise permitted commercial uses in major commercial districts; remove arbitrary barriers for certain uses on commercial streets; and allow commercial uses on upper floors of mixed-use buildings. This would rationalize zoning by removing illogical or outdated restrictions on location of certain uses. Additionally, the creation of new job-intensive zoning districts with more favorable bulk, parking, and loading controls would allow for the creation of desired loft-style buildings that meet the needs of today’s businesses.

Illustrative Examples:

In C1 districts, bike sale businesses are permitted but bike rental and repair businesses are not. In C2 districts, which are similar to C1 districts, all of these uses are permitted. The Amendment would make similar uses permitted within a district and make similar districts (C1/C2 vs. C4/C5/C6) allow the same uses.

In Midtown South, dance studios, instructional facilities, clothing rental shops, and other businesses are only permitted above the ground floor. The Amendment would allow all permitted commercial uses to locate on the ground floor in major commercial districts.

2. Support Growing Industries

Clarify controls for life sciences facilities and expand applicability of a special permit to allow for location on campuses; provide bulk relief for purpose-built buildings, such as film studios; expand areas where amusements and experiential businesses can locate; and clarify rules relating to indoor vs. outdoor uses. This would provide clarity to growing industries such as life sciences, film studios, experiential businesses, and urban agriculture and also expand the ability of these businesses to locate in new areas of the City.

Illustrative Examples:

The Zoning Resolution uses outdated terms, creating confusion regarding where life science labs are allowed. The Amendment would add clarity and allow any life science business to occupy office space, provided specified environmental standards are met.

Film soundstages require high walls which conflict with the Zoning Resolution in many districts. The Amendment would allow business to seek limited bulk relief to construct new buildings that would otherwise exceed current bulk regulations.

3. Foster Vibrant Neighborhoods

Allow for reactivation of vacant, formerly-grandfathered storefronts; allow small-scale commercial uses near intersections in residential districts; and clarify and loosen controls on small-scale wholesale, storage, and micro-delivery facilities. This would activate streets and allow for businesses to be located in proximity to residents they serve.

Illustrative Examples:

Grandfathered stores which are vacant for 2+ years cannot be reactivated in most residence districts. The Amendment would allow reoccupation of these vacant storefronts.

New neighborhood services cannot open in large swaths of the City. The Amendment would allow for new small professional offices, retail, or service uses within 100 feet of an intersection (or in a large-scale development) in any residence district via CPC Authorization.

Current controls for small wholesale and storage businesses are confusing or overly prohibitive and make it difficult to easily accommodate micro-delivery facilities and other new forms of space in commercial districts, which could alleviate truck congestion and foster alternate modes of delivery (e.g., bike delivery). The Amendment would allow wholesale and storage businesses to locate in neighborhood commercial districts at a limited scale and in higher-density areas at a larger scale, subject to streetscape rules.

4. Provide Clarity and Predictability

Simplify and modernize Use Group definitions to clarify where specific businesses can locate; and loosen loading dock requirements for conversions and enlargements to allow buildings to adapt over time.

Illustrative Example:

The current Use Group definitions are outdated and ambiguous for many contemporary uses. For example, zoning clearly categorizes typewriter stores under “Use Group 6C,” but it is unclear how a cellphone repair shop is categorized. The Amendment would reorganize the current Use Groups into more coherent categories using the North American Industry Classification System so that a common sense understanding of businesses of similar sectors and types are categorized together.

Current Status, Next Steps

Thus far, DCP has held a number of info sessions, performed initial stakeholder outreach, and collaborated with advocates and practitioners. Currently, DCP anticipates referral of the Amendment for public review in October 2023, starting the City’s public land use review process (ULURP). It is anticipated that the proposed text will be released closer to the start of public review. Following referral, DCP anticipates a public hearing in December 2023, vote by the City Planning Commission in January 2024, and City Council vote in March 2024. Assuming no mayoral veto, the Amendment will be effective at this point.

Please feel free to contact us if you have any questions, would like to provide feedback to DCP on the proposal, or otherwise wish to discuss this topic.


This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.