Updated SEC Marketing Rule FAQs Ease Adviser Presentation of Extracted Performance and Certain Characteristics
Client memorandum | March 21, 2025
Authors: Michael Sherman (Washington, DC), Ashley Rodriguez (Washington, DC), Joanna Rosenberg (New York), Brooke Gibson (New York)
On March 19, 2025, the staff of the Division of Investment Management (the “staff”) of the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) published two new Marketing Compliance Frequently Asked Questions[1] with respect to Rule 206(4)-1 (the “Marketing Rule”) under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 (“Advisers Act”) and withdrew an existing FAQ. In a departure from prior guidance, the new FAQs clarify that an investment adviser advertisement can include gross extracted performance and/or gross portfolio or investment “characteristics” without including the corresponding net figure if: (i) the extracted performance and/or characteristic is clearly identified as gross; (ii) both gross and net total portfolio performance are presented with at least equal prominence to, and in a manner designed to facilitate comparison with, the extracted performance and/or characteristic (e.g., prior to the gross-only figure); and (iii) the gross and net performance of the total portfolio is calculated over a period that includes the entire period over which the extracted performance or characteristic is calculated. The staff reasons that presentation in accordance with the FAQs presents little risk that a recipient will be misled about the impact of fees on performance, and acknowledges that presenting certain characteristics gross and net was impossible or might lead to confusing results.
Background
The Marketing Rule defines “extracted performance” to mean the performance results of a subset of investments extracted from a portfolio,[2] and provides that an adviser presenting gross performance in an advertisement need also present net performance with at least equal prominence to, and in a format designed to facilitate comparison with, the gross performance.[3] In January 2023, following the effective date of the Marketing Rule, the staff published an FAQ (“January 2023 FAQ”) stating that the performance of one investment or a group of investments in a private fund is an example of extracted performance and, accordingly, “an adviser may not show gross performance of one investment or a group of investments without also showing the net performance of that single investment or group of investments, respectively.”[4] The staff’s January 2023 FAQ was a departure from existing market practice and proved challenging for advisers to implement because fees and expenses are generally applied at the overall portfolio level rather than at the investment level or for a characteristic.
The New FAQs
Extracted Performance FAQ
The Extracted Performance FAQ applies to the presentation of performance of one investment or a group of investments (the “extract”) from a portfolio (e.g., a private fund, a representative account) or from a composite of related portfolios. The Extracted Performance FAQ permits advisers to present a gross-only extract, provided that such extract otherwise meets the requirements of the Marketing Rule, and the following additional conditions are met:
- the figures are clearly identified as gross performance (e.g., with accompanying disclosure that the figures do not reflect the deduction of all fees/expenses that a client or investor has or would have paid as well as a cross-reference to the gross and net performance of the total portfolio);
- the figures are accompanied by a presentation of the total portfolio’s gross and net performance consistent with the requirements of the Marketing Rule;
- the gross and net performance of the total portfolio is presented with at least equal prominence to, and in a manner designed to facilitate comparison with, the figures (e.g., presenting total portfolio performance on a page prior to the figures);[5] and
- the gross and net performance of the total portfolio is calculated over a period that includes the entire period over which the figures are calculated, but where multiple time periods are otherwise required to be shown by the Marketing Rule, such figure is calculated over a single, clearly disclosed time period[6].
The staff also expresses the view that presentation of a gross figure extracted from a representative account would meet the requirements of the Extracted Performance FAQ if the gross-only extract was accompanied by the gross and net performance of a composite of all of the representative account’s related portfolios (instead of the gross and net performance of the representative account itself).
Characteristics FAQ
The Characteristics FAQ applies to investment or portfolio characteristics that could constitute performance (“characteristics”), including characteristics calculated with respect to a: (i) composite aggregation of related portfolios, (ii) representative account, (iii) subset of a portfolio (i.e., extracted performance), and (iv) subset extracted from a composite aggregation of related portfolios. Under the Characteristics FAQ, advisers are permitted to present gross-only characteristics subject to the same conditions applicable to extracts under the Extracted Performance FAQ.
While the staff acknowledges that advisers can be unsure whether certain characteristics are performance that is subject to the requirements of the Marketing Rule or metrics which are not, the staff declined to take a position as to whether any particular characteristic should be considered “performance”. Instead, the Characteristics FAQ clarifies that the relief can be applied to metrics such as: (i) yield; (ii) coupon rate; (iii) contribution to return; (iv) volatility; (v) sector or geographic returns; (vi) attribution analyses; (vii) Sharpe ratio; and (viii) Sortino ratio. However, the staff states that the relief provided in the Characteristics FAQ does not apply to: (i) total return; (ii) time weighted return; (iii) return on investment; (iv) internal rate of return; (v) multiple on invested capital; and (vi) total value to paid in capital (“Performance Metrics”). As a result, advisers should continue to present gross and net portfolio-level Performance Metrics calculated on the same time and methodology as required by the Marketing Rule. However, Performance Metrics for an extract can be presented on a gross-only basis in accordance with the Extracted Performance FAQ.
Conclusion
The new FAQs, coupled with the withdrawal of the January 2023 FAQ, should significantly ease the burden of presenting extracted performance and certain characteristics in compliance with the Marketing Rule. However, when determining whether to present a particular characteristic on a gross-only basis, advisers should carefully consider whether the relief in the FAQs is available for that metric. Advisers are also reminded that their advertisements remain subject to the general prohibitions of the Marketing Rule and the general anti-fraud provisions of the Advisers Act. Advisers should continue to focus on ensuring that presentation of performance information in advertisements is in accordance with the Marketing Rule and related guidance.
[1] SEC Division of Investment Management, Marketing Compliance Frequently Asked Questions, (updated Mar. 19, 2025) at “Extracted Performance” and “Portfolio or Investment Characteristics”, available at https://www.sec.gov/rules-regulations/staff-guidance/division-investment-management-frequently-asked-questions/marketing-compliance-frequently-asked-questions (referred to herein as the “Extracted Performance FAQ” and the “Characteristics FAQ”, and, together , the “FAQs”).
[2] Rule 206(4)-1(e)(6).
[3] Rule 206(4)-1(d)(1).
[4] SEC Division of Investment Management, Marketing Compliance Frequently Asked Questions, (modified Jan. 11, 2023, withdrawn Mar. 19, 2025) at “Gross and Net Performance”.
[5] The staff indicates that, in its view, the total gross and net performance need not be presented on the same page as the gross extract or characteristic, as long as the presentation of performance facilitates comparison between the extract and the total portfolio performance. The staff states that, for example, presenting total portfolio performance on a page prior to the extract or characteristic could facilitate the required comparison.
[6] In the FAQs, the staff acknowledges that time periods over which extracted performance and characteristics are calculated might not easily align with the one-, five- and ten-year time periods required for accounts other than private funds under the Marketing Rule.
This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.