Tri-Seal Compliance Note Highlights Voluntary Self-Disclosure Procedures for Sanctions and Export Control Violations
International Trade and Investment Alert™ | July 28, 2023
Authors: Michael T. Gershberg, Gregory Bernstein
On July 26, 2023, the Department of Justice’s (DOJ) National Security Division (NSD), the Department of Commerce’s Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS), and the Department of the Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) issued a joint compliance note describing policies and best practices for filing voluntary self-disclosures (VSDs) related to potential violations of sanctions, export controls, and other national security laws. While the compliance note does not announce any new policies concerning VSDs, it provides a helpful overview of each agency’s treatment of VSDs in their enforcement processes. The guidance contained in the compliance note makes clear the US Government’s position that companies should, upon becoming aware of a potential violation, timely file a VSD with the appropriate agencies, as doing so can substantially reduce the civil and criminal penalties that may be imposed.
DOJ National Security Division
The compliance note emphasized NSD’s position that businesses should submit a VSD for any instances of potentially criminal violations of the statutes implementing the government’s primary export control and sanctions regimes. These include the Arms Export Control Act, the Export Control Reform Act (ECRA), and the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA). NSD announced a new VSD Policy in March 2023. Under this policy, if a company (i) voluntarily self-discloses potentially criminal violations, (ii) fully cooperates, and (iii) timely and appropriately remediates the violations, then NSD generally will not seek a guilty plea, and will apply a presumption that the company should receive a non-prosecution agreement and not pay a fine—provided there are no aggravating factors at play. Aggravating factors include: conduct that involves a grave threat to national security; export of items that are particularly sensitive or to end users who are of heightened concern; repeated violations; the involvement of senior management; and significant profit obtained through the unlawful conduct. When such factors are present, NSD retains its discretion to seek other resolutions such as a deferred prosecution agreement or a guilty plea.
The compliance note also highlighted that in order to obtain the aforementioned benefits of submitting a VSD, the disclosure must be made to DOJ rather than a regulatory agency, such as BIS or OFAC. Previous guidance issued by NSD also clarifies that, to obtain the benefits of NSD’s voluntary disclosure policy, the disclosing entity must not have a preexisting obligation to disclose misconduct to any DOJ component, federal or state regulator, foreign regulatory or law enforcement entity, and the disclosure must be made to NSD prior to an imminent threat of disclosure or government investigation.
Finally, NSD’s VSD Policy applies to other corporate criminal matters relating to national security, including those arising under the Foreign Agents Registration Act, laws prohibiting material support to terrorists, and criminal violations relating to the regulations administered by the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States.
Department of Commerce / BIS
The compliance note explains that under BIS civil enforcement guidelines set forth in its regulations, voluntary self-disclosures that are timely, comprehensive, and involve full cooperation by the disclosing party are eligible for substantially reduced civil penalties. To underscore the importance of filing a VSD, BIS announced a new policy in April 2023, under which the deliberate non-disclosure of a significant possible violation will be considered an aggravating factor. This applies in cases when a significant possible violation has been uncovered by a party’s export compliance program but no VSD has been submitted. BIS also cautioned that companies cannot “self-blind” themselves to potential violations, including by refraining from carrying out international investigations when necessary, as BIS will consider the existence and adequacy of a company’s export controls compliance program when calculating a penalty amount under its settlement guidelines.
BIS also reiterated its dual-track system for handling VSDs, which took effect in June 2022. Under this system, VSDs involving minor or technical infractions―which make up the vast majority of VSDs according to BIS―will be resolved with a warning letter or no-action letter within 60 days of a final VSD being submitted.
While the compliance note focused primarily on self-disclosures, BIS also emphasized that if an entity submits a tip to BIS’s Office of Export Enforcement and the tip leads to an enforcement action, then that will be considered as a mitigating factor if that entity faces an enforcement action in the future, regardless of whether or not the future enforcement action is related to the tip. This policy is intended to incentivize companies to provide information on potential violations to BIS, even if the potential violation does not involve the disclosing company.
Treasury Department / OFAC
With respect to sanctions violations, the compliance note explains that OFAC considers VSDs to be a mitigating factor when determining what enforcement action is appropriate in response to apparent violations of the sanctions programs it administers. In cases where a civil monetary penalty is warranted, a VSD can result in a 50 percent reduction in the base amount of a proposed civil penalty, similar to the penalty framework implemented by BIS.
OFAC emphasized that to be credited as a VSD, the self-disclosure must occur prior to, or simultaneous with, the discovery by OFAC or another government agency of the apparent violation or a substantially similar apparent violation. In some cases, notification of an apparent violation through a VSD to another agency, such as DOJ, will qualify as a VSD to OFAC, although this is decided on a case-by-case basis.
OFAC also explained that not all disclosures are created equal and that a disclosure will not qualify as a VSD under certain circumstances, including when: (i) the disclosure contains false or misleading information; (ii) the disclosure, combined with supplemental information submitted by the disclosing entity, is materially incomplete; (iii) the disclosure is not self-initiated (e.g. when the disclosure is ordered or suggested by a federal or state agency or when the disclosure is made by an individual without the authorization of an entity’s senior management); or (iv) a third party is required to and does notify OFAC of the apparent violation because the transaction was blocked or rejected by that third party.
Key Takeaways
Businesses, especially those with international operations or transactions, should carefully review the compliance note and familiarize themselves with each agency’s policies concerning VSDs. As the compliance note makes clear, self-disclosures, combined with appropriate remedial measures, can significantly reduce the penalties businesses may face for conduct that violates US sanctions or export controls. Companies should implement and maintain compliance policies and robust internal controls that will enable them to identify -- and if appropriate, disclose -- potential violations.
This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.