Top Five Russia Sanctions Impacting the Transport Industry
International Trade and Investment Alert™ | July 24, 2024
Given its cross-border nature, the transport industry has repeatedly found itself at the forefront of the European Union’s (the “EU”) sanction regime against Russia (Regulation 833/2014, the “Sanctions Regulation”). Not only must transporters comply with restrictions specific to their industry, but they must also contend with the day-to-day implementation of the sanctions through their interaction with customs officials. The recent 14th package of sanctions (in effect from 24 June 2024)[1] further increased the compliance burden on operators active in the transport industry (for brevity, referred to as “transporters”), both in the EU and outside of the EU.
There is no outright embargo on trade with Russia. However, the Sanctions Regulation imposes both (a) generic prohibitions on all EU operators to engage in certain conduct as well as (b) specific restrictions on transporters. This article highlights the five keys sanctions impacting both EU and non-EU transporters (and owners):
- General principles: The Sanctions Regulation will not only apply to EU nationals and transporters, but also to non-EU subsidiaries of EU transporters. Transporters should also ensure that they stay clear of circumvention risks (which includes recklessness) attaching to unclear trade routes.
- Airfreight sanctions: Non-scheduled flights in the EU where a Russian person or entity is in a position to determine the place or time of its take-off or landing are prohibited.
- Road transport sanctions: EU road transport undertakings with at least 25 percent ownership by a Russian individual or entity are prohibited from transporting goods within the EU.
- Maritime shipping sanctions: Non-EU/non-Russian vessels are effectively banned from trade with the EU where they undertake one or more listed activities which may promote Russia’s war on Ukraine. Once listed, a vessel is in effect prohibited from undertaking most shipping activities in the EU.
- Ancillary sanctions: Beyond restrictions which are tied to the mode of transport, there are also restrictions which attach to the content of the underlying freight, as well as the local activities of Russian subsidiaries of EU transporters, and finally the counterparties of the transport.
I. General principles
The Sanctions Regulation expands two general principles regarding jurisdiction and circumvention offences, both of which have implications for transporters.
Jurisdictional scope - beyond EU transporters
The Sanctions Regulation generally applies to (a) EU nationals, (b) EU entities, and (c) business conducted in the EU. As such, all EU transporters, as well as non-EU transporters that move freight to the EU, will need to comply with the Sanctions Regulation.
In addition, the 14th package expressly creates an expectation that non-EU subsidiaries of EU operators will comply with EU sanctions. As such, it is possible that non-EU transporters are required to comply with EU sanctions even when transporting freight outside of the EU. This is a completely novel area of EU sanction law; for more detail, please refer to our prior alert on the introduction of the “best efforts obligation.”
EU transporters should review their global compliance policies so that non-EU subsidiaries are aware of their obligations under EU sanctions.
Schemes of circumvention - knowledge and recklessness
Circumvention requires participating in activities, with the knowledge and intent that these activities will contribute to conduct which is ultimately in breach of applicable sanctions.[2] This could include participating in a scheme which diverts a trade route to obfuscate an otherwise illegal trade (see for example the facts in Afrasiabi[3]).
There can be no circumvention if there is no knowledge or cause to suspect wrongdoings.[4] However, the requirement for “intent” has been expressly lowered (as part of the 14th package) to that of simple recklessness (i.e., typically the lowest degree of intent in criminal regimes).
For EU transporters, the shadow cast by a potential circumvention offence requires constant diligence to detect schemes involving the re-routing of goods in breach of sanctions. Good practice requires thorough “know-your-customer” checks and employee training.
II. Air transport restrictions
The Sanctions Regulation imposes numerous prohibitions targeting the air transport industry, with an emphasis on passenger transport. In particular, it is prohibited to:
- Provide various support services to any Russia-owned aircrafts, such as overhaul, repair, inspection, replacement, modification, or defect rectification services of an aircraft or a component.[5] The prohibition also extends to non-Russian aircrafts which are used in Russia; and
- Operate Russia-linked aircrafts in EU airspace, such as: (i) aircrafts operated by Russian commercial air carriers, (ii) Russian-registered aircrafts, (iii) aircrafts owned, chartered, or controlled by a Russian individual or entity, and (iv) aircrafts for which the place or time of take-off or landing is determined by a Russian individual or entity.[6]
Moreover, EU operators will need to comply with requests from Member State authorities to provide information on the owner of the aircraft, the identity of the individual or entity chartering the aircraft, and the identity of the passengers and the crew.[7]
These restrictions have drastic consequences for operators of aircrafts which have some nexus with Russia. In particular, the prohibition on providing support services could effectively result in aircrafts being de facto grounded (as they cannot take off without showing the requisite inspection checks).
III. Maritime shipping restrictions
The Sanctions Regulation imposes the following restrictions on maritime shipping:
- Prohibits various vessels from accessing EU ports and locks, namely: (i) vessels registered under the flag of Russia, (ii) vessels certified by the Russian Maritime Register of Shipping, (iii) previously Russian-registered vessels that changed their register to another state after 24 February 2022,[8] (iv) vessels performing ship-to-ship transfers of crude oil or petroleum products originating or exported from Russia,[9] and (v) vessels deliberately disguising their Russian provenance.[10] It also prohibits EU ports operators from providing access to ports and locks, meaning liability attaches to both the EU port operator as well as the vessel operator.
- Imposes quasi-secondary sanctions on any vessels used to breach EU sanctions, for instance, vessels that transport military goods and technology to Russia.[11] At present, the Sanctions Regulation lists 27 vessels,[12] 17 of which sail under the flag of a non-Russian country. Any vessel owned by an entity or individual could fall under the prohibition as the designation criteria is country- and owner-agnostic. Once listed, it is prohibited for any EU operator to deal with these vessels, including providing them with a crew, financing, insurance, access to ports and locks, engaging in ship-to-ship transfers, or flag registrations.[13]
These quasi-secondary sanctions raise the stake for non-EU maritime shipping operators. Whilst they may not be legally required to comply with EU sanctions, failure to do so could result in barring access to EU markets.
IV. Road transport restrictions
Russia-linked road transporters are prohibited from transporting goods by road to and from Russia, as well as in transit within the EU, specifically: (i) any road transporter established in Russia,[14] (ii) any physical trailer or semi-trailer itself registered in Russia,[15] and (iii) any road transporter owned 25 percent or more by a Russian entity or individual.[16] Further, the latter cannot be admitted as a road transport undertaking with the European Registers of Road Transport Undertakings.[17]
As with the other transportation industries, Member State authorities may request information on the road transport undertakings ownership structure, which must be provided. Given that even passive, non-controlling stakes held by Russian persons may result in a prohibition, all EU transporters should confirm that their shareholding does not include such Russian links.
V. Ancillary prohibitions
Beyond restrictions which are tied to the mode of transport, there are also restrictions which attach to (i) the content of the underlying freight, (ii) the local activities of Russian subsidiaries of EU transporters, and (iii) the counterparties of the transport.
Transfer restrictions - attached to the underlying freight
EU transporters are prohibited from transferring (directly or indirectly) certain goods, as listed in extensive annexes, including:
- Transferring (directly or indirectly) certain goods originating from the EU to Russia (e.g., sensitive goods and technologies[18]; various industrial goods[19]; luxury goods[20]; various goods and technology used in oil refining[21]; and banknotes in any official currency of a Member State[22]).
- Placing certain equipment[23] (regardless of origin) destined for Russia on board of a Russian-flagged vessel.[24] This means that even logistics providers (e.g., dock operators) could be liable for intra-EU trade (e.g., goods travelling from one Member State to another’s port before being shipped to Russia).
- Transferring various goods originating from the EU and transiting through Russia (e.g., sensitive goods and technologies[25] and motor engine components).[26] On that basis, the actual trade route may be determined by the types of goods involved.
- Transferring various goods originating from Russia to the EU (e.g., significant revenue generating goods, like chemical fertilizers[27] and gold, including gold that is processed in a third country, thus imposing due diligence obligations on the transporter to determine the gold’s provenance[28]).
- Transferring various goods originating from Russia to anywhere in the world (iron and steel products[29] and oil and petroleum products[30]). Similarly, Russian petroleum oils surpassing a certain price cap are prohibited from being transported to third countries, including via ship-to-ship transfers.[31] Where the purchase price per barrel is not available, the transporter must collect itemised price information for ancillary costs incurred by operators further up the supply chain.[32]
- Transferring cultural items from Ukraine to anywhere in the world, where there are reasonable grounds to believe these were illegally removed from Ukraine.[33]
- Providing (directly or indirectly) “ancillary services” related to the transport of sanctioned goods. Applied to the transportation industry, it could include services such as warehousing, reloading, transhipment, and freight forwarding, and even in some cases the provision of storage capacity.[34]
Restrictions on operating a transport business in Russia
Additionally, transporters with a significant Russian nexus may face additional ancillary restrictions, such as:
- For EU companies with Russian subsidiaries, a prohibition on the provision of ancillary services, such as accounting or auditing, to legal entities established in Russia is likely to hamper the ability to run a group effectively.[35]
- Many EU transportation companies are likely to fall under the definition of critical infrastructure[36] due to their importance in maintaining societal functioning. In light of this categorisation, no Russian nationals can sit on the company’s board or hold managerial positions.[37]
Restrictions on dealing with certain counterparties
Separately to the prohibition on the transfer of certain goods, it is prohibited to engage with certain individuals or entities, including those individuals who are subject to asset freezes under the Sanctions Regulation.[38] EU transporters should therefore ensure that they carry out the necessary “know-your-customer” checks on all parties involved in the logistics process to steer clear of potential damages.
The authors thank Tuula Petersen for her assistance in the preparation of this memo.
[1] Regulation (EU) 2024/1745 (“Reg 1745”).
[2] Article 12 of Regulation (EU) No. 833/2014 (“Reg 833”).
[3] Case C-71/11, Bundesrepublik Deutschland v Afrasiabi.
[4] Article 10 of Reg 833.
[5] Article 3c(3) of Reg 833.
[6] Article 3d(1) of Reg 833, as amended by Reg 1745.
[7] Article 3d(1a) of Reg 833, as amended by Reg 1745.
[8] Article 3ea of Reg 833, as amended by Reg 1745.
[9] Article 3eb of Reg 833.
[10] Article 3ec of Reg 833.
[11] Article 3s of Reg 833, as inserted by Reg 1745.
[12] Annex XLII to Reg 833, as amended by Reg 1745.
[13] Article 3s(1) of Reg 1745.
[14] Specifically, any natural or legal person, entity, or body engaged with a commercial purpose in the transport of freight by means of motor vehicles or combinations of vehicles.
[15] Article 3l(1) and (1a) of Reg 833.
[16] Article 3l(1b) and (1c) of Reg 833, as amended by Reg 1745.
[18] Articles 2(1), 2a(1), 2aa(1), 3c(1), 4, and 12(1) of and Annexes VII, XI, XX, XXXV, and XXXIII to Reg 833.
[19] Article 3k(1) of and Annex XXII to Reg 833.
[20] Article 3p(1), (2), (3), (4), and 3h(1) of and Annexes XVIII and XXXVIIIA to Reg 833, as amended by Reg 1745.
[21] Articles 3(1) and 3b(1) of and Annexes II and X to Reg 833.
[22] Article 5i of Reg 833.
[23] Annex XVI to Reg 833.
[24] Article 3f of Reg 833.
[25] Articles 2(1a), 2a(1a), 2aa(1a), and 3c(1a) of and Annexes VII, XI, XX, XXXV to Reg 833.
[26] Article 3k(1a) of and Annex XXXVII to Reg 833.
[27] Article 3i of and Annex XXI to Reg 833.
[28] Article 3o of and Annexes XXVI and XXVII to Reg 833.
[29] Article 3g(1c) of and Annex XVII to Reg 833.
[30] Article 3m(1) of and Annex XXV to Reg 833.
[31] Article 3n(4) and (5) of and Annex XXV to Reg 833.
[32] Article 3n(6a) of and Annex XXV to Reg 833.
[33] Article 3v of Reg 833, as inserted by Reg 1745.
[34] Article 5p of Reg 833.
[35] Article 5n of Reg 833.
[36] Article 2(a) of Council Directive 2008/114/EC and Article 2(4) of Directive (EU) 2022/2557.
[37] Article 5o of Reg 833.
[38] Article 5aa of and Annex XIX to Reg 833.
This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.