SEC Publishes Policy Statement Regarding Mandatory Arbitration Provisions
Client memorandum | September 29, 2025
Authors: Andrew Barkan (New York), Samuel Groner (New York), Daniel Liberman (New York), Kate St. Romain (Washington, DC), Peter Simmons (New York), Michael Sternheim (New York), Joshua Wechsler (New York)
On September 17, 2025, the Securities and Exchange Commission published a policy statement clarifying that inclusion of mandatory arbitration provisions in a company’s organizational documents will not influence the SEC’s decisions about whether to accelerate effectiveness of a company’s registration statement.[1] This clarification reflects a significant departure from the SEC’s prior—albeit unwritten—position that it could delay or block a securities offering if a company included a mandatory arbitration clause for securities law claims in its organizational documents.
Key Takeaways
- The SEC will no longer delay securities offerings solely based upon the inclusion of a mandatory arbitration provision in a company’s organizational documents.
- While this new policy provides clarity on the SEC’s current position, federal and state law issues will continue to cloud the picture, as some federal and state laws may prohibit mandatory arbitration of certain stockholder claims. For non-U.S. companies, local laws may raise similar issues.
- Inclusion of mandatory arbitration provisions in organizational documents by companies going public, or existing public companies, may face litigation challenges.
- Companies considering inclusion of a mandatory arbitration provision in their organizational documents should contact counsel to discuss the potential legal risks.
The SEC’s New Policy Statement
On September 17, 2025, the SEC announced that “decisions about whether to accelerate the effectiveness of a registration statement will not be affected by the presence” of mandatory arbitration provisions in a company’s organizational documents. SEC Chairman Paul Atkins emphasized that “while many people will express views on whether a company should adopt a mandatory arbitration provision, the Commission’s role in this debate is to provide clarity that such provisions are not inconsistent with the federal securities laws.” While this may be the SEC’s view, plaintiff-side firms have already stated that they intend to challenge the SEC’s position.
This policy statement represents a marked shift from the agency’s previous unwritten position that the SEC staff could delay or block a company’s access to U.S. public markets if a company included a mandatory arbitration clause for securities law claims in its organizational documents. This prior position appeared to be grounded in concerns that requiring arbitration, and thus eliminating a judicial forum in which a plaintiff could bring a securities claim, could run afoul of the federal securities anti-waiver provisions (Securities Act § 14 and Exchange Act § 29(a)).
Going forward, SEC staff will focus on the adequacy of registration statement disclosures, including disclosures regarding mandatory arbitration provisions, and not reject out of hand a company’s registration because its organizational documents contain a mandatory arbitration provision. This means it will be up to the company and its investors to determine whether to impose a mandatory arbitration provision.
Practical Considerations and Implications
Now that the SEC no longer prohibits a company from including a mandatory arbitration provision in its organizational documents, a company must evaluate a multitude of legal considerations—in addition to non-legal considerations, such as reputation and the need and ability to attract investors—when deciding whether to adopt a mandatory arbitration provision.
- State Law Considerations Remain Critical
Issuers may still face state statutory restrictions on including a mandatory arbitration provision. For example, Section 115(c) of the Delaware General Corporation Law, as recently amended, allows Delaware companies to include mandatory forum selection provisions in their charter or bylaws, but only as long as these provisions allow stockholders to bring direct claims in at least one court in the State of Delaware.[2] The SEC has acknowledged that new Section 115(c) may give pause to a Delaware corporation considering adoption of a mandatory arbitration provision.
Companies will need to carefully evaluate applicable state law before adopting mandatory arbitration provisions in their governing documents.
- Potential Limitations on Securities Class Actions
Adoption of a mandatory arbitration provision could substantially limit shareholders’ ability to pursue class action lawsuits challenging disclosures in a company’s SEC filings, instead channeling these disputes into individual arbitration proceedings. That would be a significant shift in the securities litigation landscape for public companies.
Potential benefits for issuers include avoiding class actions and allowing for potential control of litigation costs and exposure resulting from the securities offering process.
However, these benefits must be weighed with the potential drawbacks, including that actions brought through arbitration may lack the procedural protections imposed by the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act (“PSLRA”)—including the automatic stay of discovery while motions to dismiss are pending. Additionally, companies may still face mass arbitrations covering hundreds or even thousands of individual claims, which can result in substantial costs (including, for example, paying for the arbitrator in each of these cases). In addition, there is substantial uncertainty as to whether a mandatory arbitration provision in either a company’s bylaws or charter would be found by federal courts to be viable.
- Adopters of Mandatory Arbitration Provisions May Face Legal Challenges
Despite greater SEC regulatory policy guidance, significant legal uncertainties remain. Any companies considering whether to include a mandatory arbitration provision for securities law claims should note that plaintiffs’ law firms may litigate this issue and test the boundaries of the SEC’s new policy and the nexus between this new policy and federal and state law. Potential litigation could raise various legal questions, including:
- Whether state laws, such as Section 115(c) of the Delaware General Corporation Law, prohibit investors from implementing mandatory arbitration provisions;
- Whether the Federal Arbitration Act (“FAA”) preempts state laws that would otherwise require companies to allow investors to pursue claims in court;
- Whether mandatory arbitration provisions conflict with the anti-waiver and/or forum provisions of the Securities Act or the Exchange Act; and
- Whether a mandatory arbitration provision in a company’s bylaws and/or charter is sufficient to inform an investor that it is waiving its right to bring securities litigation in the courts.
* * *
Members of Fried Frank’s Securities Litigation and Capital Markets practices are available to provide guidance regarding the SEC’s announcement, or federal securities laws and regulations more generally.
[1] SEC Issues Policy Statement Clarifying that Mandatory Arbitration Provisions Will Not Affect Effectiveness of Registration Statements, U.S. SEC. & EXCH. COMM’N (Sep. 17, 2025), https://www.sec.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2025-120-sec-issues-policy-statement-clarifying-mandatory -arbitration-provisions-will-not-affect.
[2] 8 DEL. CODE ANN. Tit. 8, Section 115(c) states that “[w]ith respect to claims that are not internal corporate claims, the certificate of incorporation or bylaws may require stockholders, when acting in their capacity as stockholders or in the right of the corporation, to bring any or all such claims only in 1 or more prescribed forums or venues . . . and allows a stockholder to bring such claims in at least 1 court in this State that has jurisdiction over such claims” (emphasis added).
This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.