SEC Enforcement Action: Schedule 13D Disclosure Obligations Regarding Pledges and Other Arrangements Concerning Issuer Securities
Client memorandum | August 27, 2024
Introduction
On August 19, 2024, the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) announced that it had entered into a settled administrative cease-and-desist order against Carl Icahn for failures to amend his Schedule 13D disclosure regarding personal margin loan agreements, his wholly-owned entities’ entry into guaranty agreements in connection with the aforementioned loan agreements, and amendments thereto, and for failing to include those agreements as exhibits to Schedule 13D amendment filings.[1] The settlement of non-scienter-based charges, which also ordered the respondent to pay a civil penalty to the SEC in the amount of $500,000, highlights the need to carefully consider Schedule 13D disclosure obligations concerning contracts, arrangements, understandings or other relationships with respect to the subject issuer’s securities, particularly where pledges are involved, and the extent to which associated agreements must be filed as exhibits to Schedule 13D.
Facts Alleged by the SEC
The SEC’s enforcement order concerns alleged disclosure failures in connection with Schedule 13D filings, and amendments thereto, by Mr. Icahn in connection with his depositary unit holdings of public company issuer Icahn Enterprises L.P. (“IEP”). According to the SEC, Icahn acquired control of IEP’s predecessor in 1990 and since that time has been, along with his wholly-owned entities, the controlling shareholder of IEP, owning approximately 85% to 92% of IEP’s outstanding depositary units during that period. Icahn also has since 1990 been the Chairman of the Board of IEP’s general partner, and a named executive officer of IEP.
As the beneficial owner of more than 5% of IEP’s outstanding depositary units, Icahn and his wholly-owned entities were required to file Schedule 13D with the SEC, which they did on September 24, 1990. That initial Schedule 13D had been amended several times, including during 1995, 2003 and 2005 when Icahn filed amendments disclosing that he and his affiliates had pledged certain IEP depositary units as collateral for personal margin loans. For example, Amendment No. 25 to Schedule 13D filed on August 29, 2003 includes disclosure in Item 6 that states, “Depositary Units and Preferred Units are collateral for loans to Mr. Icahn, including a loan from the Issuer which comes due on December 27, 2003.”[2] Similarly, Item 6 of Amendment No. 26 to Schedule 13D contained disclosure stating, “Certain Depositary Units and Preferred Units described herein have been pledged as collateral for loans to Mr. Icahn and his affiliates.”[3] Despite these disclosures, the SEC’s order notes that Icahn “failed to disclose the amount of units pledged or describe the terms of any agreements.”[4]
The SEC order goes on to allege that, from at least December 31, 2018 through December 31, 2022, Icahn entered into no less than eleven margin loan agreements and amendments with a number of lenders in which he pledged assets including IEP depositary units.[5] According to the SEC, the outstanding principal amounts of these individual loans ranged in value from $150 million to $1.8 billion and, in the event that the closing market price of IEP depositary units dropped by certain specified amounts, margin calls could be triggered. In addition, certain of Icahn’s wholly-owned entities purportedly entered into agreements to guarantee these obligations, including through delivery of the pledged collateral; the IEP depositary units pledged were significant, ranging from 51% to 65% of the total IEP units outstanding.
Despite purportedly entering into numerous margin loan agreements and amendments after 2005, Icahn did not file any Schedule 13D amendments “describing his margin loan agreements or amendments” until July 10, 2023. On that date, Icahn and his wholly-owned entities entered into an amended and consolidated margin loan agreement (the “Amended Margin Loan Agreement”) with a number of lenders in the total amount of approximately $3.7 billion.
On the same day, Icahn and his wholly-owned entities filed an Amendment No. 70 to Schedule 13D disclosing that, among other things, the Amended Margin Loan Agreement “extend[ed] the maturity of certain of the previous loans, amends certain covenants, charges interest at a variable rate, and provides for a principal payment of $500 million on or before September 1, 2023, quarterly principal payments of $87.5 million beginning in September 2024, and a final principal payment of $2.5 billion at the end of the term.”[6] The Amendment No. 70 to Schedule 13D separately disclosed that the obligations under the loan agreement were “secured by pledges of an aggregate of 320 million [depositary units] owned by [Icahn] and $2 billion of interests owned by [Icahn] in the private investment funds managed by [IEP].” According to the SEC, the loan agreement guarantees were secured through an omnibus guaranty and security agreement (the “Omnibus Guaranty Agreement”). No exhibits were filed with Amendment No. 70 to Schedule 13D.
How much information is required to be disclosed under Schedule 13D Item 6 is subject to some interpretation, but it is clear that, in the view of the SEC, such disclosure requires at a minimum a description of any “contracts, arrangements, understandings, or relationships (legal or otherwise) among the reporting persons on a Schedule 13D and between such persons and any person with respect to any securities of the issuer,” and must include “such information for any of the securities that are pledged or otherwise subject to a contingency the occurrence of which would give another person voting power or investment power over such securities except that disclosure of standard default and similar provisions contained in loan agreements need not be included.”[7]
In its order, the SEC acknowledged with apparent approval that Amendment No. 70 to Schedule 13D disclosed “the names of the lenders, the principal payments owed, amount of IEP depositary units and interest in the IEP Funds pledged as collateral, and [a] general description of a default event.”
However, the SEC took issue with the fact that, although Icahn described the general terms of the Amended Margin Loan Agreement in Amendment No. 70 to Schedule 13D, he did not file the Omnibus Guaranty Agreement pursuant to Item 7, which requires “copies of all written agreements, contracts, arrangements, understanding, plans or proposals relating to: …(3) …guarantees of loans…” to be filed as exhibits.[8] The SEC also took issue with the fact that Icahn had not amended his Schedule 13D disclosure between 2005 and 2023 to reflect material changes to the facts reported under Item 6 concerning his personal margin loan agreements and associated amendments thereto, despite having entered into numerous margin loan agreements and amendments dating back to at least December 31, 2018. The SEC characterized the absence of such amendments as violating Exchange Act Section 13(d)(2) and Rule 13d-2(a).
Conclusion
Schedule 13D disclosures require a close analysis of the relevant statutes and regulations, as well as assessment of the relevant SEC guidance. Item 6 and Item 7 disclosure, in particular, can present difficult line drawing exercises when determining which information must be disclosed or when an amendment is required. The terms of collateral arrangements and borrowing arrangements used to fund the purchase of the reported securities (as described in Item 3 of Schedule 13D) can be particularly sensitive. A Schedule 13D filer’s financing sources may have their own concerns about disclosing the terms on which they have made loans. Nevertheless, filers should weigh these obligations carefully, as the SEC’s view, as expressed clearly in the Icahn order, is that individuals “retain legal responsibility for compliance with the filing requirements, including the obligation to assure that the filing is accurately made.”[9] In some contexts, it may be appropriate to consider making prophylactic disclosure to the SEC, while seeking confidential treatment to shield specific commercially-sensitive terms (such as loan-to-value maintenance requirements) from public review.
This memorandum is not intended to provide legal advice, and no legal or business decision should be based on its contents. If you have any questions about the contents of this memorandum, please call your regular Fried Frank contact or an attorney listed on this memo.
[1] See Press Release, SEC Charges Carl Icahn and Icahn Enterprises L.P. for Failing to Disclose Pledges of Company’s Securities as Collateral for Billions in Personal Loans, available at, https://www.sec.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2024-99; In the Matter of Carl C. Icahn, Ex. Act Rel. No. 100756 (Aug. 19, 2024), available at, https://www.sec.gov/files/litigation/admin/2024/34-100756.pdf. In a related administrative settlement announced the same day, the SEC settled charges against the issuer of the securities that were the subject of Mr. Icahn’s Schedule 13D, a public company issuer controlled by him through his ownership and his position as Chairman of the Board of Directors of its general partner, for its failures to disclose his pledges in its own disclosures, in violation of Exchange Act Section 13(a) and Rule 13a-1 thereunder. The SEC alleged that Item 403(b) of Regulation S-K requires public company issuers to disclose in Part III of Form 10-K information about the security ownership of management, including the amount of any pledged securities. See In the Matter of Icahn Enterprises L.P., Ex. Act Rel. No. 100755 (Aug. 19, 2024), available at, https://www.sec.gov/files/litigation/admin/2024/34-100755.pdf.
[2] See Amendment No. 25 to Schedule 13D, American Real Estate Partners, L.P. (the predecessor issuer to Icahn Enterprises L.P.), (Aug. 29, 2003), available at https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/813762/000092847503000135/amendment25.txt.
[3] See Amendment No. 26 to Schedule 13D, American Real Estate Partners, L.P. (the predecessor issuer to Icahn Enterprises L.P.), (Feb. 1, 2005) available at https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/813762/000095012305000999/y05331dsc13dza.txt.
[4] Although the disclosures in 1995, 2003 and 2005 did not form the basis for the SEC’s charges, the agency’s order appears to cite these earlier purported disclosure failures as scene-setting for the later disclosure violations cited. The SEC is subject to a general five year statute of limitations in matters seeking civil penalties, which would have put any claim for a penalty related to these earlier disclosures outside of the reach of the SEC’s enforcement authority. See 28 U.S.C. § 2462.
[5] Although the SEC alleged that Icahn entered into “dozens” of such agreements dating back to 2005, only those entered into after December 31, 2018 were the subject of the SEC’s alleged violations.
[6] See Amendment No. 70 to Schedule 13D, Icahn Enterprises L.P. (July 10, 2023), available at https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/n2779_x153-sc13da.htm/000153949723001199/0001539497-23-001199-index.html.
[7] See 17 CFR § 240.13d-101 (Schedule 13D—Information to be included in statements filed pursuant to § 240.13d-1(a) and amendments thereto filed pursuant to § 240.13d-2(a)).
[9] The Icahn order underscores this point by noting that Icahn had represented to the SEC that he had “disclosed his various margin loan agreements and amendments to his advisors.” Despite these protestations, the SEC stated that Icahn’s disclosures did not excuse his violations because an individual retains legal responsibility for compliance and scienter is not an element of such violations.
This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.