SEC and FinCEN Propose Customer Identification Requirements for Investment Advisers
Client memorandum | May 20, 2024
Authors: Michael T. Gershberg, Michael L. Sherman, Gregory Bernstein, Tyler Kaufman
On May 13, 2024 the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) and the U.S. Department of the Treasury’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (“FinCEN”) issued a joint proposed rule (the “Proposed Rule”) that would require SEC-registered investment advisers (“RIAs”) and exempt reporting advisers (“ERAs”) to establish, document, and maintain written customer identification programs (“CIPs”)[1] with the goal of preventing illicit financial activity involving the customers of investment advisers. This latest Proposed Rule builds on a previous proposed rule issued by FinCEN in February of this year that would include ERAs and RIAs in the definition of “financial institution” for purposes of the Bank Secrecy Act’s AML compliance obligations, and therefore require investment advisers to implement an AML/countering the financing of terrorism ("AML/CFT") program, file Suspicious Activity Reports (“SARs”) and maintain records relating to the transmittal of funds. Public comments on the Proposed Rule may be submitted until July 22, 2024.
Overview of the Proposed Rule
The Proposed Rule would require ERAs and RIAs to establish CIP procedures reasonably designed to accurately verify the identity of customers, provide notice to customers of CIP procedures, and maintain records relating to customer identity. Notably, the Proposed Rule would not subject investment advisers to the requirements of FinCEN’s 2016 Customer Due Diligence Rule that requires certain financial institutions to verify the identity of legal entity customers’ beneficial owners. For example, investment advisors would only have to collect information on private fund customers and not any underlying investors in those private funds. Under the Proposed Rule:
- Identity Verification Procedures. CIP procedures adopted by ERAs and RIAs would need to include risk-based procedures for verifying the identity of customers, to the extent reasonable and practicable, within a reasonable time before or shortly after a customer’s account is opened. The CIP verification procedures would apply each time a customer opens an account with an ERA or RIA unless the investment adviser had previously verified the customer’s identity to the extent required by the Proposed Rule and continues to hold the reasonable belief that it knows the true identity of the customer based on its previous verification. CIP procedures would be tailored to an assessment of relevant risks including (but not limited to) (1) the types of accounts maintained by the ERA or RIA; (2) the methods for opening accounts provided by the ERA or RIA; (3) the types of identifying customer information made available to the ERA or RIA; and (4) the ERA’s or RIA’s (i) size, (ii) location, and (iii) customer base.
- Customer Information Required. CIP procedures would require the ERA or RIA to obtain, at a minimum, each customer’s (1) name, (2) date of birth for an individual or the date of formation for any person other than an individual, (3) address, and (4) identification number. ERAs and RIAs would need to make a risk-based assessment for when to require additional information beyond the minimum requirements. Under the Proposed Rule, “customer” is defined as a person that enters a contractual or other business relationship with an investment adviser under which the investment adviser provides investment advisory services. As a result, an ERA’s or RIA’s customers would include the direct accounts and private funds they advise but not the beneficial owners of those accounts or the investors in those private funds.
- Customer Verification. The ERA or RIA would need to develop CIP procedures related to verifying the accuracy of information provided by customers in a timely manner that would allow for a mix of documentary and non-documentary verification options.
- Additional Verification for Certain Customers. ERAs and RIAs would be required to maintain CIP procedures that account for instances when the investment adviser cannot verify the identity of a natural person with authority or control over a customer who is not a natural person without additional information. In the aforementioned instances under the Proposed Rule, CIP procedures would require (1) that an ERA or RIA identify customers that are not individuals that pose a heightened risk of not being properly identified and (2) that an ERA’s or RIA’s CIP prescribe additional measures that may be used to obtain information about individuals with authority or control over the account to verify the customer’s identity when standard documentary or non-documentary methods prove to be insufficient.
- Lack of Verification. CIP procedures adopted by ERAs or RIAs would need to include procedures for responding to circumstances where it is not possible for the ERA or RIA to establish a reasonable belief as to the true identity of a customer. This includes procedures regarding when an ERA or RIA should close the account of a customer whose identity cannot be verified and file a SAR with FinCEN.
- Recordkeeping and Retention Requirements. CIP procedures adopted by ERAs or RIAs would have to provide for (1) the recording of information used in customer identity verification and (2) the maintenance of the aforementioned information over the lifetime of the customer’s account with the ERA or RIA and for five years following the account’s closure (i.e., consistent with Rule 204-2 (the “Books and Records Rule”) promulgated under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940).
- Comparison with Government Lists. A CIP developed by ERAs or RIAs under the Proposed Rule would have to include reasonable procedures for verifying if a customer appears on any list of known or suspected terrorists or terrorist organizations issued by any Federal government agency. ERAs and RIAs would not be required to seek out all lists of known or suspected terrorists or terrorist organizations and will instead be provided with a notification from the Federal government regarding the lists of known or suspected terrorists that investment advisers must refer to as part of their customer verification process.
- Customer Notice. CIP procedures implemented by ERAs or RIAs would need to account for the provision of notice to the customers from whom the investment adviser is requesting identity information. The notice provided to the customer would need to generally describe the information required under the Proposed Rule and be provided in a manner that is reasonably designed for the customer to actually see it.
- Exemptions. The SEC or the Secretary of the Treasury may, with the concurrence of the other party, decide to exempt any ERA or RIA or any type of account from the requirements of the Proposed Rule. Additionally, ERAs and RIAs would not have to apply the CIP procedures required by the Proposed Rule to mutual fund customers if the mutual funds have already developed and implemented their own CIP procedures that comply with existing AML/CFT requirements.
Reliance on Other Financial Institutions
Under the Proposed Rule, ERAs and RIAs may rely on other regulated financial institutions to perform any of the procedures included in their CIP with respect to a customer that is also a customer of the other financial institution, provided that:
- such reliance is reasonable under the circumstances;
- the other financial institution is subject to a rule implementing the AML/CFT compliance program requirements of 31 U.S.C. 5318(h) and is regulated by a Federal functional regulator; and
- the other financial institution enters into a contract with the ERA or RIA requiring it to certify annually that it has implemented an AML/CFT program and will perform (or its agent will perform) the specified requirements of the ERA’s or RIA’s CIP.
ERAs or RIAs would remain responsible for ensuring compliance with the Proposed Rule and would be expected to actively monitor the implementation of their CIPs. However, ERAs and RIAs would not be held responsible for the failure to implement CIP responsibilities properly delegated to other financial institutions provided that the ERA or RIA has met the criteria above. Currently, many ERAs and RIAs outsource portions of their voluntary AML and “know-your customer” programs to third parties that would not satisfy the requirements of the Proposed Rule’s reliance provisions (e.g., administrators that are not regulated financial institutions and non-U.S. based administrators). Investment advisers will likely be unable to rely solely on such third parties to satisfy their CIP obligations. Nonetheless, it is anticipated that investment advisers would still be able to outsource many of the tasks involved in the CIP program to third parties, but the investment adviser would remain legally liable for the maintenance and implementation of the CIP program.
Key Takeaways
The Proposed Rule builds upon FinCEN’s recent proposal to require ERAs and RIAs to maintain an AML/CFT program and file SARs. It also comes in the wake of FinCEN releasing its 2024 Investment Advisor Risk Assessment, which noted that investment advisers “have served as an entry point into the U.S. market for illicit proceeds associated with foreign corruption, fraud, and tax evasion, as well as billions of dollars ultimately controlled by Russian oligarchs and their associates.”
The Proposed Rule underscores both FinCEN’s and the SEC’s focus on anti-money laundering, which has also been a priority for Congress and the executive branch in recent years. Many investment advisers already implement some or all of the CIP requirements included in the Proposed Rule. This may be due to many investment advisers implementing a compliance program currently required by an affiliated financial institution (e.g., a broker-dealer) because the procedures are required or expected by other regulators or as risk mitigation best practices. However, all investment advisers -- including those that have voluntarily adopted an AML/CFT program -- should review that program and the Proposed Rule with an eye towards implementing a compliant CIP in advance of the final rule.
[1] CIPs are defined by Section 326 of the Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism (“USA PATRIOT Act”), Subsection 31 U.S.C. 5318(l)(2) as the procedures for “(A) verifying the identity of any person seeking to open an account to the extent reasonable and practicable; (B) maintaining records of the information used to verify the person’s identity, including name, address, and other identifying information; and (C) consulting lists of known or suspected terrorists or terrorist organizations provided to the financial institution by any government agency to determine whether a person seeking to open an account appears on any such list.”
This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.