Q1 2024 – European Regulatory Update for Funds
Client memorandum | March 28, 2024
Authors: Gregg Beechey, Zac Mellor-Clark, Emirali Mustafa
The first quarter of 2024 saw a continued slew of regulatory updates. Going into spring, private fund managers active in and/or marketing into Europe will want to be alive to the developments below:
- AIFMD II
- ELTIF Regulation
- FCA review of AIFM Host Model
- CS3D
1. AIFMD 2 published in the Official Journal
After years of anticipation, on 26 March 2024 the Amending Directive to the EU Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive (AIFMD 2) was finally published in the Official Journal of the European Union (EU).
Consequently, AIFMD 2 will now enter into force on 15 April 2024, which generally gives EU Member States until 16 April 2026 to adopt such national measures as are necessary to adopt AIFMD 2 into national law.
For an overview of the key changes introduced under AIFMD II, please refer to our publication “AIFMD2: The next (r)evolution?” released in November 2023 based on the unofficial final text.
In terms of next steps, the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) has been mandated to produce several “Level 2” regulatory technical standards (RTS) to build out the rules in AIFMD 2 on key topics, including loan-originating AIFs, liquidity management techniques and Annex IV reporting. It has also been mandated to produce a number of reports on important issues such as delegation. We are monitoring these developments closely and intend to share further details of these measures and reports as they are released.
2. European Commission publishes proposed amendments to ESMA’s draft RTS to the ELTIF Regulation
On 19 December 2023, ESMA published its final report setting out draft RTS supplementing the Amended European Long-Term Investment Funds Regulation (ELTIF 2.0).
ESMA’s draft RTS address a number of key issues in the context of open-ended ELTIFs (which ELTIF 2.0 was intended to promote), including the minimum holding period of an ELTIF, the maximum redemption frequency, an AIFM’s choice of liquidity management tools and the notice period and maximum percentage of liquidity assets that can be redeemed (amongst other things).
The draft RTS was considered by many industry participants to be unworkable. The level of detail included in the RTS was significant, but of particular concern was the default 12-month minimum notice requirement for redemptions. Whilst derogations were available, those derogations were based on (1) the minimum percentage of liquid assets held by the ELTIF and (2) the maximum percentage of liquid assets that may be used to meet redemption requests. For illustration, for redemption notice periods of 1–3 months, pursuant to ESMA’s draft RTS, the ELTIF was required to hold a minimum of 40% of liquid assets, and a maximum of 35% of those liquid assets were permitted to be used to meet redemptions. These measures were considered to be out of line with market practice and disruptive to industry.
Following a significant amount of industry lobbying, on 6 March 2024 the European Commission published its proposed amendments to ESMA’s draft RTS. Notably, this removes the default 12-month minimum notice requirement for redemptions. The rules prescribe two methodologies for determining the maximum percentage of liquid assets that may be used to meet redemption requests, which in turn prescribe correlations between redemption frequency and the size of the liquidity buffer. The rules are complex, but the initial industry consensus appears to be that whilst the Commission’s draft RTS are not perfect, they are a significant improvement on ESMA’s draft.
ESMA has until 17 April 2024 to amend the draft RTS and resubmit them to the Commission for adoption. Whilst the fate of the open-ended ELTIF model rests on the final version of the RTS, developments now appear to be trending in an encouraging direction.
3. FCA review of the AIFM Host Model
AIFMs may use the host model to employ staff on secondment from third parties to assist with carrying out certain functions related to managing an AIF (e.g. portfolio management of the AIF’s assets or customer facing administrative jobs) (AIFM Host Model).
In 2023, the FCA reviewed the AIFM Host Model and looked at how well AIFMs understood and complied with the associated regulatory responsibilities (the 2023 Review). In particular, the FCA focused on situations where the AIFM acts as a principal firm and the persons seconded to the AIFM come from one of its appointed representatives (ARs).
On 25 March 2024, the UK’s Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) published its findings from the 2023 Review. In summary, it found instances of potential harm arising from:
- a lack of sufficient oversight of seconded staff (in particular, given that seconded staff were supervised remotely in most instances and were not physically working at the offices of the AIFM);
- insufficient involvement in investor due diligence and the fact that most of the AIFMs reviewed were not directly involved in investor onboarding checks; and
- inadequacies in capital adequacy calculations of the AIFM (given, in most instances, that the AIFM reviewed did not directly factor in the number of AIFs they manage or ARs that they are a principal of when calculating their capital requirements).
We expect the results of the 2023 Review to lead to increased scrutiny of AIFMs in the UK employing the AIFM Host Model, which may well lead to further operational friction for those managers that make use of third-party AIFMs in the jurisdiction.
4. Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CS3D)
Following a protracted negotiation process, in December 2023, the Council of the European Union (the Council) and the European Parliament (EP) announced that they had reached political agreement on the drafting of the CS3D. Broadly, the aim of CS3D is to foster sustainable and responsible corporate behaviour by obligating in-scope companies to adopt tighter scrutiny of their supply chains. In February 2024, however, the Council failed to reach a qualified majority required to endorse the previously ‘agreed on’ text of the CS3D, casting the future of the CS3D into doubt.
Yet, in what could represent a significant turn of events, on 15 March 2024 the Council proposed a compromise text of CS3D to the EP, and has explicitly confirmed that it would adopt the text (allowing it to become law) should the EP also adopt it. The revised CS3D has now been added as an item on the EP plenary agenda for adoption on 24 April 2024.
Some key changes in the revised text are:
- Scope. Under the Council’s proposed changes, the scope of companies required to comply with the CS3D is significantly more limited compared to the version of the text previously agreed to in December.
- High-risk sectors. The Council’s proposed text does not provide for different thresholds or other provisions applying to companies operating in high-risk sectors.
- Chain of activity. In terms of the scope of the due diligence obligations that entities subject to CS3D must comply with, the Council’s proposed text replaces the previous “value chain” concept with the more tightly drafted ‘chain of activities’ definition. The revised text also specifically confirms, for ‘regulated financial undertakings’ (which includes AIFMs), that the ‘chain of activities’ definition does not include downstream business partners, which means that an AIFM’s downstream activities would not be in scope of CS3D.
- Due diligence obligations. The Council’s proposed text contains new/expanded due diligence obligations.
- Climate transition plan. In-scope companies are required to prepare, implement and annually update a climate transition plan.
- Directors’ duties. The duty of care that directors were previously subject to, as well as their responsibility for setting up/overseeing the due diligence obligations, has been scaled back.
Please contact one of the team if you have any questions in respect of the above.
This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.