FTC Finalizes Rule Banning Employee Non-Competes
Client memorandum | April 25, 2024
Authors: Jeffrey Ross, Jason Ertel, Amy Blackman, Peter Simmons, Barry Nigro, Nathaniel Asker, Aleksandr Livshits, Nathaniel Bronstein, Madison Chajson
After a 3-2 vote along party lines, the Federal Trade Commission issued a final rule banning most employee non-compete agreements.[1] The rule could go into effect as soon as late August, and bans both new and existing non-competes—other than those entered into with “senior executives” prior to the effective date. The rule also contains a broad exception for non-competes related to a sale of a business or business interests.
Multiple parties have already filed litigation challenging the FTC’s authority to issue the rule. We expect that these parties will seek an injunction barring the FTC from enforcing the rule and preserving the status quo pending resolution of the litigation. If not enjoined, the new non-compete rule will present substantial challenges for companies seeking to safeguard their proprietary assets and to deter free-riding on their investments. Given the legal challenges to the rule, however, and in light of expected ongoing developments in this area, companies should not be quick to change their existing business practices and should instead discuss potential strategies and options with counsel.
Key Aspects of the Final Rule
- Broad Application: The rule imposes a broad ban on almost all non-competes between employers and workers, deeming these types of agreements to be an “unfair method of competition” in violation of Section 5 of the FTC Act. Under the rule, a “non-compete” is a term or condition that “prohibits a worker from, penalizes a worker for, or functions to prevent a worker from” working for a different person or operating a business after the conclusion of the employment. The expansive language thus prohibits not only terms that specifically block other employment opportunities, but also prohibits agreements that would be deemed to have the same effect (such as “forfeiture-for-competition” clauses).
- The Rule Allows Non-Competes Related to a Sale of a Business or Business Interests: The final rule includes an exception to the general ban on non-competes where the non-compete clause is entered into by a person in connection with a bona fide sale of any of the following: (1) a business entity, (2) the person’s ownership interest in a business entity, or (3) all or substantially all of a business entity’s assets. This broad exception should allow for many of the types of non-competes typically entered into in connection with M&A transactions. Notably, this exception is substantially broader than what was proposed in the FTC’s draft rule published last year, which only exempted from the non-compete ban “substantial owners”—individuals holding 25% or more of the business being sold. Existing federal and state antitrust and other laws continue to apply to non-competes that are not banned by the rule. Parties should be mindful that many non-competes entered in connection with HSR-reportable transactions are required to be submitted to the FTC and the DOJ with the HSR filings.
- Existing Non-Competes with “Senior Executives” May Remain in Effect: The final rule also grandfathers in non-competes with “senior executives” that are in effect as of the effective date of the rule. Although this exception broadly permits all pre-existing non-competes with “senior executives,” the definition of “senior executives” is complex and is intended to apply very narrowly. Among other requirements to qualify, a worker must serve in a “policy-making position” of a common enterprise, which raises the question of whether subsidiary-level executives would qualify. Non-competes with “senior executives” entered into after the rule takes effect would still be banned.
[1] For more on the FTC’s proposed rule banning non-competes issued January 5, 2023, see our client alert on the subject: No More Employee Noncompetes? (Jan. 13, 2023).
This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.