Skip to main content

Fried Frank Team Files Amicus Brief with North Dakota Supreme Court Arguing Right to Abortion Care Flows from State Constitutional Right to Self-Defense

Press releases | February 13, 2025

In 2007, the North Dakota Legislature enacted a trigger ban that would criminalize all abortions in the state if and when the United States Supreme Court issued any decision that authorized states to prohibit abortion. Fifteen years later, in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, 597 U.S. 215 (2022), the United States Supreme Court did just that. The trigger ban never took effect, however, because a women’s health clinic and group of medical providers moved to enjoin its enforcement. The matter went to the North Dakota Supreme Court, which found that the trigger ban violated the North Dakota Constitution because it lacked any exceptions for the life and health of the mother. One justice, writing in concurrence, noted that the ban was unconstitutional for the additional reason that it violated the right to self-defense guaranteed in Article I, Section 1 of the North Dakota Constitution. 

The North Dakota Legislature returned to the drawing board. In 2023, it enacted a revised abortion ban. This version of the law created some limited exceptions, including for abortions deemed necessary by a reasonably prudent physician and that were intended to prevent death or serious health risks (not including a psychological or emotional condition) to the pregnant person. The women’s health clinic and group of medical providers that challenged the original ban amended their complaint and challenged the new statute.

Following discovery, the State moved for summary judgment, and lost. The North Dakota trial court granted summary judgment in favor of the women’s health clinic and medical providers.  The trial court found that the revised abortion law violated the North Dakota Constitution, although it did not base its decision (or even mention) the constitutional right to self-defense. The State appealed to the North Dakota Supreme Court.

On February 5, 2025, a Fried Frank pro bono team filed an amicus brief in the Supreme Court of North Dakota arguing that the revised abortion statute unconstitutionally abridges the self-defense rights of pregnant women by failing to recognize that every pregnancy, even a medically uncomplicated pregnancy, causes or threatens to cause serious bodily injury (as that term is defined by North Dakota law). As such, the limited exceptions provided by North Dakota’s abortion statute impermissibly circumscribe the self-defense rights of pregnant women. The brief was filed on behalf of three prominent professors, Eileen McDonagh, Linda McClain and James Fleming, whose scholarship has focused on the intersection between the constitutional right to reproductive freedom and self-defense. 

The Fried Frank pro bono team that prepared the brief included partner Janice Mac Avoy, partner-elect Katherine St. Romain, special counsel Laura Israel Sinrod, associates Elizabeth Kalanchoe and Rachel Demma, and law clerk Shelley Payne.

This amicus brief, submitted in the case Access Independent Health Services, Inc., d/b/a Red River Women’s Clinic et al. v. Wrigley, is available here.


This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.