Fried Frank Obtains Litigation Victory in the Delaware Court of Chancery
Press releases | August 6, 2026
On August 6, 2026, Fried Frank obtained a complete victory in the Delaware Court of Chancery for Odfjell SE, one of Norway’s oldest and most successful chemical tanker and terminal operators, and its affiliates in litigation, brought by NCP US Terminals LP, an entity affiliated with Northleaf Capital Partners, concerning Odfjell Terminals US Holdings LLC (OTUS).
Odfjell owns 51% of OTUS and operates the business. NCP US Terminals LP owns the remaining 49%.
The dispute, NCP US Terminals LP v. Odfjell Terminals US Holdings, LLC, arose in late 2024 when Northleaf withheld consent to an amendment and extension of OTUS’s debt facility ahead of its pending maturity, while also demanding additional distributions. At the outset of the litigation, Odfjell sought relief to address the debt facility. The Court first granted Odfjell relief through the appointment of a limited-purpose custodian, which enabled OTUS to amend and extend the facility.
Northleaf then expedited claims, resulting in an extensive discovery and trial. Northleaf alleged that Odfjell was required to support additional borrowing by OTUS to fund distributions and also sought judicial dissolution based on alleged board deadlock and dysfunction.
After a four-day trial in the Delaware Court of Chancery, Chancellor Kathaleen McCormick ruled in favor of Odfjell on all counts. The Court rejected Northleaf’s breach of contract and implied covenant claims, holding that the LLC agreement did not require leveraged distributions or require OTUS to borrow money to fund distributions. The Court found that Northleaf was seeking to enforce a contractual right for which it had not bargained.
In rejecting Northleaf’s leveraged-distribution theory, the Court credited testimony that Odfjell had historically taken a conservative approach to leverage, including a preference for a strong balance sheet and lower leverage to withstand downturns in the cyclical terminals business. The Court also observed that borrowing money to pay distributions does not benefit OTUS itself, but its owners.
The Court likewise rejected Northleaf’s request for judicial dissolution. The opinion noted that Northleaf wanted an exit from its OTUS investment, but concluded that it was not the Court’s obligation to rescue Northleaf from its position and that Northleaf’s predicament did not justify the extreme relief of judicial dissolution.
The Fried Frank team representing Odfjell included litigation partners Michael C. Keats and Rebecca L. Martin; litigation special counsel Anne S. Aufhauser; and litigation associates Harrison D. Polans, Gabriella Carnazza, Shelley Payne and Wellington Baumann. The firm represented Odfjell together with Young Conaway Stargatt & Taylor, as local counsel.
Read the opinion here.
This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.