Skip to main content

Fried Frank Achieves Favorable Settlement for Pioneer Investment Management USA, UniCredit Bank and Vanderbilt Capital Advisors

Press releases | June 6, 2017

On June 6, 2017, a New Mexico state court approved -- over the objections of a qui tam relator -- a contested settlement between firm clients Unicredit S.p.A., Pioneer Investment Management USA Inc., and Vanderbilt Capital Advisors, LLC and the State of Mexico concerning allegations of having obtained tens of millions of dollars of state investment money by fraudulent means. The relator brought the qui tam action ostensibly on behalf of two New Mexico state agencies, under the state’s analogue to the False Claims Act, purporting to seek between US$350 million and US$1 billion in claimed damages. Parallel class and derivative lawsuits were subsequently brought by other plaintiffs in federal court on the same issues.  The lawsuits alleged that our clients committed securities fraud in marketing various CDO-related investments to a state pension fund and another state agency, both by misrepresenting the nature and risks of the investment and by participating in a pay-to-play scheme.  Our clients maintained that the state took a calculated business risk with investments that simply failed to withstand the unprecedented financial crisis of 2007-09, and that their dealings with the various state participants were entirely proper and customary. Following years of motion practice and appeals through several levels of state and federal courts, we structured a global settlement directly with the state agencies and the Attorney General, bypassing the relator, who claimed that the US$24.25 million settlement was inadequate compared to the hundreds of millions of dollars that state supposedly should be able to recover.  The court conducted a four day live witness hearing and took hundreds of pages of briefing, and after considering the matter for nearly a year, adopted all the key points we urged and approved the settlement as fair, adequate, and reasonable, bringing this eight yearlong litigation nearer to a close (subject to a possible appeal by the relator).  Working on the case were litigation partners Peter Simmons and Samuel Groner and litigation associate Alejandra Avila.


This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.