Final and Proposed Regulations Provide Guidance on the U.S. Taxation of Foreign Governments
December 16, 2025
By Brett Fieldston, Colin S. Kelly, Vadim Novik, David I. Shapiro, and Libin Zhang
On December 12, Treasury and the IRS released final and proposed regulations under Section 892 of the Internal Revenue Code addressing the U.S. taxation of foreign governments. The new regulations include both favorable guidance and new limitations on a number of aspects of the operation of Section 892.
In particular, the final regulations build upon the prior proposed regulations and contain changes that offer welcome relief for foreign sovereign investors with respect to certain rules imposed under current law (e.g., the impact of real estate investments on the status of a foreign sovereign’s controlled entities) and helpfully clarify several areas of lingering uncertainty (e.g., the treatment of derivatives). However, the new proposed regulations set forth broad rules regarding when debt acquisitions constitute “commercial activities” and when a foreign government has “effective control” of an entity. We expect that these, and potentially other aspects of the proposed regulations, will be the subject of further discussion and may be a topic for further guidance.
I. Background
Foreign governments are generally exempt from U.S. federal income tax on income received from investments in stocks, bonds, or other domestic securities; financial instruments held in the execution of governmental financial or monetary policy; and deposit interest. However, this exemption does not apply to any income:
- derived from the conduct of any commercial activity (whether within or outside the United States);
- received by or from (directly or indirectly) a controlled commercial entity (a “CCE”); or
- derived from the disposition of any interest in a CCE.
A CCE is generally any entity engaged (including by attribution) in commercial activities (whether within or outside the United States) if the foreign government holds (directly or indirectly) more than 50% of any interests in the entity, by vote or value, or holds (directly or indirectly) any “other interest” in the entity which provides it with “effective control” of the entity.
Under the CCE rule in the statute, among other consequences, an entity wholly owned by a foreign sovereign and otherwise entitled to the benefits of Section 892 would lose its Section 892 exemption with respect to all of its income if it engages in any amount of commercial activities anywhere in the world.
Prior regulations, published in 1988 and 2011, provided some relief, but left many questions unanswered on this and other aspects of Section 892. Moreover, the prior regulations predated many recent market developments in investment funds, real estate, and financial services.
II. Executive Summary
As discussed further below, the new regulations:
- Remove a per se rule that treated a foreign corporation as a CCE if the corporation owned sufficient U.S. real property interests and was controlled by a foreign government;
- Clarify that many market-standard derivatives are included in the definition of “financial instruments,” which generally do not give rise to commercial activity income and, if held in the execution of governmental financial or monetary policy, qualify for the Section 892 exemption;
- Retain the prior proposed rule that an entity will not be treated as a CCE merely because it engages in “inadvertent commercial activity,” so long as the failure to avoid the commercial activity was reasonable, the activity is discontinued within a specified time period, and the entity complies with record maintenance requirements;
- Retain the prior proposed rule that CCE status is generally determined annually, so that the CCE taint does not persist across taxable years;
- Replace the prior proposed “limited partner” exception with a new “qualified partnership interest” exception, which generally provides that an entity will not be engaged in a commercial activity solely due to holding a partnership interest if the partner does not have personal liability for claims against the partnership; the partner does not have the right to enter into contracts or act on behalf of the partnership; the partner does not have rights to participate in the management and conduct of the partnership’s business; and the partner does not “control” the partnership;
- Propose a new rule that all acquisition of debt is treated as commercial activity unless the acquisition is characterized as investment for purposes of Section 892 under one of two safe harbors (one for registered offerings and one for “qualified secondary market transactions”) or a facts-and-circumstances test; and
- Propose a new broad definition of “effective control,” which can be achieved by any interest in an entity, whether legal/contractual or non-legal/non-contractual “soft power”—including equity, voting power, debt, contractual rights, business relationships, or regulatory authority—that, separately or in combination, results in control over the operational, managerial, board-level, or investor-level decisions of the entity.
III. Final Regulations
- Definition of Commercial Activities
- General Rule
Treasury and the IRS declined to define “commercial activities” as coterminous with “trade or business,” concluding that commercial activities include activities that may not rise to the level of a trade of business, which is consistent with prior regulations. Regulations provide that, subject to specified exceptions, commercial activities are all activities (whether conducted within or outside the United States) that are ordinarily conducted for the current or future production of income or gain.
-
- Investment Exception
- Financial Instruments & Non-Functional Currency Deposits
- Investment Exception
Commercial activities do not include investments in “financial instruments.” Prior proposed regulations eliminated the requirement that, to avoid treatment as a commercial activity, such instruments must be held in the execution of governmental financial or monetary policy. The scope of the term “financial instruments” was unclear, though the prior temporary regulations referred to only derivatives that referenced currency or precious metals.
The final regulations clarify this rule, providing that a foreign government generally may invest in, and effect transactions (as a non-dealer) for its own account with respect to, any of the following types of instruments without being treated as engaged in commercial activities:
- Any interest rate, currency, equity, or commodity swap; or
- Any evidence of an interest in options, forward or futures contracts, and any other similar contracts, the value of which, or any payment or other transfer with respect to which, is (directly or indirectly) determined by reference to a (i) commodity; (ii) currency; (iii) share of stock; (iv) partnership or beneficial ownership interest in a widely held or publicly traded partnership or trust; (v) note, bond, debenture, or other evidence of indebtedness; or (vi) swap.
A foreign government that, in a non-dealer capacity, enters into a market standard derivative—such as a swap, forward, or option that references interest rates, currencies, debt, or equities—generally should not generate commercial activity income.
It is notable that the final regulations address only whether financial instruments give rise to commercial activity income, and not whether income with respect to such instruments qualifies for the Section 892 exemption. The final regulations do not modify the rule in the statute and temporary regulations that income from financial instruments qualifies for the Section 892 exemption only when such instruments are held in the execution of governmental financial or monetary policy. However, many types of financial instruments should not cause a foreign government to be subject to tax in any event (e.g., because income from such instruments would be sourced outside the United States) and thus it may not be necessary for income from such instruments to be exempt under Section 892.
Relatedly, the final regulations clarify that commercial activities do not include the holding of bank deposits in any currency.
-
-
- Partnership Interests
-
The final regulations confirm that, although a partner may be attributed commercial activities conducted by a partnership, the mere act of holding a partnership equity interest or effecting transactions in a partnership equity interest (for a foreign government’s own account and other than as a dealer) is not in and of itself treated as a commercial activity.
- Controlled Commercial Entities
- U.S. Real Estate and U.S. Real Property Holding Corporations
The final regulations helpfully remove a per se rule that treated any foreign-government-controlled foreign corporation as a CCE if the corporation owns sufficient U.S. real property interests (“USRPIs”) to be a U.S. real property holding corporation (“USRPHC”) (in each case, within the meaning of the Foreign Investment in Real Property Tax Act of 1980, or “FIRPTA”). The repeal of the per se rule, sometimes known as the super-USRPHC rule, means that foreign governments no longer need to monitor the relative ownership of U.S. real property by their foreign controlled entities.
For example, assume as shown below that a foreign government owns 100% of the stock of a foreign controlled entity, which owns 40% of the stock of a domestic USRPHC and 60% of the stock of a second domestic USRPHC.
If the foreign controlled entity is otherwise eligible for the Section 892 exemption, it may sell its 40% share of the stock of the domestic USRPHC without being subject to tax. (The Section 892 exemption does not apply to gain on the sale of its 60% share of the stock of the other domestic USRPHC.) Prior to the final regulations, the foreign controlled entity would itself have been a USRPHC and therefore a CCE (and accordingly ineligible for Section 892 benefits) due to its concentration of USRPI ownership.
The per se rule continues to treat a foreign-government-controlled domestic corporation as a CCE if the corporation owns sufficient USRPIs to be a USRPHC. However, depending on the facts, the 60% owned domestic corporation in the above example separately may be covered by a minority interest exception, which provides that a domestic corporation is not a CCE if it is a USRPHC solely due to its direct or indirect ownership in one or more corporations that are not controlled by the foreign government. Those minority interests are excluded (from both the numerator and the denominator) in determining whether the domestic corporation’s other non-minority-interest assets may nevertheless cause it to be a CCE.
For example, assume as shown below that a foreign sovereign owns 100% of the stock of a domestic corporation, which owns 40% of the stock of a lower-tier domestic USRPHC, such as a foreign-controlled real estate investment trust (“REIT”).
The domestic corporation is not a CCE because it is a USRPHC solely due to ownership of a minority interest in a lower-tier USRPHC. Accordingly, the foreign government’s gain from the sale of the domestic corporation’s stock can be exempt from tax under Section 892. In contrast, the domestic corporation may be a CCE if it owns other USRPIs such as 60% of the stock of another REIT.
-
- Inadvertent Commercial Activity Exception
The final regulations retain and refine a targeted exception under which an entity that engages solely in “inadvertent commercial activity” will not be treated as engaged in commercial activities under specific conditions. Consistent with the prior proposed rules, the exception affects only the determination of whether an entity is a CCE; any income derived from the inadvertent commercial activity remains ineligible for the Section 892 exemption. The exception applies only if all of the following three requirements are met:
- First, the failure to avoid commercial activity must be “reasonable” under all the facts and circumstances. Relevant factors include the number of commercial activities during the current taxable year (and, in certain cases, the immediately preceding taxable year), and the relative amount of income and assets associated with those activities compared to the entity’s overall income and assets (with a 5% safe harbor for both tainted income and tainted assets). Reasonableness also requires ongoing due diligence, evidenced by adequate written policies and operational procedures designed to monitor and prevent commercial activities on a worldwide basis. These procedures include, among other requirements that are new to the final regulations, a requirement that the entity conduct an “annual internal or external audit or review” of both direct investments and investments in entities whose commercial activities would be attributed to the entity.
- Second, the commercial activity must be discontinued within 180 days (an increase from the prior proposed rule’s 120 days) of the discovery of the activity by responsible employees, and this may include exchanging an interest in a partnership engaged in commercial activities for a “qualified partnership interest” (described below) in the same partnership. The preamble cautions that an automatic modification of a partnership interest into a qualified partnership interest (without a separate negotiation) may not satisfy the cure requirement.
- Third, and consistent with the prior proposed rule, the entity must satisfy specified record maintenance requirements.
-
- Annual Determination
The final regulations confirm that CCE status is generally determined on an annual basis. However, a limited look-back rule provides that an entity’s activities during its immediately preceding taxable year will also be taken into account to the extent relevant in characterizing the activities in the current taxable year.
If a controlled entity is engaged in commercial activities at any time during the taxable year, it will be a CCE for the entire year. The preamble clarifies that a domestic entity that is a deemed CCE because of the USRPHC per se rule would continue to be a CCE for the taxable year even if the entity ceases to be a USRPHC during the year.
If a controlled entity is engaged in commercial activities in one year but not in a prior or subsequent year, the entity would not be a CCE in such prior or subsequent year. Special rules apply if the entity’s taxable year is terminated early as a result of an acquisition.
-
- Partnerships
The final regulations reaffirm the general rule that commercial activities conducted by a partnership are attributed to its partners for purposes of determining whether a partner in the partnership is engaged in commercial activity and therefore treated as a CCE. Treasury and the IRS declined to adopt a suggestion that a foreign government should not be engaged in commercial activity as a result of receiving, through an investment fund, a share of the fees for services provided by the fund’s sponsor, when the foreign government holds (directly or indirectly) an equity interest in such fund. Instead, Treasury and the IRS stated broadly that any such arrangement must be analyzed, consistent with general tax principles, based on its substance, including possible attribution of the sponsor’s activities to the foreign government investor on the basis of agency.
Under the trading activity exception set forth in the prior proposed rules and the final regulations, an entity will not be considered to be engaged in commercial activities solely because the entity is partner in a partnership that effects transactions in stocks, bonds, other securities, commodities or financial instruments for the partnership’s own account. This exception does not apply in the case of a partnership that is a dealer in such instruments.
Finally, Treasury and the IRS declined to adopt a rule disregarding transitory ownership of a partnership interest for purposes of attribution of commercial activity to the transitory partner because of “administrability challenges” as to whether a transfer was transitory.
-
- Exception for Qualified Partnership Interests
The final regulations provide that an entity is not engaged in commercial activity solely due to holding a “qualified partnership interest” in a limited liability company, limited partnership, or other entity classified as a partnership for tax purposes.
The qualified partnership interest exception requires that the partner does not have personal liability for claims against the partnership; the partner does not have the right to enter into contracts or act on behalf of the partnership; the partner does not have rights to participate in the day-to-day management or operation of the partnership’s business; and the partner does not “control” the partnership, such as by owning 50% or more of the partnership by vote or value. The partner may have certain oversight and supervision rights in the case of major strategic decisions, such as admission or expulsion of a partner; hiring or firing key strategic personnel; amendment of the partnership agreement; dissolution, merger, or conversion of the partnership; unusual and non-ordinary course deviations from previously determined investment parameters; amending the partnership agreement or extending the partnership’s term; and disposition of all or substantially all of the partnership's property outside of the ordinary course of the partnership's activities. A limited safe harbor applies to certain partners that own 5% or less of the capital and profits in the partnership.
In a tiered partnership structure, the qualified partnership exception is applied at each level. For example, assume as shown below that a foreign government owns a 60% limited partner interest in an upper-tier limited partnership, which owns a 70% limited partner interest in a lower-tier limited partnership.
The foreign government cannot use the qualified partnership interest exception because it “controls” the upper-tier limited partnership by owning 50% or more of its value. Likewise, the upper-tier limited partnership cannot use the qualified partnership interest exception for its majority interest in the lower-tier limited partnership. The qualified partnership interest exception replaced a “limited partner” exception in the prior proposed regulations, which did not contain the 50% ownership limitation.
In contrast, if the foreign government directly holds a 42% limited partner interest in the lower-tier partnership, it may be able to benefit from the qualified partnership interest exception in the event that the lower-tier partnership is engaged in commercial activity.
IV. Proposed Regulations
To address certain comments made in connection with previously proposed regulations, Treasury and the IRS are separately proposing rules alongside the final regulations. In particular, the proposed regulations focus on whether acquisitions of debt are commercial activity income, further define “effective control” in determining CCE status and clarify the definition of “controlled entity” as it relates to partnerships.
- Debt Acquisition
The preamble to the final regulations notes that a comment stated that there is “uncertainty as to the circumstances in which loan origination is commercial activity” and recommended that “lending (and charging of associated fees) should not be treated as commercial activity unless an entity offers to make loans to the general public or makes more than five loans in a single year.” The final regulations declined to adopt that comment, stating instead that Treasury and the IRS “do not agree that making loans to the general public or making a particular minimum number of loans constitute necessary conditions for loan (or other debt) acquisitions to be commercial in character, or that a lack of those characteristics necessarily indicates absence of commercial activities.” As discussed below, the proposed regulations instead provide limited comfort for debt acquisitions as investment versus commercial activity, featuring two safe harbors and a facts-and-circumstances test.
Treasury and the IRS are of the view that whether the activity of lending or otherwise acquiring debt, including at original issuance, qualifies as investment or commercial activity under Section 892 is highly fact-dependent and requires consideration of all facts and circumstances. The proposed regulations provide an exclusive framework for determining when any debt acquisition qualifies as investment activity for purposes of Section 892.
Whether a debt acquisition is investment for purposes of Section 892 generally would be determined without regard to whether the debt acquisition is treated as a “trade or business” for tax purposes. Importantly, Treasury and the IRS specifically state that no inference is intended from the proposed regulations as to the “circumstances in which acquiring debt, including at original issuance, would or would not be a trade or business for other purposes of the Code,” such as Section 864 (definition of U.S. trade or business), Section 162 (trade or business expenses) or Section 166 (bad debt deduction).
- General Rule
The proposed regulations provide that all acquisition of debt is treated as commercial activity, unless the acquisition is characterized as investment for purposes of Section 892 under one of two safe harbors or a facts-and-circumstances test. Notably, and subject to the facts and circumstances analysis, commercial activity would appear to include secondary acquisitions of loans in private transactions, which is a change from the final regulations and seems to encompass transactions that most practitioners would consider to be investment activity. An acquisition of debt undertaken as a “dealer” is always commercial activity.
- Investment Safe Harbors
-
- Registered Offering Safe Harbor
-
Under the “registered offering” safe harbor, acquisitions of bonds or other debt securities acquired in an offering registered under the U.S. Securities Act of 1933, as amended, would be treated as investments, provided that the underwriters of the offering are not related to the acquirer. Comments are requested regarding whether offerings registered under foreign securities laws also should be eligible for the safe harbor.
-
-
- Qualified Secondary Market Transaction Safe Harbor
-
Under the “qualified secondary market transaction” safe harbor, acquisitions of debt traded on an “established securities market” would be treated as investments, provided that the acquirer is not purchasing from the issuer or participating in negotiation of the terms or issuance of the debt. A qualified secondary market acquisition must not be from a person that is under common management or control with the acquirer, unless the seller itself acquired the debt as an investment within the meaning of Section 892. Comments are requested regarding whether the acquisition of debt that is not traded on an established securities market also should be eligible for the safe harbor.
It is notable that this safe harbor (i) is more restrictive than the Section 864 trading safe harbor, which generally treats secondary transactions (whether or not traded or effectuated on a securities market) as not constituting a U.S. trade or business and (ii) specifically excludes acquisitions from persons under common control or management.
iii. Facts-and-Circumstances Test
Under the “facts-and-circumstances test,” acquisitions of debt that do not satisfy either of the two safe harbors may be treated as investment activity based on consideration of all relevant facts and circumstances. The proposed regulations provide a non-exclusive list of eight relevant factors, all of which would be taken into account, and the weight given to each relevant factor may vary depending on the circumstances.
The factors and related examples have been historically considered by market participants in both the Section 892 and the broader trade or business contexts. They include the nature of the acquirer’s solicitation and negotiation activities; entitlement to compensation other than interest (including original issue discount (“OID”)); the form of the instrument (loan versus security); percentage of debt acquired; and, in the case of a deemed issuance as a result of significant modification in a debt-for-debt exchange, whether the debt was acquired with a reasonable expectation that the debtor would default. Notably, making a single loan in one example resulted in commercial activity.
Treasury and the IRS state that, in general, a debt acquisition would be treated as investment where the expected return from acquiring the debt is exclusively a return on capital rather than including a return on activities conducted. Comments are requested regarding whether acquisitions of distressed debt, broadly syndicated loans, revolving credit facilities, and delayed-draw debt obligations should be treated as investment activities rather than commercial activities.
- Effective Control
Under Section 892, as noted above, a CCE includes any entity engaged in commercial activity if the foreign government holds (directly or indirectly) any “other interest” (i.e., other than a 50% or more voting or value interest) in the entity which provides it with “effective control” of the entity. The proposed regulations provide further guidance as to what constitutes effective control, defining the terms “other interest” and “effective control” broadly and in combination with each other. Together, they include equity, voting, or debt interests in, or contractual rights or arrangements with, the entity, or even non-legal/non-contractual “soft power” such as business relationships with (or with holders of equity or other interests in) the entity. They also include regulatory authority over the entity or any other arrangement or relationship that provides influence over the entity’s operational, managerial, board-level, or investor-level decisions. Mere consultation rights do not alone give rise to effective control. All of the facts and circumstances related to the interests would be considered in determining effective control, and attribution rules would apply to aggregate interests held by controlled entities of the same sovereign. In any event, a foreign government would be deemed to have effective control of an entity if the foreign government is, or otherwise controls an entity that is, a managing partner or managing member of (or holds an equivalent role with respect to) an entity.
The proposed regulations provide a series of examples of interests that would and would not result in effective control. Many of these examples address situations that market participants and practitioners have previously considered.
Examples 1-3 provide welcome guidance for foreign government investors:
- Example 1 provides that a foreign government that owns 40% of the voting power and value of an entity, and no other interest, along with two other investors each owning 30%, would not have effective control if the foreign government lacks the power (directly or indirectly through other arrangements) to unilaterally elect the entity’s board; choose its management; or otherwise direct the entity’s operational, managerial, board-level, or investor-level decisions through veto rights or influential business relationships.
- Examples 2 and 3 provide that the existence of a mere investment agreement (i.e., an agreement providing the criteria for what types of investments an entity can make) between the foreign government and the entity, or the foreign government’s entitlement to participate in an investment committee with mere consultation, but not decision or execution rights or powers, would not provide the foreign government with effective control of the entity.
By contrast, examples 4-8 provide adverse guidance for foreign government investors:
- Example 4 is similar to the controlled foreign corporation rules regarding voting power and provides that a foreign government would have effective control where it holds a minority equity interest that entitles it to appoint only one out of several directors of the entity, if that one director has the sole power to unilaterally appoint or dismiss the entity’s manager.
- Example 5 provides that a foreign government would have effective control where its minority equity interest entitles it to veto the entity’s dividend distributions, material capital expenditures, sales of new equity interests, and operating budget.
- Example 6 is an example of non-legal/non-contractual “soft power.” It provides a situation where a foreign government has effective control of an entity where the foreign government, although a minority equity holder, together with an unrelated investor can appoint the majority of the board of directors of the entity and, due to the foreign government’s other business relationship with the unrelated investor, the unrelated investor causes its appointed director to always vote in the same manner as the foreign government’s appointed director.
- Example 7 provides an example where a foreign government’s regulatory authority provides the foreign government with effective control of an entity.
- Example 8 provides an example where a foreign government is a creditor of an entity with sufficient creditor rights, such as veto rights over the debtor’s capital transactions and operating budget, to provide it with effective control and thereby disqualify interest payments from the Section 892 exemption.
In relation to Example 8, Treasury and the IRS state that a foreign government would not need to hold “any particular amount of (or any) equity in an entity to have effective control of the entity.” (Emphasis added.) This example raises a number of implications, including which types of creditor protections seen in the market (whether alone or in combination) may be deemed to be control provisions; and whether the Section 892 implications for these types of provisions should be viewed differently depending on the overall nature of the creditor-debt relationship (e.g., true third-party debt versus shareholder loans or ordinary commercial arrangements versus more bespoke transactions).
The proposed regulations do not address how effective control would be determined when the foreign government owns an equity interest in a partnership that has the above “other interests” in an entity.
Comments are requested regarding whether a determination could be made that controlled entities are functionally independent of one another and therefore may be appropriately considered separately for purposes of the effective control analysis. Comments are also requested regarding whether the holder of a minority equity interest in an entity should not be treated as having effective control of the entity if managerial or board-level decisions of the entity are subject to veto or “blocking” rights of the holder and other holders (e.g., through consent rights, supermajority requirements, or otherwise).
- Definition of Controlled Entity
For purposes of Section 892, the term “foreign government” means only the integral parts and “controlled entities” of a foreign sovereign. A “controlled entity” means an entity that is separate in form from a foreign sovereign or otherwise constitutes a separate juridical entity if it satisfies certain requirements, including that it is wholly owned and controlled by a single foreign sovereign directly or indirectly through one or more controlled entities. The proposed regulations clarify that partnerships are not considered controlled entities for purposes of Section 892, even if they are wholly owned (directly or indirectly) and controlled by a single foreign sovereign. This aspect of the proposed regulations appears to be consistent with a private letter ruling (PLR 202343034) that treated a local law partnership as a partnership for tax purposes even though it was owned by multiple controlled entities of a single foreign sovereign.
V. Applicability Dates
The final regulations generally apply to taxable years beginning on or after December 15, 2025. Taxpayers may choose to apply the final regulations to any open taxable years that precede December 15, 2025, so long as the taxpayer and all related entities apply all of the final regulations consistently for all such years. No transition rule is provided for taxpayers who had relied on the prior proposed regulations to be able to continue to rely on them (e.g., the limited partner exception that was replaced by the “qualified partnership interest” exception in the final regulations).
The proposed regulations are proposed to apply to taxable years beginning on or after the date they are finalized. However, a foreign government may choose to apply the rule that a partnership is not a controlled entity to any open taxable years that precede the finalization of the proposed regulations, so long as it applies that rule consistently for all such years.
This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.