EXAMS Publishes 2024 SEC Examination Priorities
Client memorandum | November 9, 2023
Authors: Phil Heimowitz, Michael L. Sherman, Joanna D. Rosenberg, Elona Belokon
On October 16, 2023, the Division of Examinations (“Division”) of the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) published its examination priorities for 2024 (the “2024 Priorities”).[1] The Division’s examination priorities are released annually and are designed to preview key areas where the Division intends to focus its resources. In past years, the Division has generally published its examination priorities near the start of the calendar year. However, this year, for the first time, the Division has aligned publication of the 2024 Priorities with the start of the SEC’s fiscal year and with the stated hope of increased transparency for investors and registrants. The 2024 Priorities include focus areas for investment advisers, registered investment companies, broker-dealers, self-regulatory organizations, clearing agencies, and other market participants. This memorandum focuses on the examination priorities applicable to investment advisers, broker-dealers, and certain self-regulatory organizations.
Similar to prior years, certain of the priority topics for investment adviser exams follow recent rulemaking by the SEC under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, as amended (“Advisers Act”), including Form PF amendments[2] and the marketing rule.[3] The 2024 Priorities also continue prior years’ focus on registered investment advisers to private funds, as described in more detail below. Other examination priorities include investment adviser fiduciary duty, effectiveness of compliance policies and procedures, information security and operational resiliency, emerging technologies and crypto-assets, and anti-money laundering programs. In a change from the 2022 and 2023 examination priorities, the Division did not include ESG investing in the 2024 Priorities. We remind our clients that the 2024 Priorities do not comprise an exhaustive list of topics that the Division would review during an examination, nor will any particular exam focus on each (or any) of the priorities.
Investment Advisers and Advisers to Private Funds
Fiduciary Duty. The 2024 Priorities state that examinations of investment advisers will review adherence to the Advisers Act fiduciary duty, with particular focus on (1) investment advice with respect to complex or high cost and illiquid products, unconventional investment strategies, and investment advice provided to certain types of clients, including older investors and those saving for retirement; (2) processes for determining that investment advice is provided in clients’ best interests; (3) economic incentives that an adviser and its personnel may have to recommend products, services, or account types, such as the source and structure of compensation, revenue, or other benefits; and (4) whether disclosures made to investors include all material facts relating to the conflicts of interest associated with the applicable advice sufficient to allow a client to provide informed consent to the conflict.
Compliance Programs. The 2024 Priorities state that the Division will prioritize review of whether advisers’ compliance policies and procedures accurately reflect their business, with a focus on one or more of the following areas: (1) portfolio management processes; (2) disclosures to investors and regulators; (3) proprietary trading by the adviser and the personal trading activities of supervised advisory personnel; (4) safeguarding and custody of client assets; (5) creation and maintenance of required records; (6) client privacy; (7) trading practices; (8) investment adviser marketing; (9) valuation processes; (10) business continuity plans; (11) selection and oversight of service providers; (12) oversight of branch offices; and (13) client consent processes. In particular, the Division will evaluate (1) investment adviser marketing practices, including whether advisers have adopted and implemented written policies and procedures to comply with the new marketing rule, appropriately disclosed marketing-related information on Form ADV, and maintained the required books and records; (2) compensation arrangements, focusing on advisers’ fiduciary obligations, alternative methods for maximizing revenue, and fee breakpoint calculation processes; (3) valuation of illiquid or difficult to value assets; (4) controls to protect clients’ material non-public information; and (5) accuracy and completeness of disclosures in regulatory filings, including Form CRS. The Division will also review investment adviser advertisements for compliance with the marketing rule’s requirements for performance, third-party ratings, and testimonials and endorsements.
Investment Advisers to Private Funds. Specific areas the Division will review when examining private fund investment advisers include (1) the portfolio management risks present during market volatility and a high interest rate environment (including as relates to poor performance, significant withdrawals and valuation issues, highly levered private funds and private funds holding illiquid assets); (2) adherence to contractual requirements, including notice and consent procedures; (3) calculation and allocation of private fund fees and expenses, including adequacy of related disclosures; (4) due diligence practices, particularly those relating to private equity and venture capital fund valuations of prospective portfolio companies; (5) conflicts, controls, and disclosures regarding private funds managed side by side with registered investment companies and the use of affiliated service providers; (6) compliance with Advisers Act custody rule requirements, including Form ADV reporting and timely audits by qualified auditors and distributions of audited financial statements; and (7) Form PF reporting, including upon the occurrence of certain reporting events. Certain of these focus areas overlap with Risk Alerts previously published by the Division,[4] the proposed outsourcing rule,[5] and the recently adopted amendments to Form PF.[6]
Consistent with prior years, the 2024 Priorities state that the Division will prioritize advisers that have never been examined, including recently registered firms, and those that have not been examined for a number of years.
Broker-Dealers
Regulation Best Interest. The 2024 Priorities state that in reviewing whether broker-dealer recommendations are in customers’ best interest, the Division will focus on, among other things, (1) recommendations with respect to certain types of products (including complex, high cost and illiquid products), investment strategies, and account types (including accounts for older investors and those saving for retirement or college); (2) conflicts of interest disclosures; (3) conflict mitigation practices; (4) processes for reviewing reasonably available alternatives; and (5) factors considered in light of the investor’s investment profile. The Division will also evaluate the adequacy and implementation of broker-dealers’ Regulation Best Interest policies and procedures.
Form CRS. The Division will review the content of broker-dealers’ Form CRS and whether broker-dealers have met their filing and delivery obligations.
Compliance with Applicable Rules and Regulations. The Division will also focus on broker-dealer compliance with (a) the Net Capital Rule; (b) the Customer Protection Rule; (c) Regulation SHO; (d) Regulation ATS; and (e) Exchange Act Rule 15c2-11.
Self-Regulatory Organizations
National Securities Exchanges. The 2024 Priorities state that the Division will examine whether national securities exchanges are meeting their obligations to enforce compliance with self-regulatory organization rules and the federal securities laws, including with respect to order handling and implementation of programs designed to detect and discipline member firm violations. The Division will also focus on exchange oversight of regulatory service agreements.
Financial Industry Regulatory Authority. The Division conducts risk-based oversight examinations of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), covering areas such as FINRA’s implementation of Regulation Best Interest and Form CRS and FINRA’s examinations of certain broker-dealers and municipal advisors that are FINRA members.
Risk Areas Impacting Various Market Participants
The 2024 Priorities list the following additional areas as risk areas impacting investment advisers and broker-dealers, among other market participants.
- Information Security and Operational Resiliency. The 2024 Priorities state that the Division will review broker-dealers’ and investment advisers’ practices to prevent interruptions to mission critical services and to protect investor information, records, and assets. Reviews will focus on cybersecurity policies and procedures, internal controls, staff training, governance practices, and responses to cyber-related incidents, as well as issues associated with reliance on third-party vendors or unauthorized use of third-party providers. The Division will also review firms’ practices, policies, and procedures to prevent account intrusions and safeguard client information, emphasizing firms with multiple offices.
- Crypto-Assets and Emerging Financial Technology. The 2024 Priorities state that the Division will evaluate broker-dealers and investment advisers offering new products and services or employing new practices to ensure compliance with relevant laws and rules, including the marketing rule. Examinations will focus on automated investment tools, artificial intelligence, and trading algorithms or platforms. With respect to market participants engaged with crypto-assets, the Division will assess the offer, sale, recommendation, advice, and trading of crypto-assets, focusing on whether such registrants (1) comply with respective standards of conduct and (2) routinely review, update, and enhance their compliance practices, including those related to custody, risk disclosures, and operational resilience.
- Regulation Systems Compliance and Integrity. The 2024 Priorities state that the Division will evaluate whether national securities exchanges, certain clearing agencies, FINRA, MSRB, and other entities covered under Regulation Systems Compliance in Integrity (“SCI”) have established, maintained, and enforced written policies and procedures to ensure that their systems’ capacity, integrity, resiliency, availability, and security is sufficient to maintain operational capability and foster fair and orderly markets. The Division will focus on whether an SCI entity’s policies and procedures are reasonably designed to ensure system security.
- Anti-Money Laundering. The 2024 Priorities state that the Division will focus on anti-money laundering programs to assess whether certain financial institutions, including broker-dealers, are (1) appropriately tailoring their anti-money laundering programs to their business and associated risks; (2) conducting independent testing of their programs; (3) establishing customer identification programs; and (4) fulfilling their SAR filing obligations. Examinations will also review broker-dealers’ procedures for monitoring and complying with Office of Foreign Assets Control sanctions.
[2] See Fried Frank Memorandum to our Clients and Friends: SEC Adopts Amendments to Form PF; Final Rule, Form PF; Event Reporting for Large Hedge Fund Advisers and Private Equity Fund Advisers; Requirements for Large Private Equity Fund Adviser Reporting, Release No. IA-6297 (May 3, 2023), available at https://www.sec.gov/files/rules/final/2023/ia-6297.pdf.
[3] See Fried Frank Memorandum to our Clients and Friends: SEC Adopts Revised Investment Adviser Marketing Rule; Final Rule, Investment Adviser Marketing, Release No. IA-5653 (Dec 22, 2020), available at https://www.sec.gov/files/rules/final/2020/ia-5653.pdf.
[4] See Risk Alert, Observations from Examinations of Private Fund Advisers, (Jan. 27, 2022).
[5] See Fried Frank Memorandum to our Clients and Friends: SEC Proposes New Oversight Requirements for Certain Services Outsourced by Registered Investment Advisers; Proposed Rule, Outsourcing by Investment Advisers, Release No. IA-6176 (Oct. 26, 2022).
[6] See Fried Frank Memorandum to our Clients and Friends: SEC Adopts Amendments to Form PF; Final Rule, Form PF; Event Reporting for Large Hedge Fund Advisers and Private Equity Fund Advisers; Requirements for Large Private Equity Fund Adviser Reporting, Release No. IA-6297 (May 3, 2023).
This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.