Skip to main content

DFC Global:  Delaware Supreme Court Strongly Endorses Reliance on Merger Price in Appraisal Cases Involving an Arm’s-Length Merger With a Robust Sale Process—But Declines to Establish an Express Judicial Presumption

M&A/PE Briefing | August 2, 2017

In DFC Global v. Muirfield (Aug. 1, 2017), the Delaware Supreme Court, in a much-anticipated decision in the appeal of the Court of Chancery’s appraisal decision, declined to establish an express judicial presumption in favor of reliance on the deal price to determine “fair value” in appraisal cases—but, importantly, strongly endorsed the Court of Chancery’s recent trend toward increased reliance on the deal price in cases involving an arm’s-length merger and a robust sale process. The Supreme Court reversed the Court of Chancery determination of fair value and remanded the case for a new determination by the Court of Chancery. The Court of Chancery—relying equally on the deal price, a DCF valuation and a comparable companies valuation—had determined fair value to be 8.4% above the merger price. The Supreme Court strongly suggested that, in this case, given the robust sale process and the unreliable target company projections available for aa DCF analysis, the merger price was the best indicator of fair value.

Also of note is that the decision:

  • Imposed a requirement on the Court of Chancery, when it determines appraised fair value, to consider the reliability of the deal price, a DCF valuation, and, if appropriate, other methodologies, and to explain the basis for the court’s determination as to the weighting of each in the court’s analysis;
  • Rejected the argument that extreme regulatory uncertainty facing the target company made the deal price less reliable; and
  • Rejected the concept that a financial buyer’s pricing model undermines the reliability of the deal price in an LBO transaction.

In the attached M&A Briefing, we discuss the decision and its likely impact and note certain key open issues that it leaves unresolved and that may affect appraisal cases going forward.

Additional information

icon View File

This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.