Skip to main content

DOJ Settlement Provides Roadmap for Mitigating Antitrust Risk of Pricing Recommendation Software

Client memorandum | August 26, 2025

Authors: Bernard (Barry) A. Nigro Jr., Kathy O’Neill, Aleksandr B. Livshits, Nathaniel Bronstein, and Joan Rosello

Challenges to the use of algorithmic pricing software is one of the hottest trends in antitrust enforcement, with pricing recommendation software in healthcare, housing, and the hotel industries currently subject to antitrust lawsuits by the DOJ, state attorneys general, and private plaintiffs.  The DOJ Antitrust Division’s recent settlement with Greystar Management Services provides valuable insights for mitigating antitrust risk of pricing recommendation software that is used by multiple competitors.[1]  Significantly, the terms of the settlement suggest that, standing alone, algorithmic pricing software that does not leverage nonpublic data of third parties and does not require or encourage users to accept its pricing recommendations is likely to avoid antitrust scrutiny.

Background

The Greystar settlement arises from the DOJ’s lawsuit against RealPage, Inc. (filed in August 2024) in which the DOJ alleges that RealPage’s software allowed competing landlords to unlawfully share nonpublic rental information to generate pricing recommendations.[2]  The DOJ amended its complaint in January 2025 to add Greystar, the largest landlord in the United States, and five other landlords as defendants.[3]

The Proposed Settlement

  • Greystar’s settlement with the DOJ prohibits Greystar from using or licensing software that generates rental prices if the software:

  • uses nonpublic competitively sensitive information of third party properties to generate pricing recommendations;

  • uses Greystar’s nonpublic competitively sensitive information to generate pricing recommendations or to train pricing recommendation models for third parties;

  • pools or combines nonpublic competitively sensitive information from Greystar-managed properties that have different property owners; or

  • incorporates a price floor, limits rent decreases, or requires Greystar to accept (or provides an economic incentive to accept) pricing recommendations.[4] 

The settlement does not preclude the use of public data (including pricing and discount data) in pricing recommendation software if that information is “readily accessible” to the general public or to natural persons who reasonably present themselves as prospective renters (which would presumably include secret shoppers).[5]  

The settlement terms permitting the use of public data in pricing recommendation software is consistent with a Nevada district court’s recent decision in Gibson v. Cendyn Group, where the court dismissed a lawsuit challenging the use of algorithmic pricing software for casino hotels that combined publicly available data (where the public data was collected by the software rather than provided by users of the software) and the user hotel’s proprietary data to generate pricing recommendations.[6]  The DOJ’s settlement with Greystar is also virtually identical in substance to the DOJ’s settlement at the end of the Biden administration with another user of RealPage’s software, Cortland Management, suggesting little daylight between how the Biden and Trump administrations view the use of algorithmic pricing software under the antitrust laws.

Takeaways

The DOJ settlements and the decision in Gibson provide a roadmap for algorithmic pricing software configuration that is unlikely to violate the antitrust laws:

  • The software should not leverage in any way competitors’ nonpublic competitively sensitive information;

  • The software should not set a price floor or limit discounting, as that could enable competitors to coordinate minimum pricing;

  • The software should not provide incentives to accept pricing recommendations, as that reduces independent decision-making among competitors;

  • The software can leverage competitors’ publicly available data in the algorithm, including scraping the internet for such data.  However, the terms of the DOJ settlements raise the question of whether antitrust concerns could arise where the software users themselves provide data to the software that is publicly available but which may not be “readily accessible” to the general public; and

  • Software users should not agree to use a particular pricing recommendation software.  The DOJ has explicitly stated that “an agreement among competitors to use certain pricing algorithms to generate default or starting-point prices is per se illegal even if there is no further agreement on final prices.”[7]

Assistant Attorney General for the Antitrust Division Slater “anticipate[s] that the number of investigations involving these shared algorithms will grow.”[8]  Therefore, companies considering using pricing recommendation software and deal teams looking to acquire companies that use such software should carefully examine whether the software algorithm and how it is used in the market creates antitrust risk.  While the factors described above provide useful guidance, the antitrust implications associated with the use of algorithmic pricing software will depend on the totality of the facts.



[1] Justice Department Reaches Proposed Settlement with Greystar, the Largest U.S. Landlord, to End Its Participation in Algorithmic Pricing Scheme, DOJ (Aug. 8, 2024), https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-reaches-proposed-settlement-greystar-largest-us-landlord-end-its [hereinafter DOJ Press Release].

[2] Complaint at 5–6, 225, United States and Plaintiff States v. RealPage, Inc., No. 1:24-cv-00710 (N.D. N.C. Aug. 23, 2024).

[3] Amended Complaint at 5, 259–279, United States and Plaintiff States v. RealPage et al., No. 1:24-cv-00710-LCB-JLW (M.D. N.C. Jan. 7, 2025).

[4] Proposed Final Judgment, United States v. Greystar Mgmt. Services, LLC, Section IV.

[5] Id. at Section II(M).

[6] Gibson, et al. v. Cendyn Grp., LLC, 2024 WL 2060260, at *4–5, 9 (D. Nev. 2024).

[7] Brief for the United States in Support of Plaintiff-Appellants at 15, Gibson, et al. v. Cendyn Grp., LLC, 2025 WL 2371948 (9th Cir. 2025) (No. 24-3576).

[8] Abigail Slater (@AAGSlater), X (Aug. 8, 2025, at 10:18 ET), https://x.com/AAGSlater/status/1954910329734881786.


This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.