Skip to main content

Delaware Supreme Court Reinforces High Bar to a Finding of Director Non-Independence in the Context of Demand Refusal–McElrath v. Kalanick

Client memorandum | February 3, 2020

In McElrath v. Kalanick (Jan. 13, 2020), the Delaware Supreme Court upheld the Court of Chancery’s decision that dismissed a derivative suit brought by a stockholder of Uber Technologies, Inc. for damages arising from Uber’s 2016 acquisition of Ottomotto LLC. The Supreme Court agreed with the Court of Chancery that a majority of the defendant directors were independent and had not acted in bad faith--and, therefore, that pre-suit demand on the board to bring the derivative litigation was not excused. The decision (i) reinforces Delaware’s presumption of director independence and its high bar to a finding of bad faith (although, we note, in our view, the facts the plaintiff alleged did not present a strong case for non-independence or bad faith) and (ii) serves as a reminder of the importance of a good board process, but also that, without more, a failure to have “dug deeper” or “further investigated” issues that later turn out to be problematic generally would not substantiate “bad faith.” In the attached memorandum, we discuss the opinion and offer related practice points.
 

Additional information

icon View File

This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.