Court Of Chancery States MFW Protection Would Apply to Third Party Merger Involving a Controller Who Obtained “Side Deals” from the Buyer— Another Road Leading to Business Judgment Review—Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia
M&A/PE Briefing | August 25, 2017
In an important opinion (Aug. 18, 2017) relating to third party mergers involving a controlling stockholder who obtains a special benefit in the transaction, the Delaware Court of Chancery applied the business judgment rule standard of review, rather than entire fairness (and so dismissed the case at the pleading stage). According to the court, the “side agreements” between the buyer and Martha Stewart did not cause the controller to be “conflicted” in the transaction as they essentially replicated the controller’s pre-merger arrangements with the company. Moreover, the court stated that the business judgment rule would have applied in any event, under MFW, because the transaction was subject to approval by a special committee and a majority of the minority stockholders. Previously, MFW has only been applied in transactions in which the controller was the buyer and the MFW-prescribed minority stockholder protections were in place before negotiations commenced between the buyer and the company. In the context of the controller being a seller, the court stated, it was sufficient that the minority stockholder protections were in place before negotiations commenced between the buyer and the controller about the controller’s separate arrangements. In the attached Briefing, we discuss the decision, the new standards it articulates, issues left open, and related practice points.
Additional information
This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.