Chancery Decision Highlights Need for a “Remedy Hierarchy” in a Post-Closing Purchase Price Adjustment Provision—WSP v. Versar
M&A/PE Briefing | July 9, 2026
In WSP USA Services, Inc. v. Vestar, Inc. (July 2, 206), the Delaware Court of Chancery, at the pleading stage, dismissed a seller’s claim that the buyer breached the parties’ Stock Purchase Agreement (the “SPA”) by treating a post-closing disagreement about allegedly undisclosed current liabilities as a purchase price adjustment dispute rather than a breach-of-representations dispute. The SPA provided for a post-closing purchase price adjustment based on net working capital adjustments; and the SPA required that the buyer obtain a representations-and-warranties (R&W) insurance policy, which would provide the sole post-closing remedy for breaches of representations. The court ruled that, based on the language of the SPA, which lacked a specific provision as to the “hierarchy” of the two post-closing remedies (purchase price adjustment versus R&W insurance recovery), the buyer was free to choose between the remedies.
Key Point
- The decision reinforces the need for careful drafting of post-closing purchase price adjustment and indemnification provisions. Where, as is typical, a purchase agreement (i) provides for a post-closing purchase price adjustment based on net working capital (or another metric), and (ii) requires that the seller indemnify the buyer for breaches of representations and warranties (or that the buyer obtain an R&W insurance policy to cover such breaches), the buyer may be entitled to elect between seeking recovery under (i) or (ii) if a post-closing dispute falls within the purview of both—unless the parties have specified in their agreement a “remedy hierarchy” stating that, in case of conflict between the two provisions, one would supersede the other. We note that these two remedies typically provide for different recoveries, particularly as indemnification usually is subject to caps and deductibles.
Background. In 2023, Versar (“Buyer”) acquired facility management company Louis Berger Services, Inc. (the “Company”) from WSP USA Services, Inc. (Seller”). Post-closing, Buyer alleged that the Company had not materially performed certain of its government contracts (the “Florida Contracts”). Seller had represented in the SPA that the Company had materially complied with and performed all of its government contracts. Under the post-closing purchase price adjustment process set forth in the SPA, Buyer proposed a purchase price adjustment of about $9.7 million, of which about $5.3 million was attributable to the alleged nonperformance of the Florida Contracts. Seller did not argue that liabilities associated with underperformance of the Florida Contracts were not current liabilities within the SPA’s definition of “Net Working Capital”—but Seller argued that the SPA prohibited Buyer from treating the dispute over the Florida Contracts as the basis for a purchase price adjustment. Seller argued that the proper source of recovery was through the R&W insurance, given the representation in the SPA covering compliance with government contracts. Seller brought suit, claiming that Buyer breached the SPA by submitting the dispute to the SPA’s independent arbiter process for Net Working Capital disputes. Chancellor Kathaleen St. J. McCormick ruled that Buyer was entitled to choose between seeking recovery under the purchase price adjustment or the R&W insurance policy.
Discussion
The court interpreted the SPA as contemplating the potential for disputes to implicate both methods of recovery and, in that case, intending that Buyer could choose between them. The court concluded that the SPA “contemplates a scenario in which a post-closing dispute implicates multiple potential paths of recovery and Buyer chooses one—either a purchase price adjustment or recovery under the representations-and-warranties insurance policy.” The court noted that the R&W policy, which was incorporated by reference into the SPA, stated that, to avoid double counting, any disputes that could warrant recovery under both a purchase price adjustment and the R&W policy could only qualify for recovery under one of them. The double-counting prohibition only would have been necessary to include in the insurance policy, the court stated, if the parties had contemplated that some losses might give rise to claims under both the insurance policy and the purchase price adjustment. The court held that, absent language in the agreement establishing a “hierarchy” between the two remedies when disputes fell within the purview of both, Buyer was entitled to choose between them.
We note that a purchase price adjustment and indemnification (or R&W insurance recovery) typically provide for different recoveries. Usually, different claims are covered; the timing for asserting the claims is different; the process for resolving the claims is different; and indemnification is subject to caps and deductibles that would not apply to a purchase price adjustment. Although not relevant in WSP, we note that, in previous cases, the court generally has been skeptical of buyer attempts to circumvent bargained-for limitations on indemnification by characterizing post-closing disputes as requiring a purchase price adjustment rather than indemnification (at least where the dispute seemed more like a breach-of-representations dispute and less like a balance sheet adjustment).
The court distinguished OSI Systems (which Seller cited) on the basis that the accounting issue in dispute in that case “necessarily implicated” breach of a representation. In OSI Systems v. Instrumentarium (2006), the court held that the buyer’s remedy was through its R&W insurance policy, not the purchase price adjustment set forth in the parties’ agreement. The buyer had made a purchase price adjustment after alleging that the seller’s original working capital statement was not prepared in compliance with GAAP while the seller had represented in the parties’ agreement that all financial statements had been prepared in compliance with GAAP. The court held that the “accounting issue” presented a representations-and-warranty dispute, not a purchase price adjustment dispute, because the issue necessarily implicated a breach of the representation that the financial statements had been prepared in compliance with GAAP. In WSP, the Chancellor wrote: “[In OSI,] it was impossible for the buyer to defend its purchase price adjustment without asserting that the seller breached a representation in the purchase agreement.”
By contrast, in WSP, the Chancellor stated, Seller had represented that the Company had materially complied with all government contracts, and nothing suggested that the liabilities arising under the Florida Contracts were necessarily coextensive with breach of a representation. Seller maintained that it had not breached the representation; and, the court observed, there were “myriad conceivable scenarios in which Seller did not breach any representation and yet there is still some liability under the Florida Contracts that would classify as a current liability under Net Working Capital.” In other words, Buyer’s making the Net Working Capital adjustment did not require that it argue at the same time that Seller breached any representation.
Further, the court noted in WSP that the case did not give rise to the concern in OSI that the buyer was seeking an “end-run” around limitations on liability in the agreement. Unlike OSI, in WSP there were “other provisions in the [SPA]”—namely, the R&W insurance policy that was incorporated by reference—that “contemplate[d] disputes that could properly arise as both purchase price adjustment disputes and representations-and-warranties disputes.” There could not be an “end-run,” the court wrote, as “pursuing recovery through a purchase price adjustment instead of the [R&W] insurance policy [was] contemplated in the agreement.”
The court viewed Alliant Techsystems (which Seller cited) as weighing in Buyer’s favor, as the parties’ agreement in that case included a remedy hierarchy provision. In Alliant Techsystems, Inc. v. MidOcean Bushnell Holdings, L.P. (2015), the purchase agreement had “a purchase price adjustment provision that stated that it was the ‘sole and exclusive’ remedy for purchase price disputes, and an indemnity provision that stated that it was the ‘sole and exclusive’ remedy for any claims concerning the transaction.” The parties agreed that their “accounting methodology” dispute fell under both provisions. However, the agreement contained a proviso stating that in case of conflict between the two provisions, the purchase price adjustment provision would supersede the indemnity provision. Based on the hierarchy proviso, the court held that the dispute had to proceed as a purchase price dispute. In WSP, the court noted that, by contrast, the SPA did not contain a hierarchy provision—which suggested that there was “no remedy hierarchy.” Without a remedy hierarchy, and with the SPA’s “plain terms contemplat[ing] Buyer choosing a purchase price adjustment over the representations-and-warranties insurance policy, it [was] unreasonable to conclude that Buyer breached the [SPA] by doing exactly that.”
We note two other recent Court of Chancery decisions that address similar issues—and further highlight the need to clarify the interrelationship between purchase price adjustment and indemnification provisions.
- Golden Rule. In Golden Rule Financial Corporation v. SRS Services LLC (2021), the court ruled (and the Delaware Supreme Court affirmed) that the buyer was entitled to recover under both the purchase price adjustment and the indemnification provision, as the purchase price adjustment payment itself was traceable to a breached representation. The agreement contained a standard “no-duplication” provision that barred recovering under the purchase price adjustment and then recovering, again, under the indemnification provision (i.e., it barred a “double” recovery). Double recovery was not the issue, however, the court stated, as, once the purchase price adjustment amount was resolved through litigation, the buyer then sought indemnification for breach of the seller’s representation that its financial statements had been prepared correctly in accordance with GAAP. That breach resulted in the buyer having to pay the purchase price adjustment (which it would not have had to pay if the seller had applied GAAP correctly, as it represented it had). The court rejected the seller’s argument that the buyer was trying to relitigate how GAAP should be applied for the purchase price adjustment. Rather, the court stated, the buyer was seeking indemnification for the seller’s breach of its pre-closing financial statement representation. The court noted that the indemnification provision defined “loss” broadly (including by not being limited to out-of-pocket costs and not excluding the expectancy harm that the buyer claimed) and that the purchase price adjustment provision did not state that it was the exclusive remedy.
- Northern Data. In Northern Data AG v. Riot Platforms, Inc.(2025), the court ruled that the buyer’s remedy was through the indemnification provision, not the purchase price adjustment, as the disputes “directly implicated” the seller’s representations and warranties in the parties’ agreement. The parties disputed (i) whether the company’s alleged pre-closing double-billing of a customer was properly included in accounts receivable, and (ii) whether an invoice for electricity, received pre-closing, had been paid and so should not have been included in accounts payable. The court found that (i) above directly implicated the seller’s representation that the accounts receivable in the company’s financial statements represented bona fide transactions and, to the seller’s knowledge, were current and collectible. The court found that (ii) above directly implicated the seller’s representation that it had provided a complete list of all indebtedness, including certain outstanding accounts payable, as of the date of the agreement. As the representations were “directly implicated,” and the agreement stated that indemnity was the sole and exclusive remedy for alleged breach of these representations, the court held that the buyer could pursue only an indemnification remedy (which was subject to a damages cap). The court noted that permitting the parties to characterize claims for breach of representations as purchase price adjustment “accounting disputes” would “render the indemnification cap meaningless and eviscerate the basic bargain between two sophisticated parties.”
Practice Points
- Drafters of purchase agreements should consider specifying a “remedy hierarchy” as between a purchase price adjustment and indemnification. Where a purchase agreement provides for (a) a purchase price adjustment based on net working capital (or other metric) and (b) indemnification (or recovery under R&W insurance) for breaches of representations, the drafters should consider specifying, with respect to disputes that implicate both, which remedy supersedes the other.
- Drafters should consider carefully how the purchase price adjustment provisions interrelate with the indemnification provisions. Typically, an agreement will: specify that indemnification is the exclusive remedy for breaches of the seller’s representations under the agreement; carve out purchase price adjustment amounts (as well as fraud and other specified matters) from the exclusive remedy provision; and prohibit double recoveries by excluding purchase price adjustments from indemnification claims. Many agreements provide that a purchase price adjustment is the sole remedy for net working capital inaccuracies and that indemnification is the sole remedy for breaches of representations and warranties—but, as noted, the agreement should specify which of these remedies takes precedence over the other when the dispute falls under both. For additional clarity, parties could consider providing specific, hypothetical examples of how they intend that specific situations would be treated where both a post-closing purchase price adjustment and indemnification could be implicated.
This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.