Skip to main content

CFTC Staff Provides Relief to Facilitate Use of Swaps in Credit Risk Transfer Transactions

Client memorandum | November 25, 2025

Authors: Nihal Patel (New York, NY)

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (“CFTC”) Market Participants Division (the “Staff”) granted no-action relief to the Structured Finance Association (“SFA”) that will facilitate the use of swaps in bank credit risk transfer (“CRT”) transactions. In letter 25-37,[1] the Staff granted relief from registration as a “commodity pool operator” (“CPO”) in the context of transactions designed to transfer the risk of certain assets on bank balance sheets through sales of credit-linked notes.

Background

CRT transactions are an increasingly common form of risk-sharing transaction engaged in by financial institutions, primarily with the aim of obtaining relief under relevant bank capital requirements.[2] The transactions are designed to transfer to third-party market participants the risk of particular assets (e.g., loans, mortgages) held on bank balance sheets. In a common form of transaction, this is accomplished by the bank establishing a special purpose vehicle (“SPV”) that raises capital by issuing credit-linked notes to investors.[3] In these transactions, the risk of the bank assets is transferred to the SPV via a credit-default swap or similar risk-sharing contact (generally referred to here as a “CDS”) between the bank and the SPV, pursuant to which the SPV provides protection to the bank against losses sustained on the assets (the “Reference Portfolio”). In turn, the notes issued by the SPV transfer the risk of the CDS to the note purchaser(s), as the notes are written down upon specified events related to the Reference Portfolio.

In many cases, the CDS between the bank and the SPV is a “swap” subject to CFTC regulation under Section 1a(47) of the Commodity Exchange Act (a “Swap”).[4] Once a Swap is present in the structure, the transaction participants must consider a number of potential issues arising under the Commodity Exchange Act (“CEA”). An SPV that issues securities to investors and enters into one or more Swaps must consider whether it is a “commodity pool” under CEA Section 1a(10) and whether the person that forms and operates the SPV is either a “commodity pool operator” under CEA Section 1a(11) or a “commodity trading adviser” under CEA Section 1a(12).[5] Under relevant CFTC rules and interpretations, a pooled investment vehicle engaging in even one CFTC-regulated transaction such as a Swap is considered a “commodity pool.”

Given the nature of the participants in CRT transactions, a requirement to register as a CPO is generally seen as overly burdensome. Registration as a CPO involves a number of ongoing regulatory obligations, including membership in the National Futures Association, and is accompanied by a number of duties owed by the registered CPO to the pool it manages. In limited circumstances, the Staff has granted no-action relief for participants in similar circumstances. Most notably, in letter 14-11, the Staff granted relief to the Federal Housing Finance Agency relating to CRT transactions engaged in by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.

The Relief

Pursuant to letter 25-37, the Staff granted no-action relief to permit reliance on CFTC Regulation 4.13(a)(3), sometimes referred to as the “de minimis” exemption from CPO registration. Under Reg. 4.13(a)(3), a person is not required to register as a CPO if, among other things, interests in the pool are exempt from registration under the Securities Act of 1933, the level of “commodity interest” activity (including Swaps) remains below specified thresholds, each investor is a “qualified eligible person” under CFTC Reg. 4.7(a),[6] and interests in the pool are not marketed as in a vehicle for trading commodity interests. The relief letter, in reliance on the request from SFA, assumes that all of the foregoing requirements except the “marketing” prong are “easily” met.[7] As a policy matter, the Staff reasoned that the CRT structures are “distinguishable” from more traditional commodity pools, given the absence of active management or trading strategies.

The relief from CPO registration provided in the letter applies to members of SFA that are “regulated financial institutions” and their affiliates “or any other person involved in setting up or operating” the SPVs in the CRT transactions described in the letter on behalf of such financial institutions. The relief is subject to a number of conditions, including that:

  • The conditions of Reg. 4.13(a)(3)(i)-(iii) are met (i.e., exemption from the Securities Act, limitations on commodity interest activity, and limitations on sales to “qualified eligible persons”).
  • The person relying on the relief files a notice of eligibility for the Reg. 4.13(a)(3) exemption with the National Futures Association (pursuant to Reg. 4.13(b)) and meets the other terms of Reg. 4.13 with respect to each SPV (or series/cell, if applicable) utilized in CRT transactions.
  • The SPV only engages in one commodity interest transaction – i.e., the CDS with the bank that transfers the risk of the reference portfolio assets.
  • Assets purchased by the SPV are limited to certain “highly liquid” assets,[8] payment obligations of the SPV to the bank are secured by such assets, and the assets are subject to arrangements that protect the bank in the event the SPV becomes subject to an insolvency proceeding. (The letter provides a number of details on the methods by which the last aspect can be accomplished.)[9]

Considerations and Next Steps

The relief is a welcome development for banks engaging in CRT transactions. It eliminates a potential pitfall for participants that has existed for years, despite the limited policy justifications for subjecting the CRT market to the the protections that CPO regulation is designed to provide. Among other things, CRTs are generally only offered by very large and highly regulated financial institutions and only sold in private offerings to large, sophisticated institutional investors. Further, the transactions are subject to a number of other significant financial regulatory laws, including relevant banking requirements and the federal securities laws.

Market participants engaged in CRTs should promptly review their CRT structures and consider whether to adjust those structures in order to take advantage of the relief provided in letter 25-37. Firms relying on the relief will also need to consider issues relating to the relevant NFA filings, including (i) which entity will make the filings / is relying on the relief; (ii) whether any filings may be required or advisable in respect of existing CRTs; and (iii) setting up a process for timely making filings for each relevant CRT transaction as they occur going forward.



[1]      The letter from the SFA requesting relief from the CFTC is available here.

[2]      CRTs are specifically identified in the capital rules of many prudential banking regulators, including Regulation Q of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. See, e.g., 12 C.F.R. 217.2 and 217.41.

[4]      This is not always the case. Given joint jurisdiction over swaps between the SEC and the CFTC, depending on the nature of the CDS, it may be designed as a “security-based swap” subject to SEC regulation or as a Swap subject to CFTC regulation. However, the letter is only relevant as to CFTC-regulated Swaps and this memorandum does not address potential issues arising under the federal securities laws if the SPV-bank swap is a “security-based swap.” In a nutshell, a bank establishing an SPV that will only enter into SEC-regulated “security-based swaps” must consider the status of the SPV as an “investment company” under the Investment Company Act of 1940, as amended, and the status of a person operating the SPV as an “investment adviser” under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, as amended.

[5]      While the letter does not address the status of a person operating the SPV as a “commodity trading adviser,” it is notable that CFTC Reg. 4.14(a)(5) deems an exempt CPO to be an exempt CTA for the same product and the letter from the SFA requesting this relief expressly contemplates some discretion in the form of permitted substitutions of reference assets.

[6]      This includes a person that is an “accredit investor” under the Securities Act meeting an additional portfolio requirement, as well as certain non-U.S. persons as defined under relevant CFTC rules.

[7]      As noted in the letter, the quantitative limitations in Reg. 4.13(a)(3) require that (i) margins, premiums, deposits, and the like to establish the CDS do not exceed 5% of the liquidation value of the pool’s portfolio after taking into account unrealized profits and losses; or (ii) aggregate notional amount of the CDS at time of establishment does not exceed 100% of the liquidation value of the pool’s portfolio after taking into account unrealized profits and losses. It would generally be expected that SPVs in CRT transactions would rely on prong two of the test.

[8]      The letter makes reference to CFTC Reg. 1.25(b)(1) for the definition of “highly liquid” and requires that the assets mature before the CDS termination or are convertible to cash upon demand.

[9]      Among other things, the SPV must be limited in its activities to transactions relating to the CRT and cannot engage in “commodity interest” transactions beyond the CDS, must have particular governance arrangements in place, observe relevant corporate formalities, and have traditional “non-petition” language in its contracts.


This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.