Skip to main content

CFTC Proposes Significant Amendments to Exemptions for Commodity Pool Operators and Commodity Trading Advisors Under Regulation 4.7

Client memorandum | October 12, 2023

Authors: William J. Breslin, Dorothy Mehta, David S. Mitchell, Josh Xiong

Summary

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (the “Commission” or “CFTC”) has proposed significant amendments to CFTC Regulation 4.7 (“Rule 4.7” or “4.7”), a rule that provides broad exemptive relief from the Part 4 disclosure, reporting, and recordkeeping requirements for registered commodity pool operators (“CPOs”) and commodity trading advisors (“CTAs”) in connection with pools and separate accounts that are offered exclusively to certain categories of “highly accredited” persons referred to as “Qualified Eligible Persons” (“QEPs”), as defined thereunder.[1] The proposed amendments would narrow the scope of the relief provided under Rule 4.7, which has been in effect since 1992, including the following changes:

  • Increasing the Portfolio Requirement for Certain QEPs. Rule 4.7 requires certain categories of persons to satisfy specified monetary thresholds (the “Portfolio Requirement”) in order to be treated as QEPs. The monetary thresholds are (i) owning at least $2,000,000 of securities and other investments; (ii) having on deposit with a futures commission merchant at least $200,000 in initial margin and options premiums; or (iii) meeting a composite of (i) and (ii), such that the percentage of portfolio investments and initial margin or options premiums relative to their respective thresholds equals at least 100%. To account for the effects of inflation, the proposed amendments would double the Portfolio Requirement thresholds, i.e., would increase the securities and investments threshold in (i) to $4,000,000 and the initial margin and options premium threshold in (ii) to $400,000. The proposed amendments, however, would not require existing participants in 4.7 pools or clients in 4.7 accounts to be re-qualified as QEPs, except perhaps in the event that they wish to make additional investments in such a vehicle.
  • Imposing Minimum Disclosure Requirements for 4.7 CPOs and CTAs. The proposed amendments would require CPOs to include in a 4.7 pool’s offering memorandum descriptions of the pool’s principal risk factors, investment program, use of proceeds, custodians, fees and expenses, and conflicts of interest with the details as set forth under CFTC rules, as well as certain performance information, including a break-even table, calculated pursuant to CFTC rules. Similarly, under the proposed amendments, CTAs would be required to provide written disclosure to their prospective QEP clients, including a description of their principals, descriptions of the trading program and the principal risk factors of the investment, fees, and conflicts of interest with the details as set forth under CFTC rules, as well as certain performance information calculated pursuant to CFTC rules. CPOs and CTAs would be required to maintain such disclosures (“QEP Disclosures”) among the books and records of the respective 4.7 pool or trading program, keep such QEP Disclosures up-to-date to reflect any changes to the pool or trading program, and make such QEP Disclosures available to the CFTC, National Futures Association (“NFA”), and the Justice Department for examination.
  • Codifying Exemptive Relief for 4.7 Fund-of-Funds CPOs. Under the proposed amendments, CPOs of Rule 4.7 fund-of-funds would be permitted to provide monthly account statements to pool participants within 45 days after month end, instead of the existing 4.7(b)(3) requirement to provide quarterly account statements within 30 days after quarter end. This change would codify the exemptive relief that the CFTC staff has routinely granted to CPOs of Rule 4.7 fund-of-funds because these CPOs typically cannot control when they receive financial information from the underlying investee funds and therefore often have difficulty complying with the 30-day distribution timing requirement in the rule. This proposed amendment, if adopted, would be self-effectuating for CPOs of 4.7 fund-of-funds.

Discussion/Analysis

In the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking and the related Fact Sheet and Q&A, the Commission noted that many aspects of Rule 4.7 have not been updated since its adoption and that it is proposing to update and modernize the requirements to reflect developments in the derivatives markets over the last 30 years. Among others, the CFTC noted that the number of CPOs and CTAs that rely on Rule 4.7 in comparison to those that do not has grown dramatically in recent years. Moreover, it appears that the Commission believes that minimum disclosure requirements for QEPs are necessary in view of the significant expansion and growth in the complexity and diversity of commodity interest products, most notably swaps and digital assets, as well as to address the perceived unequal bargaining power of certain categories of QEPs.

Most will agree that increasing the monetary thresholds in the Portfolio Requirement in the QEP definition in Rule 4.7(a) to account for inflation is acceptable. Similarly, it is appropriate to codify relief for CPOs of funds-of-funds relying on Rule 4.7 to elect an alternative account statement schedule that is consistent with exemptive letters routinely issued by the CFTC staff. However, as noted by Commissioner Mersinger in her Dissenting Statement, the Commission has not offered an adequate justification for imposing minimum disclosure requirements for QEPs.[2] For example, while reference is made to the development of digital assets, the Commission has disregarded the disclosure and reporting requirements for virtual currencies, including virtual currency derivatives,[3] already required by NFA of CPOs and CTAs, including those relying on Rule 4.7.

It is likely that, among the most significant issues for CPOs of Rule 4.7 pools, is the proposed requirement to include in the pool’s offering memorandum a break-even table and performance of the pool calculated pursuant to CFTC rules. Similarly, CTAs relying on Rule 4.7 would be required to disclose performance information related to their trading programs calculated pursuant to CFTC rules. In this regard, while concurring on issuing the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking, Commissioner Pham expressed concern that the proposed changes for CPOs and CTAs offering to or advising QEPs would “impose overly broad obligations that would be burdensome and unnecessary for sophisticated clients and would present operational challenges and costs without a persuasive cost-benefit analysis under the Commodity Exchange Act.”[4] The proposed amendments would require that these Rule 4.7 offering memoranda and disclosure documents be updated at least every 12 months. Such disclosure also would have to be updated as necessary to reflect any material changes; disclosures to QEPs are already required to not be misleading under Rule 4.7. However, the Commission is not proposing to require that QEP disclosure for 4.7 pools or trading programs be reviewed or approved by the CFTC or NFA prior to their first use.

Conclusion

If enacted, the proposed amendments to Rule 4.7 would have a significant impact on 4.7 CPOs and CTAs. The Commission is requesting comments on all aspects of the proposed amendments. Comments will be due by December 11, 2023.

We will continue to monitor and report on developments in this rulemaking proceeding.



[1] See 88 Fed. Reg. 70852 (Oct. 12, 2023).

[2] See Commissioner Mersinger’s Dissenting Statement at 88 Fed. Reg. 70852 at 70881 – 70884.

[3] See, e.g., Interpretive Notice 9073 (Disclosure Requirements for NFA Members Engaging in Virtual Currency Activities) (the “Interpretive Notice”) . See our prior Memorandum on the Interpretive Notice for a more in-depth discussion. 

[4] See Commissioner Pham’s Concurring Statement at 88 Fed. Reg. 70852 at 70884.


This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.