Skip to main content

International Trade and Investment Alert™ | August 3, 2023

Authors: Michael T. Gershberg, Gregory Bernstein

The Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States ("CFIUS") recently delivered its unclassified Annual Report to Congress for the calendar year 2022 (“Annual Report”). CFIUS continued to be very busy, as reflected in the high number of notices and declarations filed, as well as its monitoring of non-notified transactions and signing and enforcement of mitigation agreements. The number of CFIUS filings in 2022 again reached an all-time high. The number of notices that were withdrawn and refiled also reached an all-time high and CFIUS was responsible for scuttling 12 deals in 2022—a 25% increase from the previous year. The timing of the CFIUS process also became a little more unpredictable in 2022 with increases in both the percentage of notices proceeding to investigation and the percentage of declarations that required a subsequent notice filing.

As in previous years, the Annual Report summarizes CFIUS’s activities during the covered period, including the number and disposition of CFIUS filings, the nature and prevalence of mitigation arrangements, and the geographic source and sector concentration of covered transactions. In addition, the Annual Report describes its 2022 calendar year activities in comparative and cumulative perspective for the years 2013 to 2022. In accordance with the legal prohibition against public disclosure of such information, the Annual Report contains no information with respect to specific transactions. Nonetheless, it remains a remarkable window into the reach and operation of CFIUS and its impact on transactions involving U.S. businesses.

We have set forth below a brief summary of the key data points of the Annual Report, along with a discussion of emerging trends in the CFIUS review process.

A. Notices Filed and Country of Origin

Consistent with anecdotal reports, CFIUS continued to be very active. In 2022, 286 CFIUS notices were filed and determined to describe “covered transactions” or “covered real estate transactions,” two types of transactions within CFIUS’s regulatory purview. This is a slight increase from the 272 notices that CFIUS reviewed in 2021. While the number of notices filed rose slightly, the number of declarations filed declined slightly to 154 (from 164).  Therefore, the combined total of 440 filings was consistent with the previous year, when a total of 436 filings were made.

Transaction notices were filed from 52 different countries in 2022. Singapore was the largest filer, which is a notable change from previous years.  The following countries accounted for the greatest number of notices:

Country

Number of Notices

Singapore

37

China

36

United Kingdom

18

Canada

17

Japan

15

France, South Korea

14

CFIUS activity involving Chinese acquirers fell from a four-year high of 44 notices filed in 2021. The general trend of fewer notices filed by Chinese acquirers in recent years is likely a product of the perceived hostile CFIUS environment and particularly strict scrutiny by CFIUS of inbound Chinese investment, including high-profile decisions by the President over the past few years to block transactions involving Chinese acquirers.  However, China was still the second-largest source of notices filed in 2022, suggesting that inbound deal-making is still active, perhaps with somewhat less-sensitive transactions. The most notable change from 2021 was the nearly tripling of notices filed by Singaporean acquirers, which rose from 13 in 2021 to 37 in 2022, more than the number of notices from acquirers in any other single country.

The number of notices filed by Russian acquirers dropped from seven in 2021 to only 1 in 2022, likely as a result of new restrictive measures imposed by the United States and its allies in response to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. For countries with at least ten notices, there was an even split between those that saw an increase in the number of notices filed in 2021 (France, Singapore, South Korea, and the United Kingdom) and those that saw a decrease in the number of notices filed in 2021 (Canada, the Cayman Islands, China, and Japan). There was also a modest decrease in the number of notices filed from Israel, which dropped from 12 in 2021 to nine in 2021.    The number of notices filed by Cayman Island acquirers declined from 18 in 2021 to only ten in 2022 (although both figures are up from only five filings in 2020). This change is likely attributable to change in the level of investment activity by private funds for which either the ultimate beneficial owner is Cayman or the principal place of business is considered to be the Cayman Islands.

B. Declarations Filed and Country of Origin

Beginning on February 13, 2020, pursuant to regulations implementing the Foreign Investment Risk Review Modernization Act of 2018 (“FIRRMA”), parties to a covered transaction could make a mandatory or voluntary CFIUS filing via short-form declaration instead of a full notice.

In 2022, CFIUS completed assessments of 154 declarations filed for covered transactions, including five real estate declarations. CFIUS is required either to clear the transaction, initiate a unilateral review, request that the parties file a written notice, or inform the parties that CFIUS cannot conclude its review of the transaction based on the information provided in the declarations. CFIUS may also reject an incomplete or improper declaration. CFIUS resolved the declarations submitted in 2021 as follows:

CFIUS Action

Number of Declarations

Request that the parties file a written notice

50

Inform the parties that CFIUS cannot conclude action

14

Initiate a unilateral review

0

Clear the transaction

90

Reject the declaration

0

Fewer than 60% of declarations were cleared outright, which is a significant decrease from 2021, when nearly two thirds of declarations were cleared outright. While parties have more experience at determining when a declaration may be the more expedient option, the decline in clearance rate is a  reminder that filing a declaration is far from a guarantee of an expedited process.  In fact, CFIUS requested a written notice after approximately one-third of all declarations in 2022.  This fact indicates that declarations may be the preferable option for only a limited set of lower-risk transactions.

Acquirers from 38 countries filed declarations in 2022, up slightly from 35 countries in 2021. The following countries accounted for the greatest number of declarations:

Country

Number of 2022 Declarations

Canada

22

Japan

18

Germany

13

South Korea

11

Singapore

9

The foregoing list is unchanged from 2021. Over the past three years, Canada (62 declarations) was responsible for the largest number of declarations, followed closely by Japan (47 declarations) and Germany (34 declarations). Together, these three countries accounted for approximately a third of all declarations filed in the last three years. The United Kingdom and South Korea round out the top five filers during the same time period.  This list is not surprising as these countries are either excepted foreign states or close U.S. allies with many repeat CFIUS filers.

Combining notices and declarations, Singapore became the largest CFIUS filer in 2022, with 46 total filings. China was second with 41 total filings, and Canada, which was the largest CFIUS filer in 2021 and 2020, was third with 39 filings.  The following countries accounted for the greatest number of combined CFIUS filings in 2022:

Country

Total 2022 Filings

Singapore

46

China

41

Canada

39

Japan

33

United Kingdom

26

South Korea

25

C. Investigations and Presidential Review

In 2022, 57% (162) of the 286 notices went into the 45-day investigation phase, following the 45-day review phase. This is increase from the previous three years when 48%, 47%, and 49% of notices, respectively, went into the investigation phase. The clearance rate during the review period, while the lowest it has been since the August 13, 2018 effective date of FIRRMA, remains higher than it was before FIRRMA took effect.  In 2017, prior to the implementation of FIRRMA, which extended the statutory review period from 30 to 45 days, 73% of notices proceeded to the investigation phase. Similarly, 76% of notices filed in 2018 before FIRRMA’s effective date proceeded to investigation.  In other words, while FIRRMA’s new timeline has helped expedite approvals overall, it is notable that with CFIUS’s workload and increasingly complex transactions and national security analyses, more than half of all notices can be expected to last the full 90 days.

In 2021, for the second year in a row, CFIUS did not refer any transactions to the President. From 2016 through 2020, CFIUS referred a single transaction to the President each year, with the President deciding to block each transaction. In three cases, the ultimate owners of the acquiring company were Chinese acquirers, and in another case (Qualcomm’s proposed acquisition of Broadcom), the national security risk was largely from Chinese competition in the 5G telecommunications sector.

D. Withdrawn Notices

The number of withdrawn notices increased for the second year in a row. In 2022, 88 notices were withdrawn, including 87 of the 162 notices (54%) that proceeded to the investigation phase. By contrast, in 2021 only 72 notices were withdrawn after the commencement of an investigation and in 2020 and 2019, only 28 and 30 notices were withdrawn after the investigation phase began. For the second year in a row, as well as only the second time in the past ten years, a majority of notices proceeding to the investigation phase were withdrawn.  This is a key statistic for deal timing.  The number of withdrawn and refiled notices remained high at 68, compared with 63 in 2021.  The main reason to withdraw and refile a notice is to obtain additional time for CFIUS to complete its review or for the parties to reach agreement on mitigation measures. It is possible that the factors responsible in part for the increase in withdrawn notices include the level of Chinese inbound investment, CFIUS’s overall workload, and the number and complexity of mitigation agreements.

The number of abandoned transactions in 2022 nearly doubled to 20, compared with 11 in 2021, 8 in 2020, and 12 in 2019.  In 12 instances, the parties withdrew the notice and abandoned the transaction after CFIUS could not identify mitigation measures to resolve the national security concerns or parties chose not to accept the proposed mitigation measures. In eight instances, parties abandoned the transactions for commercial reasons. Both of these figures are higher than in previous years, with the number of scuttled deals increasing from nine in 2021 and seven in 2020. Notably, in three instances, CFIUS adopted mitigation measures to address residual national security concerns involving transactions and notices that were voluntarily withdrawn and abandoned. Separately, in five instances, the U.S. Department of the Treasury imposed conditions in connection with granting the withdrawal and abandonment of notices. These conditions were not, however, considered to be mitigation measures.

E. Mitigation Measures

In 2022, 52 (or 18%) of notices were approved by CFIUS subject to the imposition of mitigation measures and conditions. This is a substantially higher rate than in 2021 (11%) or 2020 (9%).

Pursuant to these mitigation arrangements, parties were required to take one or more of the following actions. None of these measures were new in 2022.

  • Prohibiting or limiting the transfer or sharing of certain intellectual property, trade secrets, or technical information;
  • Ensuring that only authorized persons have access to certain technology and information;
  • Establishing a corporate security committee, voting trust, or other mechanisms to ensure compliance with all required actions, including the appointment of a U.S. Government (“USG”) approved security officer or member of the board of directors and requirements for security policies, annual reports, and independent audits;
  • Establishing guidelines and terms for handling existing or future USG contracts, USG customer information, and other sensitive information;
  • Ensuring that only U.S. citizens handle certain products and services, and ensuring that certain activities, products, facilities, equipment, and operations are located only in the U.S.;
  • Requiring prior notification to and non-objection by the U.S. Government regarding changes to data storage locations;
  • Restricting recruitment and hiring of certain personnel;
  • Assurances of continuity of supply for defined periods, and notification and consultation prior to taking certain business decisions, with the USG reserving certain rights in the event that the company decides to exit a business line;
  • establishing meetings to discuss business plans that might affect USG supply or national security considerations;
  • Notifying, for approval, security officers, third party monitors, or relevant USG parties in advance of foreign national visits to the U.S. business;
  • Notifying customers or relevant USG parties regarding a change in ownership;
  • Security protocols to ensure the integrity of goods or software sold to the USG;
  • Exclusion of certain sensitive assets from the transaction;
  • Establishing meetings to discuss business plans that might affect U.S. Government supply or raise national security considerations;
  • Ensuring that only authorized vendors supply certain products or services;
  • Prior notification to and approval by relevant USG parties in connection with any increase in ownership or rights by the foreign acquirer; and
  • Divestiture of all or part of the U.S. business.

CFIUS member agencies also have various procedures to monitor compliance with the mitigation arrangements that companies are subject to, including:

  • Periodic reporting to USG agencies by the companies;
  • On-site compliance reviews by USG agencies;
  • Third-party audits when required by the terms of the mitigation measures; and
  • Investigations and remedial actions if anomalies or breaches are discovered or suspected, including the imposition of penalties or unilateral initiation of another review of the covered transaction.

F. Industry Sectors

As in previous years, notices were filed in connection with transactions in a wide variety of sectors, with the bulk of transactions in the Finance, Information, and Services sector and the Manufacturing sector. The notices filed in 2022 were divided among four industry sectors as follows:

Sector

Share of 2022 Notices

Finance, Information, and Services

52%

Manufacturing

29%

Mining, Utilities, and Construction

13%

Wholesale Trade, Retail Trade, and Transportation

6%

For the fourth time in the last five years, the Finance, Information, and Services sector was the sector with the most notices. For the second year in a row an outright majority of notices filed were from that sector. The share of notices in the Manufacturing sector, which accounted for the plurality of filings until 2016, held steady from 2021 when it was at 28%, the lowest share of notices in the Manufacturing sector in the last decade. The increase in the percentage of notices that fall within the Finance, Information, and Services sector suggests that an acquired company’s access to sensitive personal data is an increasingly important factor when parties are deciding whether to file with CFIUS.  It may also reflect a general trend of increased deal-making in technology and service sectors.

The Manufacturing subsector with the most notices was again Computer and Electronic Product Manufacturing, at 37% of the notices in the Manufacturing sector. Transportation Equipment Manufacturing (17%), Fabricated Metal Product Manufacturing (14%), and Machinery Manufacturing (12%)  were other large subsectors of notices, with Fabricated Metal Product Manufacturing seeing the largest increase of any subsector from 2021, when it accounted for only 4% of all Manufacturing sector notices. The Finance, Information, and Services subsector with the most notices was again Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services at 39%. Other subsectors with a large number of notices include Telecommunications (15%) and Publishing Industries (13%). The Mining, Utilities, and Construction sector was dominated by the Utilities subsector at 67%, although that represented a decreased share from 2021, when Utilities accounted for 94% of all Mining, Utilities, and Construction sector notices.The largest Wholesale Trade, Retail Trade, and Transportation subsector was Support Activities for Transportation (44%) and the second largest was Merchant Wholesalers, Durable Goods (33%).

The chart below shows the sectoral distribution of 2022 declarations. It is comparable to the distribution of notices, except that Finance, Information, and Services transactions are slightly more likely to involve a notice and some Trade and Transportation transactions are more likely to be filed by declaration.

Sector

Share of 2022 Declarations

Finance, Information, and Services

42%

Manufacturing

30%

Mining, Utilities, and Construction

17%

Wholesale Trade, Retail Trade, and Transportation

11%

G. Non-Notified Transactions

The CFIUS Monitoring & Enforcement team was formally created post-FIRRMA and given resources to monitor non-notified transactions and enforce violations of CFIUS rules and agreements.  In 2022, CFIUS identified and considered 84 transactions that were not notified to CFIUS. CFIUS became aware of these transactions through interagency referrals, tips from the public, media reports, commercial databases, and congressional notifications. Of the 135 transactions, CFIUS requested that parties file notices for 11 transactions. This is an increase from 2021, when CFIUS identified 135 non-notified transactions but only requested a filing for eight of them.  Accordingly, CFIUS remains active in monitoring for non-notified transactions.  It is almost finished reviewing a backlog of pre-FIRRMA transactions and has begun shifting its attention more toward current deals.

H. Critical Technologies

In 2022, CFIUS found that 181 cases involved acquisitions of U.S. critical technology companies, with acquirers from 41 countries and territories. The countries with the highest number of notices regarding critical technology were as follows:

Country

Number of Acquisitions

Japan

16

France

14

Canada

13

United Kingdom

13

South Korea

12

Most cases involved activities in the Machinery Manufacturing (84 transactions), Telecommunications (36 transactions), and Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services (34 transactions)  sectors, a change from 2021 when the Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services sector accounted for the largest number of critical technology transactions.

As discussed in previous reports, the Annual Report noted that foreign governments are “extremely likely to use a range of collection methods to obtain critical U.S. technologies.” As in previous years, the Annual Report also noted that foreign intelligence agencies represent the most “persistent and pervasive cyber intelligence threat tied to economic espionage and the potential theft of U.S. trade secrets and proprietary information.”


This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.