Skip to main content

Appraisal Decision Deducts Certain Merger Synergies from a Financial Buyer’s Deal Price and Establishes There is No Right to a Refund on Prepayments–Panera

Client memorandum | February 18, 2020

Panera is notable for being one of the few appraisal cases in which the court has actually made a deduction to exclude from appraised fair value the value of expected merger synergies. The decision offers  guidance as to the type of synergies that may be deducted and the type of evidence that will substantiate a deduction. Also, the court, for the first time, affirmed that a buyer that has pre-paid an amount that turns out to be higher than the court’s ultimate fair value determination is not entitled to a refund. The decision thus underscores that, as part of any prepayment, the buyer should negotiate with the appraisal petitioners a contractual claw-back right. The decision also serves as a reminder that, notwithstanding the decline in appraisal risk over the past couple of years, appraisal claims may still be made when there are perceived flaws in the sale process. At the same time, the decision highlights the risk to appraisal petitioners of an at-or-below-the-deal-price result—which has significantly discouraged the filing of appraisal claims in the context of arm’s-length third party mergers without seriously flawed sale processes.

Additional information

icon View File

This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.