Skip to main content

A Biometric Law’s “Absurd,” “Annihilative Liability” Following the Illinois Supreme Court’s Decisions in Tims and Cothron

Client memorandum | March 1, 2023

Authors: Amir R. Ghavi, Michael A. Kleinman, and Katelyn E. James  

Earlier this month, the Illinois Supreme Court issued long-awaited decisions that will have a major impact on current and future lawsuits alleging violations of the Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act (“BIPA”).[1]  Following those decisions, two things are now clear: (1) all claims arising under BIPA have a five-year statute of limitations and (2) each instance of repeated collection and disclosure of biometric information or identifiers (“biometrics”)[2] can give rise to a separate violation of the act and corresponding fines.

As a reminder, BIPA requires businesses that collect, capture, disclose or disseminate biometrics to take certain steps to safeguard and protect such information.[3]  Violations give rise to a private cause of action (meaning individuals can sue, not just an attorney general) and can lead to damages of up to $5,000 per violation.

Taken together, Tims and Cothron significantly expand, by several orders of magnitude, the number of potential claims and the amount of potential damages under BIPA, threatening “annihilative liability,” in the words of the Cothron dissent.  Although there has been only one BIPA case that has reached a jury verdict, companies that collect biometrics from Illinois residents should prepare for a deluge of putative consumer and employment class action cases accompanied by dramatically increased settlement demands by plaintiffs’ attorneys.  Below we illustrate the potential monetary impact of Tims and Cothron using a hypothetical BIPA violation and offer some compliance and governance recommendations for consideration in light of the Illinois Supreme Court’s decisions.

Five-Year Statute of Limitations.  In Tims, the Court held that the statute of limitations for all BIPA claims is five years, rather than one year, for violations of Sections 15(c) and (d).  While acknowledging that (as Black Horse contended) a one-year statute of limitations plausibly could have applied to Sections 15(c) and (d) claims, the Court reasoned that BIPA’s legislative intent—specifically, concerns about the supposedly unknown increased risk of harm associated with the collection of biometrics back in 2008—tipped the balance in favor of the five-year statute.

Multiple Claim Accrual.  In Cothron, the Court held that a separate claim accrues each time an individual’s biometric is scanned or disclosed in violation of BIPA, rather than accruing the first time the biometric is collected, captured or disclosed.  Moreover, the Court’s decision can be read to mean that failure to obtain consent for the collection (required by Section 15(b)) and transfer to a third party (required by Section 15(d)) can give rise to two violations.  White Castle estimated that the damages awardable to its 9,000 current and former class of employees would be between $19 million and $95 million if the Plaintiff could recover under both Sections 15(b) and (d), and under one violation per employee, damages could equal close to $9.5 million.

In response, the majority found that BIPA’s language was clear and therefore must be given effect even though the consequences may be “harsh,” “unjust” or “absurd.” Aside from noting that damages were made discretionary rather than mandatory under BIPA, meaning that a court has equitable discretion to fashion an award that deters future violations without destroying a defendant’s business, the Court left any policy-based concerns about excessive damages to the Illinois legislature to decide.  Businesses should not rely on such relief coming any time soon.  Over the last few years, there have been numerous bills introduced in the Illinois legislature that have attempted to curtail BIPA’s reach.  These proposals have focused on, among other things, providing a notice to cure period for violations of BIPA, limiting the damages available to actual damages suffered (rather than liquidated damages) and including an exemption to allow for the collection of biometrics for a security purpose.  Although all have stalled or failed thus far, Illinois legislators continue to frequently introduce new proposals to narrow the law.

Until and unless any such bills are passed, the potential impact of Cothron and Tims on BIPA damages is staggering.  In October, we wrote about Rogers v. BNSF Railway Co., No. 19-cv-03083, where a jury awarded $228 million to a class of approximately 45,600 truck drivers (i.e., liquidated damages of $5,000 per driver) whose fingerprint scans were transmitted to a third-party vendor purportedly without their written consent over a five-year period.  The jury determined that BNSF violated the law 45,600 times—i.e., one time per driver.[4]  For illustrative purposes, under Cothron and assuming that (i) each truck driver scanned into the railway yard once per work day (using the American daily average of 260 work days per year) over a five-year period and (ii) a reference image of each driver’s fingerprint was transmitted to BNSF’s third-party vendor each time a fingerprint was scanned, counting each scan and disclosure to BNSF’s vendor as a separate violation, potential damages would have increased from $228 million to more than $592 billion.

Searching for a silver lining, legal and compliance departments should use Rogers, Cothron and Tims to seek “business” buy-in for a review of, and investment in, their company’s biometrics compliance program.  In particular, companies that collect or use biometrics from Illinois residents should consider the following action items:

  • Update notice and consent forms.  Reviewing and updating BIPA notices and consent forms to make clear that notice and consent applies to the first and future collections and disclosures of biometrics.  The Court in Cothron did not have an occasion to address whether fresh notice and consent is also required each time a biometric is collected or disclosed, or if notice and consent at initial collection and disclosure is sufficient.  However, in an earlier decision in Cothron, the United States District Court of Illinois stated in dicta that White Castle could have satisfied BIPA by providing employees with a consent form that would have been sufficient to cover “all future scans” of their fingerprints.  This remains an open issue, and Senate Bill 1506, introduced earlier this month, seeks to clear up any ambiguity by proposing an amendment to BIPA specifying that notice and consent should only be required upon the first collection or capture.  In addition, companies should consider providing renewed notice and getting additional consent when a new biometric vendor is onboarded.
  • Preserve records.  Preserving records of BIPA notices, retention and destruction policies and proof of consent for a period of time commensurate with the five-year statute of limitations.
  • Negotiate vendor contracts.  Carefully reviewing and negotiating contracts with biometric vendors to seek clear and favorable allocations of compliance responsibility and business-friendly indemnity terms in the event of a BIPA violation.
  • Assess potential exposure.  Assessing potential exposure from past collection and disclosure practices and the availability of claims-made and occurrence-based Employment Practices Liability and Cyber insurance policies, noting in particular exclusions for liquidated damages, wrongful employment practices and wrongful data collection.
  • Revisit use of biometrics.  Weighing the benefits of biometrics to the business, potentially applicable exemptions under BIPA and the resources available to ensure compliance with BIPA’s retention, destruction and security requirements and considering the availability of alternative authentication and access measures that do not involve the collection and disclosure of biometrics.
  • Evaluate compliance with other biometrics laws.  Evaluating applicability of and compliance with biometrics privacy laws in international, federal, state and even local jurisdictions.  While laws in jurisdictions such as Texas, Washington, New York City and Portland, Oregon[5] directly regulate collection and disclosure of biometrics, many comprehensive privacy laws, such as the EU and UK General Data Protection Regulation, the California Consumer Privacy Act and Virginia’s Consumer Data Protection Act, also include provisions requiring heightened protections of such information.

[1] See Cothron v. White Castle System, Inc., 2023 IL 128004 and Tims v. Black Horse Carriers, Inc., 2023 IL 127801.

[2] “Biometric identifier” is defined as “a retina or iris scan, fingerprint, voiceprint, scan of hand or face geometry.” “Biometric information” is defined as “any information, regardless of how it is captured, converted, stored or shared, based on an individual’s biometric identifier used to identify an individual.”

[3] Section 15(a) requires businesses in possession of biometrics to develop and make available a written policy that sets forth a retention schedule and destruction procedures; Section 15(b) requires informed consent before a business may “collect, capture, purchase, receive through trade, or otherwise obtain” biometrics; Section 15(c) prohibits the sale, lease, trade or profit from a person or customer’s biometrics; Section 15(d) requires notice and consent before a business may “disclose, redisclose, or otherwise disseminate” biometrics; and Section 15(e) requires a business to use a “reasonable standard of care within [its] industry” with respect to the storage, transmission and protection of biometrics.  The precise meaning of each of Section 15’s requirements and prohibitions has been, and will continue to be, subject to judicial interpretation.

[4] Notably, following Cothron, BNSF filed a notice of supplemental authority with the court in support of its motion for a new trial, seeking reduction of the $5,000 per driver jury verdict on the basis that, under Cothron, such damages were discretionary, and not mandatory.

[5] In 2021, Portland became the first jurisdiction in the United States to prohibit the use of facial recognition technology by private entities and city agencies (subject to certain exemptions) in places of public accommodation.


This communication is for general information only. It is not intended, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice. In some jurisdictions, this may be considered attorney advertising. Please refer to the firm’s data policy page for further information.